35 Comments
User's avatar
Sick Boy's avatar

TLDR: "The Americans are living well. How do I know? Well, I'm living well and all my friends are living well, and that's the statistical evidence you just can't beat. Brought to you by BlackRock".

Thanks for sharing the article. I guess you've covered the third part of your slogan for this month. When I've seen this Boudreaux guy claim that the CPI "overstates" the rate of inflation, I cracked up.

I’m A Nobody, Cogito, Ergo Sum's avatar

Yea

I have been scratching my head on that one. That is the first time I have ever seen someone state that.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

TCB's avatar

I agree with you that’s “CPI is overstated” is a head scratcher.

But the main premise - current income comparisons omit benefits paid to “poor” Americans AND taxes paid by “rich” Americans - remains intact. I never realized this until now.

Then consider the fact our own eyes confirm all governments exist to grow their control and power (Covid policies, new laws, new programs, etc). Where interests are aligned, a conspiracy is not required.

We’re are struggling. But “tax the rich” to play Robin Hood ain’t the answer.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

Sick Boy's avatar

I've picked up a different message from the article. It says: Not Going Hungry is the New American Dream. Shifting the goalposts obviously isn't just the leftist pastime.

The whole article is just the rich telling us that everything is fine and if they can, please, keep their money, because it's not like they're hurting our existence. But they are. Big time. Not because they're rich, but because of the way most of them are getting there.

They're teaching us that the redistribution is an ugly word, if it means progressive taxation. I used to agree with that. But what they didn't tell us is that their Wall Street shenanigans, governmental subsidies and money printing are also redistribution - going their way, at our expense.

So, tax them away, I say. Answer or not, it would be nice to let them feel our pain for a bit. But no government is gonna do it, anyway. The problem with the government is not so much that it's too big (and getting bigger) - as is that it is not "for the people and by the people".

Abbe Faria's avatar

Student Loan Debt: $1.6 trillion

Credit Card Debt (revolving): $488 Billion

Auto Loan Debt: $1.5 Trillion

Source: Nerd Wallet

Americans living paycheck to paycheck: 64%

These debt numbers suggest not a dying middle class, but a dead middle class.

Our nation has been looted. Who?

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

phil@InflationEducation.net's avatar

I appreciate the different perspective, but this article seems like a bungled attempt to defend America and capitalism as if we even have either of those two things anymore. To state that the "CPI is an index known for almost 30 years to substantially overstate the rate of inflation" is patently absurd and directionally wrong -- and to source that to the Social Security Adminstration (given their motives) is laughable. American inequality is real, and that would be fine if we had a level playing field, but we don't. The fix is not to redistribute income. The fix is to level the field by putting an end to the broken, crooked, debt-based fiat money system, returning to a gold (or Bitcoin) standard.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

phil@InflationEducation.net's avatar

From our first children’s book on sound versus fiat money. Fiat-

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

I have come to believe that the underlying premise of the Democrat party is control. People attracted to that party have an unusual affinity for totalitarian methods and ends. When given a choice of "freedom" versus centralized planning or control they generally choose control. Every societal problem or concern requires a government response, rather than a plea for personal responsibility and acceptance of risk.

Yes, there are a couple of exceptions--namely abortion and sex (both of which are interrelated), but even their response to people who disagree with them on these issues is totalitarian.

So when the author above comments on Leftist's propensity to ignore plainly available evidence that challenges their worldview, it is completely understandable that they ignore it, rather than be content that we might have actually improved a societal problem. The goal is not improvement, but to impose their will on others.

I believe that many people on the Left are on a spectrum of mental illness, and have unhealthy psychoses towards their fellow human beings. They choose not to "live and let live," but to "judge and control." They themselves are largely controlled by their inner feelings and instincts rather than the objective data that lie before them. That they are not celebrating this paper is more key evidence to that assertion.

balazs's avatar

Regarding sex and abortion - these too are about more control and less individualism. Let me elaborate.

What most people forget about this, is that these things used to be private matters. That meaning, that the government had absolutely no business in these. Now these strictly private matters become public matters, see the gay parades, the LGBT festivals, the trans education for children, etc. The first move of socializing something is always making a private matter public. Once the overton window has been widened to accept that a previously private topic is now public, the government can come in and regulate it and be ever more dictatorial and authoritarian about it. This is why they are so interested in everything related to sex and reproduction.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

I agree that the Left is constantly attempting to push the Overton window. They understand how society changes, and they seemingly have a lot of free time to be activists for their causes.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

RU's avatar

You can see this authoritarian tendency in the left with regard to incarceration as well. "Free all the prisoners!" (Except the ones we want in jail. they should be locked up forever without due process or trial. See: Trump, Penny, Chauvin, etc.) And, of course, things like science, religion, and so on. If they don't personally like a finding or belief, it is wrong and needs to be stamped out. Definitely not openly debated. This is indeed a form of psychosis.

Tankster's avatar

Pardoning all the political prisoners in jail for their January 6 sightseeing tour of the Capitol must be the first thing President Party of Trump (GOP exists no more) must do.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

Matt Brady's avatar

"The second of these major flaws is the common practice of adjusting for inflation by using the Consumer Price Index – an index known for almost 30 years to substantially overstate the rate of inflation." This is a wild claim.

Income alone is not a great metric for this debate. It would be better to look at purchasing power of accumulated wealth, but calculating this accurately due to the problems with CPI would be difficult. A better metric might be share of wealth and that data seems to substantiate the claim that the middle class is being curb-stomped into the poor house:

Share of Total Net Worth Held by the Top 1% https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBST01134

Share of Total Net Worth Held by the 50th to 90th Wealth Percentiles https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBSN40188

Share of Total Net Worth Held by the Bottom 50% https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBSB50215

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

Wealth is not a fixed entity. Therefore "share of wealth" is misleading. There could be massive amounts of wealth being created, and you might only make a bit for yourself, but that doesn't mean you are worse off.

I've never understood the propensity of people to be spiteful or envious when someone else creates tremendous value that millions of people voluntarily trade with. This excludes crony capitalism or theft, of course. Both of those problems are government related.

But if you are suggesting that the middle class should be "given" wealth that others have created simply because they exist in the same society, then you are talking about something different than a free society where people are allowed to create as much value and trade as they wish.

If people feel that they are not adequately compensated for the value they create, then they should look to alternative wealth creation. That is how a free market works. The guy cutting the lawns all day can work to create his own landscaping company. No, it's not easy, but it seems that many people consider their situation to be the result of others "curb stomping them into the poor house" rather than taking control of their own destiny.

Tankster's avatar

Everything the Fed has done since 2007 has been curb stomping us rubes while enriching Jeff Epstein's friends. Stock buybacks. Read Ben Hunt.

Matt Brady's avatar

"Wealth is not a fixed entity. Therefore "share of wealth" is misleading. There could be massive amounts of wealth being created, and you might only make a bit for yourself, but that doesn't mean you are worse off."

Directly addressed in my comment: "It would be better to look at purchasing power of accumulated wealth, but calculating this accurately due to the problems with CPI would be difficult." If you have a better measure, I'm all ears.

"But if you are suggesting that the middle class should be "given" wealth that others have created simply because they exist in the same society, then you are talking about something different than a free society where people are allowed to create as much value and trade as they wish."

When did I ever suggest this?

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

Maybe I took too much from your comment "...that data seems to substantiate the claim that the middle class is being curb-stomped into the poor house."

First, I don't believe this insinuation. If anyone becomes "poor" in our economy it's usually because they are spending too much, not because they don't make enough. Usually. Sometimes it's a terrible event or something out of their control, and I absolutely feel for those folks. But for the vast majority, poverty is brought upon themselves. If they don't make enough there are ample opportunities for all people of all skill sets to better themselves. But not all people want to make the sacrifices necessary to do that. That's fine, but please don't suggest that their own condition is due to some wealthy bogeyman who is purposefully stealing their wealth.

Wealthy people are mostly wealthy because they have a "wealth mindset." Yes, that means they have largely figured out how to create wealth and continue to do so. That does not preclude anyone else from also creating wealth.

So, what are you suggesting, here, if not what I originally thought?

Tankster's avatar

Just saw Baby J. Is this like his GQ interview? Income and support and 55" color TV's are commonplace all the way down. Rudy Havenstein writes about WEALTH inequality all the time, and the share of wealth held by the .1%, 1%, as opposed to the bottom 50% has risen dramatically courtesy of the Fed. Do you disagree with those alternative facts?

Trilander's avatar

when I read CPI understates inflation, I cancelled my membershio

Jim Brown's avatar

I believe the cited authors are correct, that the systemic "inequality" claim is mostly a myth. But in my view most of them miss a separate, more important point in the inequality discussion. This is the issue of wealth re-distribution caused by the Fed, mostly during QE. Since 2009, the Fed (and other central banks) have pumped up asset prices, benefiting mostly the biggest owners of assets. This was a massive transfer of wealth to the very wealthy from nearly everyone else. The injustice of this transfer cannot be ignored. It is not to say upward mobility is gone, or that the American dream is dead. But the asset bubble was rigged in favor of the very rich. We must not forget this problem, and we must fix it.

Andy Fately's avatar

It seems to me that there have been quite a few stories lately about the fact that a family of four can obtain support to the tune of $100k or more in a number of states adding up unemployment, SNAP, welfare and other transfers, so clearly, not counting those would be incorrect. However, it is also difficult to look around and not see the extreme increases in wealth from the super rich.

Ultimately, I would contend the issue is the lack of personal responsibility by many and their unwillingness to take ownership of their actions and decisions and how that affects their lives.

Stephen Amaretti's avatar

Agree with Illinois Entrepreneur 💯%

Laird's avatar

I’m sure all those sweet benefits were used in purchases of assets like real estate, equities, gold and silver, and bitcoin countering the affects of inflation. Yeah, probably not.

Litcap Vell (CAVELL POLEON)'s avatar

Gaining financial freedom at this economic crisis is a must. Grow and diversify your Portfolio by Trading stocks, real estate, crypto and rare metals for generational wealth. Hit me up to gain more insight about investing

Email: litcapsvell@gmail.com

Whatsapp: +357 99 016766

User's avatar
Comment removed
May 26, 2023
Comment removed
Tankster's avatar

Nobody's been fed more by the government than the rapacious CEO's of companies who are now history. BBBY, Toys R Us are but two examples. Borrow money, buy a company, pay out with borrowed money implode the company. let the PBGC pick up the pieces. Make the uninsured depositors of SVB, and the other crashed entities whole. WTF, Chris? https://www.epsilontheory.com/the-united-states-of-bed-bath-beyond/

RU's avatar

I think it's actually about representation. There is an entire third or so of this country that works in lower to middle class jobs, supports the country via taxes and their blood, and yet has no representation in government or among the elite institutions. To use a leftist phrase: they don't see themselves in the institutions that are supposed to be supporting them. They are overtly, illegally discriminated against in hiring (especially high-paying government jobs) and in college admissions. They are purposefully excluded from the national conversation. To me, that's the "inequality" that the populist right is talking about. And they are correct in that assessment.