36 Comments
User's avatar
CaptAlan's avatar

Recessions, and the occasional depression, are a feature of capitalism that tends to keep the wealth gap from getting too extreme. Things are how they are now as an unintended result of pulling out all the stops to avoid the depression that should have begun in 2008 or 2020. Our political inability to make difficult decisions, and the voter's tendency to punish anyone who tries, ensures that crisis will be forced upon us and the result will be worse than it could have been. When it happens, what triggers it, how long it lasts and what the other side looks like are anyone's guess. Captain Obvious over and out.

badnabor's avatar

Exactly. I, like Chris, am pro capitalist. The problem is that this nation hasn't operated under true capitalism for a very long while now. 2008 was just a glaring example of government intrusion on the behalf of the 'too large to fail' financial behemoths. It was sold as the cure to avoid another 'Great Depression', which, to be fair, would drastically realign the wealth and cause hardship throughout the economy. As politicians always do, they backed the plan that would avoid the immediate, deserved realignment and went with the 'kick the can down the road' money printing option. Governments throughout history have made these same mistakes and yet...they never learn from them. I can't predict the time, but it's very clear that a reckoning is past due.

DLB's avatar

There is a lot that can be said about paper wealth in the world today, but one thing is clear, that wealth was built on cheap credit and government spending

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Well done Chris. As I have been saying - this Fourth Turning is not going to end well for us. The factors you have been mentioning (and others) have combined to create the Perfect socio/politico/economic Storm.

John Horst's avatar

Try this: Start with 1964. Why? Because that was the last year the Quarter Dollar was minted in 90% silver. The federal minimum wage was $1.25 at the time. That's five quarters. Melted down, they are a little north of .90 oz of silver. Now look away from the CPI, which is garbage and has been since 1982 when the cost of buying a home was stripped from it in favor of "owner's equivalent rent." Instead look to the delta between the minimum wage and the price of an oz of silver factored by 0.9042 (I think that's the exact ratio to an ounce from melting down five 1964 Quarter Dollars.

One hour of labor cost 0.9042 oz. of silver in 1964. Using silver rather than the CPI to tell the story of lost purchasing power, you will discover that $1.25 nominal 1964 dollars are worth less than $0.02 in today's Dollar. The problem, though, is that is the contours of the story as we like to tell it.

Now tell the same story, only now look at things like the "Fight for $15" about ten years ago. When you use the minimum wage in ounces of silver as the benchmark, this wasn't a demand for a raise as much as it was for a return of stolen purchasing power.

If you want a barometer for the social pressure cooker, compare 1964 with today. Silver is priced in the $60/oz ballpark and the federal minimum wage is $7.25.

Our kids aren't stupid for pining for socialism. They're wrong, for sure, but they're not stupid. There is almost nothing left of "owned home purchasing power" in their Dollar denominated wages. They are living a version of the story of the Silesian Weavers (look it up) as told by Wilhelm Wilbur... to whom - upon Wilbur's death - Karl Marx dedicated Das Kapital.

We had better start telling the story of owned-home purchasing power, and quickly, because the only people speaking to today's stories of despair are the bat-shit crazies in the DSA.

Herschel Savage's avatar

I don't think we can blame inflation on the top 0.1%. There are only so many Bentleys, mansions, islands, Jets, and yachts they can buy. And those don't really contribute that much to inflation. Your point is where is the *feeling* coming from that the system is rigged?

Thats not even coming from the one percenters.

It's the people who *masquerade* as one percenters but are up to their eyeballs in debt. Social media has made it 100x worse. Keeping up with the Joneses used to just mean Fred got a new Lincoln every two years and remodeled his kitchen. Now you have dipshits online flaunting their Bvlgari jewelry and six figure handbags from their $20k/mo rental homes and the idiots who follow them believe they are wealthy. These are the same people who believe Real Housewives are Real.

So this feeds into the comparative thinking part of the human brain that is deeply embedded in all of us, leading to general dissatisfaction with our lives. Heres a clue - the vast majority of one percenters don't get up in the morning and go online to behave like asshats. They are generally seniors, who are self-made, and are using their wealth to de-risk their portfolios, not buy shit they don't need. You wouldn't know them if you passed them on the street. I belong to three country clubs. The average age is 60, and 80% of them a) suck at golf, b) are one percenters, and c) lead anonymous lives. Only a couple have jets and they're dicks.

One of the very few pearls of wisdom my Dad gave me was this: there will always be somebody under you who works harder and deserves it more, and somebody above you who hardly works and deserves it less. Spending your life looking up and down just feeds into envy or guilt, neither of which are going to be helpful to you.

But its what the Mamdani's of the world are counting on.

Charles K's avatar

They don't have to buy anything. Their vast wealth, no matter the source was materialized out of cheap debt. The very existence of their wealth IS the inflation.

Forget about whatever definition of "inflation" is in your head. It is a function of money which is a function of debt.

Doug Ross's avatar

BTW, the Fed is ultra-political. ZIRP under Obama; instant ratchets of rates under Trump 1?

Any thoughts on Trump Accounts addressing this gap? I'm hearing some speculation that DJT's goal is to eliminate the income tax and pay for government expenditures through the sovereign wealth fund. If the Singularity Thesis pans out, this could be a massive equalizer. I wrote this up in July:

Your Kid Is Already a Millionaire. You Just Haven’t Opened the App Yet.

https://directorblue.substack.com/p/your-kid-is-already-a-millionaire

STEVEN's avatar

trump accounts are a backdoor to social security privitization. imo, it wont happen fast, but it will happen.

J-9's avatar

Senate just passed a Make the IRS Great Again bill last week, a pet project of Ron Wyden and rinoriffic Mike Crapo, combined 77+ years in D.C. Cloaked in promises of making the IRS responsive to taxpayers but the devil is in the details. Unanimously, in fact. So either Rand Paul bought into it or he was absent.

The Color Of Air's avatar

Whatever these government spooks say, all roads point to tokenization of every asset in a digital world controlled by A/i filled data centers. Meaning in the end you will own nothing, nada, zilch.

Trilander's avatar

Hey Fringe,

Great writing as always and many of the points you make together are supurb. However I want to go and revisit what Capitalism really is: Go and look up the wording. It is the unrestrained entrance by new smaller companies into any and EVERY mkt they want to enter which is the central theme, to keep pricing competitive and fair. All we have today is a corporatism/fascist model where the mega companies and the government work "together" to rule over the people. This is ALMOST the complete opposite of the spirit within Adam Smith's capitalism! Look at how bad small caps have faired since the QE era. The government is only in bed with the largest most powerful institutions... The little companies and the little citizens are getting run OVER.

george's avatar

We are repeating the Industrial Revolution and producing modern day Rockefellars, Vanderbilts, Carnegies and the like. (Nice guys, right?) The Fabian Society is eternal too, they just say they don't exist.

george's avatar

Did I mention on the back of cheap immigrants? Plantation living is all the rage.

Calatwood's avatar

Capitalism doesn’t create wealth gaps per se. Of course those most motivated to succeed are far more likely to get rich. But through their production all are better off. It’s that we have a debt based system. Banks create most new money via credit expansion. They borrow short and lend long on fractional (which is now zero) reserves. The Federal Reserve was created by the banking cartel to ensure the cartel played nice amongst themselves so they’d all grow rich. Then the fairytale called “dual mandate” was told by the WSJ and CNBC to provide the necessary comfortable lie that the Fed cares about main street. Madison Ave came along to ensure debt slavery was entered voluntarily. Washington is paid handsomely to go along with the scheme, and the occasional crank like Ron, or to a lesser degree Rand, Paul is tolerated as the example of tin hat conspiracy theorist. The perfect fool to make those brilliant Greenspan/Bernanke/Yellen/Warsh look like a genius manning the wheel of the financial ship. But the system will collapse. Each period of growth has met with a bigger fall necessitating larger Fed bailouts. But in the end “ there is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as the result of voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as the final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved.“

J-9's avatar

Nothing matters; self-pitying whiners gonna whine no matter what. Getting sucked in by envy-stoking ads that the trust-fund leftist Senator up for re-election is running endlessly with smurfed contributions. The ads would be the same if gas was $2 a gallon. I'm glad I grew up in the years before middle-class welfare became a thing but even back then we were supposed to be hating on millionaires except of course the Kennedys. Now it's those evil Billionaires. Since Elon Musk hitting $1 trillion launched Elizabeth Warren into a frothy rage, I'm rooting for him to make it $2 trillion and watch her self-propel into psycho orbit. If a harridan screeches in space does it make a sound? How about that SPCX, up 5% this morning to $166 and but another bad JOBy report. Elon's going to need it to set up a refuge on Mars before the next Dem A.G. (Letitia?) concocts charges for a genius-filled DC jury to rubber-stamp and Our Saviour Centennial FDR II orders NASA to extradite him. We might actually get to see an experiment to settle the question of how many weeks the government can run on assets confiscated from the rich.

K Tucker Andersen's avatar

The commentary is interesting and at the macro level where it resides hard to broadly disagree with. But I continue to ask - what is the solution which is not worse than the disease?

Clearly our. Notary regime needs serious reform. but it is not the sole and perhaps not even primary reason for our wealth inequality. The surest way to reduce the wealth inequality is make a lot of people poorer , either through a depression which also deflates asset prices or a wealth redistribution scheme so draconian that it destroys most of the incentive to create wealth for the super productive members of society. Even the poorest able bodied and mentally sound individuals among us who are in the bottom quintile of the wealth distribution have everyday items that were literally unavailable to the rich when I was a teenager 70 years ago. E.g. - 60+ inch color televisions, cell phones, food choices that were unavailable then (some even health) , incredibly cheap airfares, very beneficial medical advances (such as robotic surgery and well functioning artificial limbs), etc, etc. the greater a society’s wealth, the greater the probability of inequality. “ You will always have the “relatively” poor with you” is an incredible insight from a very wise prophet.

Brett Howser's avatar

Awhile back I heard an interview with some scholar of Ancient Rome. I don’t recall who it was nor who was interviewing him. The interviewer asked what was the cause of the decline of the Roman Empire? Enemies? Plagues? Corruption? Christianity? Nope. The interviewee simply said “the Roman Empire fell apart because too few had too much.” History repeats itself and rhymes.

The Color Of Air's avatar

The currency was constantly debased so that the poor became poorer with doing anything.

El Doco's avatar

Fantastic article. I am, sadly, pessimistic about the future because every political faction in the US is more invested in economic religion than actually acknowledging and addressing problems.

What the right refuses to confront is that the left's criticisms of capitalism have real teeth. It really is exploitative. It really does lead to exactly the outcome you're describing in this article: a widening ultra-wealth gap and, eventually, more and more people falling behind. I don't buy it when people claim this is a perversion of capitalism. It's a feature of it. It's baked into the cake. It's the same objection when people claim "That's not real communism!" Real communism, and real capitalism, are what you actually get when you implement them, not what they claim on paper. I have no emotional or religious attachment to capitalism like many seem to on the right (even though I'd definitely describe myself as more right- than left-leaning).

Of course, exceptionally productive people *should* receive greater rewards, so wealth inequality isn't inherently bad. But that isn't an unlimited principle. If it were really unlimited, eventually you'd have one person with everything and everyone else with zero. Which kind of seems like where we're heading.

Unfortunately, the left's answer to these problems is even worse. If they think wealth inequality is bad now, just wait until the DSA assumes power and they discover that socialism/communism means the party elite have everything and everyone else lives in extreme poverty. It's going to get really ugly if we go that route, which I fear we will. Not all at once and not in a clean line, but I'm expecting a hard swing left economically and politically in the coming years and it's not going to be pretty. I hope to be proven wrong.

Ultimately, it's the tyranny of the Pareto distribution. No economic model has found a way to fight its perverse effects effectively. Capitalism seems to have done better than other economic systems, but we appear to be hitting some real limits.

I don't pretend to be wise enough to know the best solutions to our problems, and I know there is no perfect solution. I suspect the best achievable outcome would be heavy reforms of what we've got -- sticking with this capitalist model but working hard to rein in its excesses -- but I'm afraid that's not where we're going.

We'll see. All anyone can do who doesn't inhabit the halls of power (and who would want to enter that cesspit?) is prepare as best they can for an uncertain future on an individual level. Good luck to all.

CaptAlan's avatar

Capitalism is inherently self-correcting though the corrections are unpleasant and occasionally brutal. Communism is just brutal.

Capitalism and democracy are two sides of the same coin. In democracy we vote every two years. In capitalism we vote every day with our money. The problem is that people do stupid things with their money and their votes, so we swing from one extreme to the other. If the Constitution holds, we will be fine. If not, all bets are off.

Harold Koehler's avatar

We don't have free market capitalism. We have corrupt crony capitalism and that is why we're circling the drain. We have the best government money can buy.

Dan Bouchard's avatar

So, what can be done about it without punishing anyone?

CaptAlan's avatar

Nothing. Your mission is to see it coming and maneuver you and yours away from the worst of it.

george's avatar

The original Titans of Industry understood charity and public works. That's the difference.