"The war between the governments of Israel, the US, and Iran will be just like all other wars, negative in all its aspects." This is true enough, but a nuclear blast is also negative in all aspects.
Ukraine's 2014 war was negative in all respects for the unfortunate residents of Crimea, Lugansk and Donetsk. China's annexation of Tibet was negative certainly for the Tibetans. Russia's Chechan war was negative for the Chechans.
Moral of the story: War is bad, but it is usually worse for the losers. You lose your identity if you submit to an aggressor. Sometimes you have to fight.
The US has never faced an existential threat from external enemies. It faces a number of threats internally. Stepwise loss of control to illegal immigrants. Decimation by those who flood the country with drugs. Purveyors of sexual perversions that snuff out future generations.
The question is not economic. And, yes, sometimes wars need to be fought.
Currently, the US is under assault from external enemies in a manner that is incomprehensible to the majority of the population. Instead of weapons, people and mass media are being used.
It was pioneered in the EU and was quite successful.
It looks like it might succeed in the US.
Physical war is destructive and vicious. I've seen it. Cultural war is extremely destructive as well.
Any sane person is opposed to war. But there can still be positive results. The U.S. civil war precipitated mass manufacturing using standardized, interchangeable parts in manufacturing guns. Interchangeable parts is so obsequious today that we don't even think about how it was before then. WWII also brought about efficiencies and standardization in manufacturing. Houses built post WWII are built using materials and procedures largely different from before the war.
We keep measuring our economy in money, and we all know that money is a false god. Measure the economy in productivity and efficiency. That's the reality.
People who think war causes prosperity are incapable of abstraction. Remember Frederic Bastiat's "broken window fallacy": A shopkeeper's son breaks a window. Bystanders console the father by saying it's actually good for the economy — the glazier (window repairman) gets paid, then spends that money at the baker's, who spends it at the cobbler's, and so on. The broken window created economic activity! But the broken window didn't create new wealth. It simply destroyed value and redirected spending that would have happened somewhere else. This is so obvious and self-contradictory that you wonder about the Keynesian mentality that claims destruction causes wealth accumulation.
Left to their own devices, Germany and Japan, would have erased the Jewish population of Europe and Chinese in Manchuria and island states of the Pacific. Hard to ignore the social benefit of USA efforts to stem those forces. It cost a lot of $$ and lives in that successful effort. You did not address the banking system which, in several documented instances, supported both sides at great profit. I am not Jewish.
"I will go back to Washington, and issue notes for circulation; for it is certain that the war must go on until the rebellion is put down, if we have to put out paper until it takes a thousand dollars to buy a breakfast".
~~~ Saloman Chase, Treasury Secretary
1919:
"The profiteers are a consequence and not a cause of rising prices," and if a government allows matters to take their course, "the worthlessness of the money becomes apparent, and the fraud upon the public can be concealed no longer".
~~~ J.M Keynes
1946:
The nature of the inflationary pressure inherent in diverting half of the income stream of the country to the government is simple. It is this: The value of all of the production of the country goes to its producers in the form of wages and salaries, rents, interest, dividends, and profits. But only half of this production consists of goods and services which are available to be purchased by these producers. The remaining half goes to the Government for prosecuting the war. The problem is to prevent the people from trying to spend all of their incomes on half of the goods—and so merely bid up prices.
~~~Hans Morgenthau, Treasury Secretatry
1971:
"I have directed Secretary Connally to suspend temporarily the convertibility of the dollar into gold or other reserve assets, except in amounts and conditions determined to be in the interest of monetary stability and in the best interests of the United States."
It's true that war doesn't beat peace regarding innovation ; I can't imagine Pistol Pete inventing one click free shipping. Joke appart, this article is to the point. And I remark that two major countries, former warmongering threats, China and Russia, are now very reluctant to enter the fray. Maybe the learned their lesson.
Every war ends on paper long before it ends in the lives of those it touched. Soldiers, the maimed, bystanders, whole populations schooled in fear — they bear their wounds into old age. Economists can estimate the monetary wreckage, but no figure accounts for what matters most: the weight of suffering carried in silence, and all the ordinary joy that war quietly made impossible.
Just so. In the Arab/Muslim Umma, the state sector is bloated beyond belief. People show up for “work” or not, draw paychecks and leave. Nothing productive goes on. No innovation, no risk taking. OTOH, see Israel, where experimentation is encouraged from age 18, in the squads of the IDF, and (some) lessons are learned through failure. In the Umma, failure is shamed, so there is no incentive to move out of your lane. Yes, war is wasteful, but advances technology. It has to be paid for, not put on a $30T on the books debt, unless we take the resources conquered. I always said that when we saved the Kuwaitis, we should have forced $10/Bbl oil for 50 years as the price of that little interlude.
"The war between the governments of Israel, the US, and Iran will be just like all other wars, negative in all its aspects." This is true enough, but a nuclear blast is also negative in all aspects.
Oppenheimer and Fallout were timed to install "The Science" of scary nukes back into the operating system of western boomers.
Ukraine's 2014 war was negative in all respects for the unfortunate residents of Crimea, Lugansk and Donetsk. China's annexation of Tibet was negative certainly for the Tibetans. Russia's Chechan war was negative for the Chechans.
Moral of the story: War is bad, but it is usually worse for the losers. You lose your identity if you submit to an aggressor. Sometimes you have to fight.
The US has never faced an existential threat from external enemies. It faces a number of threats internally. Stepwise loss of control to illegal immigrants. Decimation by those who flood the country with drugs. Purveyors of sexual perversions that snuff out future generations.
The question is not economic. And, yes, sometimes wars need to be fought.
Written from Kyiv.
Currently, the US is under assault from external enemies in a manner that is incomprehensible to the majority of the population. Instead of weapons, people and mass media are being used.
It was pioneered in the EU and was quite successful.
It looks like it might succeed in the US.
Physical war is destructive and vicious. I've seen it. Cultural war is extremely destructive as well.
Any sane person is opposed to war. But there can still be positive results. The U.S. civil war precipitated mass manufacturing using standardized, interchangeable parts in manufacturing guns. Interchangeable parts is so obsequious today that we don't even think about how it was before then. WWII also brought about efficiencies and standardization in manufacturing. Houses built post WWII are built using materials and procedures largely different from before the war.
We keep measuring our economy in money, and we all know that money is a false god. Measure the economy in productivity and efficiency. That's the reality.
It's difficult to understand how people can place 'the economy' over lives.
People who think war causes prosperity are incapable of abstraction. Remember Frederic Bastiat's "broken window fallacy": A shopkeeper's son breaks a window. Bystanders console the father by saying it's actually good for the economy — the glazier (window repairman) gets paid, then spends that money at the baker's, who spends it at the cobbler's, and so on. The broken window created economic activity! But the broken window didn't create new wealth. It simply destroyed value and redirected spending that would have happened somewhere else. This is so obvious and self-contradictory that you wonder about the Keynesian mentality that claims destruction causes wealth accumulation.
Batiast’s “Broken Window”
http://bastiat.org/en/twisatwins.html
Left to their own devices, Germany and Japan, would have erased the Jewish population of Europe and Chinese in Manchuria and island states of the Pacific. Hard to ignore the social benefit of USA efforts to stem those forces. It cost a lot of $$ and lives in that successful effort. You did not address the banking system which, in several documented instances, supported both sides at great profit. I am not Jewish.
War is inflation. Always.
1783:
"Not worth a continental."
1864:
"I will go back to Washington, and issue notes for circulation; for it is certain that the war must go on until the rebellion is put down, if we have to put out paper until it takes a thousand dollars to buy a breakfast".
~~~ Saloman Chase, Treasury Secretary
1919:
"The profiteers are a consequence and not a cause of rising prices," and if a government allows matters to take their course, "the worthlessness of the money becomes apparent, and the fraud upon the public can be concealed no longer".
~~~ J.M Keynes
1946:
The nature of the inflationary pressure inherent in diverting half of the income stream of the country to the government is simple. It is this: The value of all of the production of the country goes to its producers in the form of wages and salaries, rents, interest, dividends, and profits. But only half of this production consists of goods and services which are available to be purchased by these producers. The remaining half goes to the Government for prosecuting the war. The problem is to prevent the people from trying to spend all of their incomes on half of the goods—and so merely bid up prices.
~~~Hans Morgenthau, Treasury Secretatry
1971:
"I have directed Secretary Connally to suspend temporarily the convertibility of the dollar into gold or other reserve assets, except in amounts and conditions determined to be in the interest of monetary stability and in the best interests of the United States."
~~~President R.M. Nixon
It's true that war doesn't beat peace regarding innovation ; I can't imagine Pistol Pete inventing one click free shipping. Joke appart, this article is to the point. And I remark that two major countries, former warmongering threats, China and Russia, are now very reluctant to enter the fray. Maybe the learned their lesson.
Every war ends on paper long before it ends in the lives of those it touched. Soldiers, the maimed, bystanders, whole populations schooled in fear — they bear their wounds into old age. Economists can estimate the monetary wreckage, but no figure accounts for what matters most: the weight of suffering carried in silence, and all the ordinary joy that war quietly made impossible.
Randolph Bourne: “War is the Health of the State.”
Just so. In the Arab/Muslim Umma, the state sector is bloated beyond belief. People show up for “work” or not, draw paychecks and leave. Nothing productive goes on. No innovation, no risk taking. OTOH, see Israel, where experimentation is encouraged from age 18, in the squads of the IDF, and (some) lessons are learned through failure. In the Umma, failure is shamed, so there is no incentive to move out of your lane. Yes, war is wasteful, but advances technology. It has to be paid for, not put on a $30T on the books debt, unless we take the resources conquered. I always said that when we saved the Kuwaitis, we should have forced $10/Bbl oil for 50 years as the price of that little interlude.