I worked at Smith Barney in downtown LA in the late 1980s when Joe Kernen was a bullpen broker, then he left to work in TV. We called him Mr Hollywood. I was in operations. He was a dick then and apparently hasn't changed much. Little bit of history hahaha
There are decisions and outcomes. As humans, we get to make decisions. Outcomes, we do not control. His decisions were based upon solid concepts. Only those on the inside knew that the Fed would abandon sound financial wisdom. Magical computers, the collapse of rule of law, regulators leaving town all contributed to his being “wrong”. Buffett has been “wrong” before too. I don’t think he is worried where his next meal is coming from.
Right or wrong on his thoughts, Kernen was uncharacteristically rude. Grantham is a legend. That was a hit job.
As for stock picking, you have done a great job. Individuals who bought them have done well. That said, institutions could never follow many of your picks. They have too much money. It is why it is a stock pickers market. The mice can go where elephants cannot.
In The Big Short there's an exchange where two angry fund investors in Scion come to Burry's office. They can't imagine why anyone would bet against home mortgages and they want out.
Burry's reply: "I may be early but I'm not wrong."
His angry visitor: "It's the same thing!"
Bitcoin's principal utility is the anonymity. If that comes unwound, likely because governments decide they are not getting their expected cut, that might end it. Then again, the threat that looking under the hood might kill a golden tax goose could result in an everlasting standoff.
The most significant thing I’ve heard about BTC was the Philippe Laffont clip, earlier last week. He questioned its relevance in a coming era of stablecoins. I’ll always hang on to my small position, but that is one fugly chart, and I could easily see it going MUCH lower
I think the issue with stable coins is they are invented and controlled by a centralized authority who can issue as many as they want. Which gets back to the problems of Fiat again. As a currency though they seem to work much better than Bitcoin.
"Bitcoin's principal utility is the anonymity." I totally agree and beyond that, I am no expert on the digital landscape, but the looming possibilities of AI disrupting encryption seems to also be a giant negative.
RSA / elliptic curve encryption is secure to the extent it requires extraordinary compute power to break it. It's the human interface and computer to computer interface invocation of the process that might be weak. Mythos has found a terrific niche by setting it on a couple of off the shelf ecommerce apps. Now every IT manager is asking that AI be pointed at the assets he's responsible for. Fear is a great motivator/marketing tool.
👏👏👏Well stated and point well taken. I woujd only add the following observations. First, the biggest risk of market drawdowns is actually the fact that the pain causes an investor to liquidate they’re holdings as they become increasingly bearish near the bottom. Thus they never participate in the eventual recovery. I remember vividly how this happened in the mid 1970s after the prolonged bear market that began in 1966. The second point is that interviewers have to be viewed as at least neutral or many of the people they want to interview will refuse to appear on their programs. So if you are particularly tenacious and argumentative interviewer, you may lose an opportunity to host many of the guest, which you would like to question. Thus you have a difficult line to walk, but I agree totally that most most interviewers defer much too often to their guests, in other words, to use the vernacular they are simply “suck ups”..
Great piece. I particularly agree with your point that these questions often do not have black or white answers, but are nuanced.
I can live with myself for being "wrong"; I can't live with myself if I ACT on the basis of what I consider to be an insane paradigm! Hence - no interest whatever in "digital" (so-called) assets.
Like Warren B. (though on a far smaller scale of course) I don't worry about there my next meal is coming from.
BTC is a synecdoche for the post-2008 financial order in the Grantham-Kernan debate.
BTC has some uses as money and is also some kind of asset. It works well in this environment, but will it always work? Who knows, but it is interesting.
It was the complete disrespect for Grantham that really made it bad for me. All great investors know they are going to be right and wrong. GMO's long term record says it all for me, I'm pretty impressed.
Chris, I agree that CNBC needs challenge guests’ claims, especially bullish ones. I must admit that I’m a little disappointed that you didn’t manage to bring up Cathie Wood.
My question is what is likely to trigger the next Bear cycle? Will it be like 2000, where there was no specific trigger other than people just started to sell and take profits and it snowballed, or like 2008 where there was a financial system failure, or like the brief 2020 C-19 crash that was triggered by an exogenous event?
Just my opinion. It will come from left field and will be a credit issue. In retrospect, it will take 3-6 months to develop with no one/few seeing the end result. A black swan dosen't just show up. It swims into view.
Something I just recalled about Warren Buffett. When asked about bitcoin he said he guessed it was time to start shorting briefcases. I am a CPA in a firm and my business partners did not understand or like investing so I explained what he meant. In addition I cannot deny people have made a lot of cash in bitcoin. I don't have it or want it. I do not feel left out. I know it does not have a dividend or earnings or a fungible nature and you need to hope someone pays you more than you paid for it to go up. Maybe I am nuts and will regret it. Not sure as I only can trust what I believe.
When I saw the headline of this post I did not look down at first to see you attached the interview/discussion and so I found the podcast and listened to it while knocking out some paperwork. I did this because I did not want to read your article before I heard the discussion and interplay for my self. I really liked listening to Mr. Grantham and Kernen just sounded like a jerk. It ticked me off. However I must say my feeling changed slightly after reading your article. I agree that we need to give people a chance to defend their thesis and ask tough questions and it should also be done with perma-bulls not just the ursine crowd. I think after reading your thoughts the real thing that bothered me was not what Kernen said but how he said it. You do not always remember what people say but how they made you feel. My sense was that he was being an ass to a smart guy and could have done it in a classier way. Thanks as usual for sharing your thoughts.
I often think these debates on Bitcoin missed the most important arguments. Surviving a bear market is a pretty good one. But usually someone will say it's wasting electricity, it has no intrinsic value, it has no use case except for criminal transactions. And those are the things Grantham touched on. All of them have good counter arguments from educated bitcoiners. And then there are the network effects of Bitcoin. The network is growing. As well as nation states getting involved with treasuries and mining, institutional adoption with ETFs, The value of hard money. All would have been more interesting to hear about from these two guys.
I'm bullish on Bitcoin but I only came to that conclusion from listening to the best arguments on both sides for about 6 months. And that did not happen on this show. Probably why I seldomly watch it.
But I agree with QTR. Nobody actually knows. Given the percentage of Bitcoin that's in my portfolio I would love to believe the bullish stuff. But I also know that's a trap that could have a very painful ending. Blind hodle? No. More like ongoing vigilance and debate for me.
Bitcoin is nothing but a "price". There is no "There" there.
Thank you for hauling up the oysters. As consumers of financial information, it is our responsibility to shuck these bad boys and find the pearls.
I worked at Smith Barney in downtown LA in the late 1980s when Joe Kernen was a bullpen broker, then he left to work in TV. We called him Mr Hollywood. I was in operations. He was a dick then and apparently hasn't changed much. Little bit of history hahaha
There are decisions and outcomes. As humans, we get to make decisions. Outcomes, we do not control. His decisions were based upon solid concepts. Only those on the inside knew that the Fed would abandon sound financial wisdom. Magical computers, the collapse of rule of law, regulators leaving town all contributed to his being “wrong”. Buffett has been “wrong” before too. I don’t think he is worried where his next meal is coming from.
Right or wrong on his thoughts, Kernen was uncharacteristically rude. Grantham is a legend. That was a hit job.
As for stock picking, you have done a great job. Individuals who bought them have done well. That said, institutions could never follow many of your picks. They have too much money. It is why it is a stock pickers market. The mice can go where elephants cannot.
Hit jobs go viral. There isn't the expectation of civility that once was the case. CNBC surely has click farms working their audience, too.
💯% I did live through the dot.com bubble. IMO it's always better to be too early than too late. BTW, my precious metals assets behaved as agreed.
In The Big Short there's an exchange where two angry fund investors in Scion come to Burry's office. They can't imagine why anyone would bet against home mortgages and they want out.
Burry's reply: "I may be early but I'm not wrong."
His angry visitor: "It's the same thing!"
Bitcoin's principal utility is the anonymity. If that comes unwound, likely because governments decide they are not getting their expected cut, that might end it. Then again, the threat that looking under the hood might kill a golden tax goose could result in an everlasting standoff.
It's early. Either side might be wrong.
The most significant thing I’ve heard about BTC was the Philippe Laffont clip, earlier last week. He questioned its relevance in a coming era of stablecoins. I’ll always hang on to my small position, but that is one fugly chart, and I could easily see it going MUCH lower
I think the issue with stable coins is they are invented and controlled by a centralized authority who can issue as many as they want. Which gets back to the problems of Fiat again. As a currency though they seem to work much better than Bitcoin.
"Bitcoin's principal utility is the anonymity." I totally agree and beyond that, I am no expert on the digital landscape, but the looming possibilities of AI disrupting encryption seems to also be a giant negative.
RSA / elliptic curve encryption is secure to the extent it requires extraordinary compute power to break it. It's the human interface and computer to computer interface invocation of the process that might be weak. Mythos has found a terrific niche by setting it on a couple of off the shelf ecommerce apps. Now every IT manager is asking that AI be pointed at the assets he's responsible for. Fear is a great motivator/marketing tool.
👏👏👏Well stated and point well taken. I woujd only add the following observations. First, the biggest risk of market drawdowns is actually the fact that the pain causes an investor to liquidate they’re holdings as they become increasingly bearish near the bottom. Thus they never participate in the eventual recovery. I remember vividly how this happened in the mid 1970s after the prolonged bear market that began in 1966. The second point is that interviewers have to be viewed as at least neutral or many of the people they want to interview will refuse to appear on their programs. So if you are particularly tenacious and argumentative interviewer, you may lose an opportunity to host many of the guest, which you would like to question. Thus you have a difficult line to walk, but I agree totally that most most interviewers defer much too often to their guests, in other words, to use the vernacular they are simply “suck ups”..
Great piece. I particularly agree with your point that these questions often do not have black or white answers, but are nuanced.
I can live with myself for being "wrong"; I can't live with myself if I ACT on the basis of what I consider to be an insane paradigm! Hence - no interest whatever in "digital" (so-called) assets.
Like Warren B. (though on a far smaller scale of course) I don't worry about there my next meal is coming from.
Someone should ask Grantham that if Bitcoin is based on nothing, what about the USD or any other fiat currency?
True enough and exactly why at this later stage of my life I've turned to precious metals, especially gold, silver, brass and lead!
Since 1971’s decoupling of the USD to Gold….You are spot on.
👊
BTC is a synecdoche for the post-2008 financial order in the Grantham-Kernan debate.
BTC has some uses as money and is also some kind of asset. It works well in this environment, but will it always work? Who knows, but it is interesting.
It was the complete disrespect for Grantham that really made it bad for me. All great investors know they are going to be right and wrong. GMO's long term record says it all for me, I'm pretty impressed.
Also see my substack about similar thoughts: https://pigsatthetrough.substack.com/p/the-inmates-are-running-the-asylum?r=3ib8e
Chris, I agree that CNBC needs challenge guests’ claims, especially bullish ones. I must admit that I’m a little disappointed that you didn’t manage to bring up Cathie Wood.
Look in the linked article "No Accountability".
My mistake. I read all your posts, so I don’t typically click the links.
My question is what is likely to trigger the next Bear cycle? Will it be like 2000, where there was no specific trigger other than people just started to sell and take profits and it snowballed, or like 2008 where there was a financial system failure, or like the brief 2020 C-19 crash that was triggered by an exogenous event?
Just my opinion. It will come from left field and will be a credit issue. In retrospect, it will take 3-6 months to develop with no one/few seeing the end result. A black swan dosen't just show up. It swims into view.
Something I just recalled about Warren Buffett. When asked about bitcoin he said he guessed it was time to start shorting briefcases. I am a CPA in a firm and my business partners did not understand or like investing so I explained what he meant. In addition I cannot deny people have made a lot of cash in bitcoin. I don't have it or want it. I do not feel left out. I know it does not have a dividend or earnings or a fungible nature and you need to hope someone pays you more than you paid for it to go up. Maybe I am nuts and will regret it. Not sure as I only can trust what I believe.
When I saw the headline of this post I did not look down at first to see you attached the interview/discussion and so I found the podcast and listened to it while knocking out some paperwork. I did this because I did not want to read your article before I heard the discussion and interplay for my self. I really liked listening to Mr. Grantham and Kernen just sounded like a jerk. It ticked me off. However I must say my feeling changed slightly after reading your article. I agree that we need to give people a chance to defend their thesis and ask tough questions and it should also be done with perma-bulls not just the ursine crowd. I think after reading your thoughts the real thing that bothered me was not what Kernen said but how he said it. You do not always remember what people say but how they made you feel. My sense was that he was being an ass to a smart guy and could have done it in a classier way. Thanks as usual for sharing your thoughts.
I often think these debates on Bitcoin missed the most important arguments. Surviving a bear market is a pretty good one. But usually someone will say it's wasting electricity, it has no intrinsic value, it has no use case except for criminal transactions. And those are the things Grantham touched on. All of them have good counter arguments from educated bitcoiners. And then there are the network effects of Bitcoin. The network is growing. As well as nation states getting involved with treasuries and mining, institutional adoption with ETFs, The value of hard money. All would have been more interesting to hear about from these two guys.
I'm bullish on Bitcoin but I only came to that conclusion from listening to the best arguments on both sides for about 6 months. And that did not happen on this show. Probably why I seldomly watch it.
But I agree with QTR. Nobody actually knows. Given the percentage of Bitcoin that's in my portfolio I would love to believe the bullish stuff. But I also know that's a trap that could have a very painful ending. Blind hodle? No. More like ongoing vigilance and debate for me.