Argentina isn’t going to drive global change via monetary brute force. Instead, it’s going to be an ideological example that the rest of the world can watch unfold successfully.
we saw a trial run in 2015/2016 with the presidential election in Austria going to an outsider (although subsequently overturned in the courts there), then Brexit then Trump. the entrenched elite fought back hard to regain their power, hence the turmoil in 2020 and the subsequent acceleration of every asinine idea from the left like men can be women and global boiling as well as the push to allow the WHO to make all global decisions in the next pandemic. But I agree, this is a noteworthy outcome and presages many elections in the next 18 months, obviously including ours in the US. I expect that the left has pushed too far and they are going to be routed all around the world. do not be surprised if AfD in Germany comes into power without a coalition in the 3 German states that have elections next year. people are fed up with the bullshit.
I agree it is going to be messy and very difficult, but simply waiting in a bunker is no way to solve the problem. at least this is an effort and kudos to the Argentines for making it
I guess the problem is that doing nothing will simply allow those currently entrenched to continue on their merry way, citing the law on their side. they need to feel significant pushback in the only place they care, the ballot box. hence my approval of what the argentines did. who knows if it will work out, but it is a damn sight better than allowing the Peronists to remain in office.
and that is what we need here, somebody completely outside the box. it was the benefit of Trump in 2016, although I fear that is no longer the case with him. perhaps Vivek fits that role now, but you can tell the leadership is getting concerned because they no longer try to hike what they are doing, they have moved onto the stage where they seek to convince everyone that total control is the most natural, and best, outcome for the masses.
It is why every day I think god for the 2nd amendment and the 300 million weapons in private hands
While I share your optimism I do so with concern that this guy is just a plant to get in power and continue much of before, perhaps even discredit the libertarian ideals you speak of. Remember Meloni in Italy.... god even the name sounds the same....
I'm under the impression that the WEF has a bio blurb (like this one for Milei) for many well known people. It doesn't necessarily make the person a WEF supporter.
There is a picture of him at the WEF. See the post by The Good Citizen. People are listed on company sites where they work or contribute to. I see no reason to give the WEF a pass for the "well known people" listed on their site. Birds of a feather stick together. But it is probably just a coincidence.
"...there would be an entire faction of Americans that would actually celebrate an attack on their own home country."
Like Jan.6?
From my perspective both hard left extremists and MAGAns are toxic. Libertarianism and Liberalism are twin poles---guideposts that need each other to form a successful country. Let's make the analogy of both hot and cold water to make the right shower temp.
As far as Trump being the great savior by cutting taxes, in his 4 years in office, he added 7 trillion to the federal deficit after promising to reduce it--a rate higher than any recent prez though Biden may outpace him (Clinton--projected balance budget, Bush--6 trillion in 8 years, Obama--8 trillion in 8 years, Biden 4.8 trillion in 3 years).
Steve - Jan 6th was not an attack on our country. It was a bunch of rednecks protesting knowing that the 2020 election with mail in and dead people voting was not a legit election. It was MUCH less of an attack on our country that the BLM protests which actually caused damage and death.
How are MAGA people toxic? I am all for lower taxes, much smaller government and less foreign interactions (aka wars). So I am toxic?
The fact that Trump is pretty blatant about having an authoritarian conservative politburo should make you question how much freedom he really offers. Maybe you should support an actual Libertarian candidate.
The real question is whether Milei will hit a wall of bureaucratic resistance (i.e. “deep state”) like Golden Man did in the US. Judging from the reaction of the US ruling class, the so-called alphabet agencies in the US government will do everything in their power to ensure this happens and Milei fails.
Interesting essay that points out the unique and somewhat stunning election in Argentina of an eccentric liberatarian with a strong educational background in economics. His policies seem sound and his nature unique and original enough to keep things interesting. Also enjoyed QTR pointing out how the left has lost its mind along with its moral compass. Queers for Palestine?? Yeah, don't forget to throw me off the roof after you're done with the Jews.
Wow, you're feeling optimistic today! What a refreshing read. I'm feeling a tad more optimistic too. But I'm still overwhelmingly pessimistic. This country has its head so far up its ass it may never recover. I've been watching a TV show about the Roman Republic and how it ended. It is eerily similar to what is happening today. But maybe Argentina will show us the way this time. Who the hell knows. I'll give optimism a try. Why not? It will definitely improve my disposition. 🙂
Great piece, Chris. One clarification: You mentioned "Argentina is going to put... sound money... into practice", but also that Milei is adopting the US Dollar, which is not sound money. I keep waiting for someone to go back to a Gold standard, as that would truly be a gamechanger. Yes, governments prefer fiat (who wouldn't want the ability to create money from nothing?). Will it take hyperinflation as a forcing function? Probably, although it could be a tremendous capital boost for someone big to do it. Imagine the prosperity we'd share, the rebirth of America, if we just went back to the Constitution, including Article 1, Section 10 "No State shall... make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts;". The sad thing is, no one even understands this, not even our most highly educated in every field. We are so far removed from the wisdom of our founders (which they did not have by chance, but only through the careful study of history). Was it by design or happenstance that our institutions lost sight of the most important lessons of history, the concepts of liberty, sound money, Austrian economics and Natural Law? BTW, like you, I am trying to bring it back with our line of 'better bedtime stories' (had to toss that in, but not the reason for the comment).
This sounds like a great way to demonstrate to the world how to implement all the ideals while selling it as "New Freedom".
-CBDC thanks to the central bank closure (but not Bitcoin, it will be the Gov. variant)
-Devaluation of the peso, to drive the population into poverty and CBDC dependance
-No civil service to foil the plans (get rid of the troublemakers)
Also @QTR your conversation with the gentleman in his 60's was more likely him lamenting all the immigrants who don't give a toss about MAGA, given they want to convert the country to their religions and ideals instead. True they don't love or revere the flag and nation, but I don't believe its going to be the red, white & blue citizens rejoicing after something bad happens in their back yard.
Mr. Trump is no "Conservative." Wm. F. Buckley, Jr. is spinning in his grave over what has happened to small government and less federal spending by the party formerly known as the GOP. Nikki Haley wants pre-emptive war with Iran? Desantis uses taxpayer dollars to fight protected speech and behavior by private corporations? Where's a Conservative on that debate stage? St. Ronnie couldn't get the nomination today.
The Tax cuts and Jobs Act blew a trillion dollar a year hole in the budget when times were "good" and while that may seem minuscule in today's terms, it certainly wasn't Conservative. More like "Voodoo Economics" We need some f'ing common sense, maybe like Paine suggested. There is no Conservative movement or party in the US. Change my mind
I think the problem is simple: the majority of the people in the West have no representation. Sure, they vote for politicians. But those politicians then enact laws and policies that enrich themselves, their families, and their voting blocs at the expense of the majority, the average American (or avg. citizen of the West). And there is never accountability for this b/c everyone who is allowed on the ticket (at state and federal levels, at least) is on-board with this dynamic.
E.g., everyone agrees somewhat flippantly that we have a Uniparty in the US...but no one seems to start with that fact in any analysis of what is going on. Instead, everyone defaults to talking about (R)s vs. (D)s, as if the two parties are different in some substantive way. They are not. Did the spending decrease under (R) presidencies or (R) congresses? Nope. Did the wars stop? Nope. Did government size and power increase or decrease with (R)s in control? It increased, massively. It's thanks to W and Cheney that we are under surveillance by our own government now. Did the culture continue its leftward slide no matter which party held power? Yep. Did (R)s vote to mandate covid shots for everyone (except themselves, of course)? Yep. They're on the same team. They have the same values: big government, big business, globalism, and extremely, uh, "libertine" social values. There is no daylight b/w the "two parties."
I don't know the solution, but I can say that if we don't properly identify the core issue (i.e., we don't actually have a meaningful choice - our choices are basically bigger government or biggest government), we'll never find a solution. We'll just be stuck in finger pointing and name calling while the "two party" charade goes on.
That's a long-winded way of saying I'm happy about the Millei election, if only because it pushes open the range of possible and acceptable options a little bit. It suggests that, at least in Argentina, some sizable chunk of voters have seen through the charade and are ready to ditch government as a necessary part of the solution to every "problem." Time will tell if it makes a dent in what citizens think the relationship b/w a people and its government can/should look like.
Great article! ... As for my thoughts on Javier Milei,a quote from Billy Graham seems to be prophetic here. “When a brave man takes a stand the spines of other are often stiffened”. May it be so.
we saw a trial run in 2015/2016 with the presidential election in Austria going to an outsider (although subsequently overturned in the courts there), then Brexit then Trump. the entrenched elite fought back hard to regain their power, hence the turmoil in 2020 and the subsequent acceleration of every asinine idea from the left like men can be women and global boiling as well as the push to allow the WHO to make all global decisions in the next pandemic. But I agree, this is a noteworthy outcome and presages many elections in the next 18 months, obviously including ours in the US. I expect that the left has pushed too far and they are going to be routed all around the world. do not be surprised if AfD in Germany comes into power without a coalition in the 3 German states that have elections next year. people are fed up with the bullshit.
I agree it is going to be messy and very difficult, but simply waiting in a bunker is no way to solve the problem. at least this is an effort and kudos to the Argentines for making it
I guess the problem is that doing nothing will simply allow those currently entrenched to continue on their merry way, citing the law on their side. they need to feel significant pushback in the only place they care, the ballot box. hence my approval of what the argentines did. who knows if it will work out, but it is a damn sight better than allowing the Peronists to remain in office.
and that is what we need here, somebody completely outside the box. it was the benefit of Trump in 2016, although I fear that is no longer the case with him. perhaps Vivek fits that role now, but you can tell the leadership is getting concerned because they no longer try to hike what they are doing, they have moved onto the stage where they seek to convince everyone that total control is the most natural, and best, outcome for the masses.
It is why every day I think god for the 2nd amendment and the 300 million weapons in private hands
More...
While I share your optimism I do so with concern that this guy is just a plant to get in power and continue much of before, perhaps even discredit the libertarian ideals you speak of. Remember Meloni in Italy.... god even the name sounds the same....
Bingo!
https://www.weforum.org/people/javier-gerardo-milei/
I'm under the impression that the WEF has a bio blurb (like this one for Milei) for many well known people. It doesn't necessarily make the person a WEF supporter.
There is a picture of him at the WEF. See the post by The Good Citizen. People are listed on company sites where they work or contribute to. I see no reason to give the WEF a pass for the "well known people" listed on their site. Birds of a feather stick together. But it is probably just a coincidence.
https://substack.com/@thegoodcitizen/note/c-44003300?r=5ihn6
This is definitely worse...so much worse.
Rooting for Milei, too. “Stepping down to the studs” is exactly the medicine for decades of excess & malinvestment.
"...there would be an entire faction of Americans that would actually celebrate an attack on their own home country."
Like Jan.6?
From my perspective both hard left extremists and MAGAns are toxic. Libertarianism and Liberalism are twin poles---guideposts that need each other to form a successful country. Let's make the analogy of both hot and cold water to make the right shower temp.
As far as Trump being the great savior by cutting taxes, in his 4 years in office, he added 7 trillion to the federal deficit after promising to reduce it--a rate higher than any recent prez though Biden may outpace him (Clinton--projected balance budget, Bush--6 trillion in 8 years, Obama--8 trillion in 8 years, Biden 4.8 trillion in 3 years).
Steve - Jan 6th was not an attack on our country. It was a bunch of rednecks protesting knowing that the 2020 election with mail in and dead people voting was not a legit election. It was MUCH less of an attack on our country that the BLM protests which actually caused damage and death.
How are MAGA people toxic? I am all for lower taxes, much smaller government and less foreign interactions (aka wars). So I am toxic?
You need to turn off your TV and live life.
The fact that Trump is pretty blatant about having an authoritarian conservative politburo should make you question how much freedom he really offers. Maybe you should support an actual Libertarian candidate.
This guy will fail miserably......like Trump, big mouth, little substance. No one cares about Argentina other than soccer fans.Sorry!
The real question is whether Milei will hit a wall of bureaucratic resistance (i.e. “deep state”) like Golden Man did in the US. Judging from the reaction of the US ruling class, the so-called alphabet agencies in the US government will do everything in their power to ensure this happens and Milei fails.
Interesting essay that points out the unique and somewhat stunning election in Argentina of an eccentric liberatarian with a strong educational background in economics. His policies seem sound and his nature unique and original enough to keep things interesting. Also enjoyed QTR pointing out how the left has lost its mind along with its moral compass. Queers for Palestine?? Yeah, don't forget to throw me off the roof after you're done with the Jews.
Wow, you're feeling optimistic today! What a refreshing read. I'm feeling a tad more optimistic too. But I'm still overwhelmingly pessimistic. This country has its head so far up its ass it may never recover. I've been watching a TV show about the Roman Republic and how it ended. It is eerily similar to what is happening today. But maybe Argentina will show us the way this time. Who the hell knows. I'll give optimism a try. Why not? It will definitely improve my disposition. 🙂
Great piece, Chris. One clarification: You mentioned "Argentina is going to put... sound money... into practice", but also that Milei is adopting the US Dollar, which is not sound money. I keep waiting for someone to go back to a Gold standard, as that would truly be a gamechanger. Yes, governments prefer fiat (who wouldn't want the ability to create money from nothing?). Will it take hyperinflation as a forcing function? Probably, although it could be a tremendous capital boost for someone big to do it. Imagine the prosperity we'd share, the rebirth of America, if we just went back to the Constitution, including Article 1, Section 10 "No State shall... make any Thing but gold and silver Coin a Tender in Payment of Debts;". The sad thing is, no one even understands this, not even our most highly educated in every field. We are so far removed from the wisdom of our founders (which they did not have by chance, but only through the careful study of history). Was it by design or happenstance that our institutions lost sight of the most important lessons of history, the concepts of liberty, sound money, Austrian economics and Natural Law? BTW, like you, I am trying to bring it back with our line of 'better bedtime stories' (had to toss that in, but not the reason for the comment).
Keep up the good work!
Milei is a WEF plant:
https://www.weforum.org/people/javier-gerardo-milei/
This sounds like a great way to demonstrate to the world how to implement all the ideals while selling it as "New Freedom".
-CBDC thanks to the central bank closure (but not Bitcoin, it will be the Gov. variant)
-Devaluation of the peso, to drive the population into poverty and CBDC dependance
-No civil service to foil the plans (get rid of the troublemakers)
Also @QTR your conversation with the gentleman in his 60's was more likely him lamenting all the immigrants who don't give a toss about MAGA, given they want to convert the country to their religions and ideals instead. True they don't love or revere the flag and nation, but I don't believe its going to be the red, white & blue citizens rejoicing after something bad happens in their back yard.
Great article Chris, I totally agree, lets hope someone doesn't take out Javier Milei, he is to me like Trump.
Mr. Trump is no "Conservative." Wm. F. Buckley, Jr. is spinning in his grave over what has happened to small government and less federal spending by the party formerly known as the GOP. Nikki Haley wants pre-emptive war with Iran? Desantis uses taxpayer dollars to fight protected speech and behavior by private corporations? Where's a Conservative on that debate stage? St. Ronnie couldn't get the nomination today.
The Tax cuts and Jobs Act blew a trillion dollar a year hole in the budget when times were "good" and while that may seem minuscule in today's terms, it certainly wasn't Conservative. More like "Voodoo Economics" We need some f'ing common sense, maybe like Paine suggested. There is no Conservative movement or party in the US. Change my mind
I think the problem is simple: the majority of the people in the West have no representation. Sure, they vote for politicians. But those politicians then enact laws and policies that enrich themselves, their families, and their voting blocs at the expense of the majority, the average American (or avg. citizen of the West). And there is never accountability for this b/c everyone who is allowed on the ticket (at state and federal levels, at least) is on-board with this dynamic.
E.g., everyone agrees somewhat flippantly that we have a Uniparty in the US...but no one seems to start with that fact in any analysis of what is going on. Instead, everyone defaults to talking about (R)s vs. (D)s, as if the two parties are different in some substantive way. They are not. Did the spending decrease under (R) presidencies or (R) congresses? Nope. Did the wars stop? Nope. Did government size and power increase or decrease with (R)s in control? It increased, massively. It's thanks to W and Cheney that we are under surveillance by our own government now. Did the culture continue its leftward slide no matter which party held power? Yep. Did (R)s vote to mandate covid shots for everyone (except themselves, of course)? Yep. They're on the same team. They have the same values: big government, big business, globalism, and extremely, uh, "libertine" social values. There is no daylight b/w the "two parties."
I don't know the solution, but I can say that if we don't properly identify the core issue (i.e., we don't actually have a meaningful choice - our choices are basically bigger government or biggest government), we'll never find a solution. We'll just be stuck in finger pointing and name calling while the "two party" charade goes on.
That's a long-winded way of saying I'm happy about the Millei election, if only because it pushes open the range of possible and acceptable options a little bit. It suggests that, at least in Argentina, some sizable chunk of voters have seen through the charade and are ready to ditch government as a necessary part of the solution to every "problem." Time will tell if it makes a dent in what citizens think the relationship b/w a people and its government can/should look like.
He's affiliated with the WEF. He has already changed his position about central banks. Just another politician seeking power and influence.
I’d be a lot happier if Jav denounces his WEF status along with the pile of shit that is Davos.
Great article! ... As for my thoughts on Javier Milei,a quote from Billy Graham seems to be prophetic here. “When a brave man takes a stand the spines of other are often stiffened”. May it be so.