14 Comments
User's avatar
Matt Cook's avatar

I love discussions that quote M&Ms.

Murray and Mises.

What geniuses they were.

Bread and Circuses's avatar

Thank you Mr. Sowell, I feel a bit better

“No one is equal to anything. Even the same man is not equal to himself on different days.”

The Radical Individualist's avatar

It's discouraging, the number of college grads have never even heard of Thomas Sowell. How is that possible?

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

It's called the "Big Lie" - repeated over and over.

Bread and Circuses's avatar

Cool, Sowell documentary. I’ve been slacking:

https://youtu.be/WK4M9iJrgto?si=VJ_BgndC9IBc-cgH

craazyman's avatar

fully agree DEI is a disaster. faster it's destroyed the better. I wish Mises Freeks (MF) would use their analytical acumen to diagnose why socialist movements arose in first place. MF's answer to every free market failure is "more cowbell". (Famous SNL skit with Christopher Walken).

Prosperous capitalism and true freedom requires some antidote to free market failures -- even the 20th century union movement paved way for broad middle class prosperity and resulting entrepreneurial fortunes it made possible., "More cowbell" won't do it as history shows over and over and over. You need some kind of balance, some kind of harmony -- that's true prosperity and true freedom. Otherwise you're only a lion in a jungle. That may sound good to some, but it's inhuman.

Steve Mudge's avatar

I don't mind DEI going the way of the dinosaurs though the "tyranny" that is disposing of it may be an even more pernicious form of governance.

Realty based's avatar

Unfortunately, the right to own and control one's private property has been broadened to mean that society cannot interfere with the right of individuals to use whatever advantage they have (which can be smarts, inherited money, family and other connections, working hard in fields that pay well as well as corruption) to accumulate private property (which includes stocks and other financial assets) far beyond any needs of these individuals and their families for generations to come. Any attempt to tax this stream of money to pay for programs helpful to those less fortunate would seem to interfere with the rights of property owners. Neither can the money (property) of the wealthy be used to pay governmental debt (which, despite the focus on waste, does have ends which society and its leaders have chosen to have). So, you have what?: a XX national, state, and municipal debt that can never be paid back, hundreds (?) of yachts for the uber wealthy that cost 300 to 500 million), endless amounts of political donations to steer more money their way, etc. So, while property rights are essential, it is not the only 'good'; money (begets) money (a form of property) which begets more money/property).

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

Your logic fails to understand how wealth is created and the inherent properties of it. It is difficult to explain in a short reply, but the essence is that wealth is created, not transferred. It is a measure of one's contribution to society, not what one took from it. This is the primary difference between how Austrian school economics views wealth versus Marxist school (if you could even call that a "school").

Your view implies that one's wealth just magically creates more wealth without an active, purposed reallocation of that original wealth towards the best use and societal need. And you seem to also imply that this is a flaw, when it's actually an indication of further contribution to society. That one individual may benefit from it is not a flaw, as his wealth does not force anyone else to do or perform anything in response. This is the essence of free markets and liberty.

The overriding principle is that government is an inefficient zero-sum redistributor of wealth while the free market is the creator of that wealth.

craazyman's avatar

Dear Lord on a Sunday

There's a dude I follow who is a top-shelf econometrician. His full-cycle stock market valuation work is beyond reproach. His methods are rigorous and fiercely intelligent. He publishes his results and views for free. (Partly its his marketing, but his analytical integrity is indisputable). When he is wrong, he tries to adapt if needed. He is intellectually confident but humble.

I follow another dude who publishes weekly commentary. He too is thoughtful, well informed, honest and highly intelligent.

I have nothing but respect for each of these guys, as analysts of markets.

However! Both (like many in our culture) have jumped the shark into political commentary. There, they are raging lunatics. They view the world through TDS and seem pathetically ignorant of their own "tribe's" sins. All they can see are flaws and virtues. The other side's (MAGA variants) flaws and their ("establishment" variants) virtues.

How can they be this way in politics and so capable in the markets realm?

That's a great mystery. I see some of the same tendency here, in the elevation of all things libertarian, although my political views likely overlap a great deal with the house view here.

There's something about politics that makes people crazy. I think people mostly are crazy, and certain triggers bring it out. In the context of political economy, I call that "political psychosis", our modern variant of the religious wars that used to convulse humanity. It's a very high dimensional world. Reductions to a discrete set of alleged factors don't often have much explanatory power. If someone thinks they do, it's mostly an illusion.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

As I noted earlier in response to another comment, the overriding problem is how people understand wealth as a concept. Many think that it is simply money, and how much you have. This is incorrect as money ultimately has no intrinsic value. It's value is the measurement of how much one has contributed to society, aka wealth.

Austrian school economics views wealth as being created into an ever bigger pie, not transferred. Marx school views wealth as finite, and something that is taken or transferred, not created.

It thus makes sense that Austrians encourage the creation of more and more wealth via as much freedom as possible. It also makes sense that Marxists want to limit activities that would normally create wealth, because they just see it as a transfer from the less powerful to the more powerful. This Marxist view is inherently flawed.

No matter how much money a "robber baron" has, no one else has to perform or do work for them. Yes, if resources are monopolized and others can't even work for them, then this not a free market, and thus illegal. This is why anti-trust is important for free markets to do their magic.

I could go on and on, but it would be out of scope. My biggest point is that I see people's misunderstanding of wealth being used over and over again to propagate Marxist concepts.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Justice must be served. Convene the Tribunals and start the Trials.

Realty based's avatar

Addendum: in today's world, even to suggest changing this will lead to one being called a "socialist".