By Daniel Klein, Brownstone Institute
In the Vice-Presidential debate, the Democratic candidate Tim Walz used shouting fire in a crowded theater to justify limitations on free speech. Ironically, he resembles a man shouting fire in a crowded theater.
The history of this phrase traces to Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. in the 1919 Supreme Court case Schenck v. United States, in which he says it is wrong to “falsely” shout fire. The case concerned the right to protest war. Schenck was later largely overturned.
Still, the phrase has stuck.
When we think about why it is wrong to shout fire in a crowded theater, we see why Walz’s invocation makes little sense. A premise, here, is the shouter knows there is no fire and seeks to cause a panic.
Imagine it. You are in a movie theater and a man in the row in front of you starts shouting “Fire!”
Most likely you would assume that the shouter is a troublesome soul, since you see no smoke and no flames. Today, when fire alarms go off in a school or office building, do we panic? We are used to false alarms, even when it comes to the hazard of fire.
Even if the shouter succeeds in causing a panic, think about how that panic occurs. A few theatergoers become alarmed and rush for the door. Others see others panicking, and that impels them to panic. Those panickers have little time to ask, Is there a real danger?
The shouter’s action violates the contract he made with the theater. Ethically, his action is wrong, as it is bad to lie and it is bad to disrupt the show and cause a panic.
Does the shouter’s action resemble the activity that Walz would censor? Whether it be public health claims or political claims, the resemblance is slight.
First, whether there is a fire in the theater is straightforward. After a bit of investigating, everyone will agree, either that there is a fire or there is not a fire. But the claims Walz would censor are not like that. They are complex matters of social affairs and call for judgment, after considering vying interpretations of things. People will not immediately agree.
Second, when the man shouts fire in a crowded theater, there is a sense of urgency. No one wants to suffocate or burn in a fire. But when one listens to a podcast or reads content on the internet, he has time to consult with others and explore other points of view. He has time to reflect. We learn to sift vying interpretations and to form our own judgments.
Third, for the controversial public issue, different people will continue to have differing assessments, even after each has spent much time exploring the issue. Give them twenty years and still they may not agree. That is profoundly different than with a fire in a theater.
In some ways, Walz resembles the man who shouts fire in a crowded theater. Claiming a great danger, he incites people to fall in with a political program.
But, having heard the shouting—“Save democracy!”, “Hammer disinformation out of existence!”—we have some time to consult, discuss, and reflect, using our capacious moral and intellectual faculties.
Nothing confesses untruthfulness like censorship.

QTR’s Disclaimer: Please read my full legal disclaimer on my About page here. This post represents my opinions only. In addition, please understand I am an idiot and often get things wrong and lose money. I may own or transact in any names mentioned in this piece at any time without warning. Contributor posts and aggregated posts have been hand selected by me, have not been fact checked and are the opinions of their authors. They are either submitted to QTR by their author, reprinted under a Creative Commons license with my best effort to uphold what the license asks, or with the permission of the author.
This is not a recommendation to buy or sell any stocks or securities, just my opinions. I often lose money on positions I trade/invest in. I may add any name mentioned in this article and sell any name mentioned in this piece at any time, without further warning. None of this is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. I may or may not own names I write about and are watching. Sometimes I’m bullish without owning things, sometimes I’m bearish and do own things. Just assume my positions could be exactly the opposite of what you think they are just in case. All positions can change immediately as soon as I publish this, with or without notice and at any point I can be long, short or neutral on any position. You are on your own. Do not make decisions based on my blog. I exist on the fringe. The publisher does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided in this page. These are not the opinions of any of my employers, partners, or associates. I did my best to be honest about my disclosures but can’t guarantee I am right; I write these posts after a couple beers sometimes. I edit after my posts are published because I’m impatient and lazy, so if you see a typo, check back in a half hour. Also, I just straight up get shit wrong a lot. I mention it twice because it’s that important.



Marxists are the masters of accusing others of exactly what THEY are doing. TRUTH does not mind being questioned. LIES hate to be challenged.
Even at the time, truth was a defense. And Schenck was one of the worst SCOTUS decisions ever. It was about as far from the First Amendment as we've strayed; Walz's enthusiasm for it (to the extent we can credit him with knowing what he's talking about) is ominous when it comes to his comprehending and supporting free speech rights.