"It takes away any realistic hope of the vast majority of people making money because eventually 80-90% won’t/don’t work because they can’t compete with a machine."
Not all machines are connected to a keyboard. The modern machine age didn't start with the computer, it started about two centuries ago with the development of steel, communications, and modern transportation.
All buildings used to be built with hand-cut lumber, from the forest to the final product. Efficient production didn't reduce the need for carpenter/woodworkers, it increased the demand due to the affordability of housing and furniture that was previously too expensive for the average person.
Same for clothing, food and even healthcare.
Same for books. Modern printing didn't reduce the demand for authors, it increased it thousands fold.
The downside is that quality and uniqueness often suffers. Efficient productivity does not promote individuality. We al have a sense of that, even when we're not sure why. So, here we are, at the crossroads of AI. It will destroy some jobs, but it will create others that we aren't even aware of yet. And, without doubt, it will lower the quality and the uniqueness of the product. But that is nothing new. For some, average levels of quality, and high levels of conformity are what make them feel comfortable. AI has found its niche.
It is possible to live mostly outside of all of that. I have done it. It ain't easy, but it is rewarding. AI is no threat to me, any more than a table saw or a drill press is a threat to me. I use them all to my advantage.
AI has been around in concept for decades, mostly as a single-task computer program. For example, in 1996 IBM built a computer, named Deep Blue, that beat the world-renowned chess player Gary Kasparov.
When did AI become a general-purpose human-replacing machine? When humans became too expensive. The campaign to raise the minimum wage to $15 began in 2012, growing out of fast food worker strikes. This movement became widely recognized as the "Fight for $15.”
“Large language model" AI development became prominent about the same time, with the advent of deep learning and the development of models like GPT-3, which was released in 2020. From there, it was a short step to marry AI to robotics, and one of the first targets of that marriage was fast food workers, who are now demanding (and in Blue States, receiving) $20+ per hour. (LA just passed a law mandating minimum wage+benefits of $38/hour for foodservice and hospitality workers for the 2028 Olympics.)
While “intelligent robots” are not cheap, it’s more-or-less a once-and-done expense. At $20/hour, a year’s worth of minimum wage costs an employer $41,600, plus matching FICA, plus benefits. Then, with a human, the meter starts running again next year.
Let’s face it, a teen-age stock boy is not worth $15-$20 per hour. Nor is a restaurant greeter of the same age. Had bleeding-heart liberals had not championed absurd wages for part-time, entry-level positions, AI would not be replacing workers at alarming rates.
Perhaps you should take a high school reading comprehension class. It would certainly help you understand what you read. The term “minimum wage” is LITERALLY In the second, third, and fourth paragraphs, with the synonym “entry-level” in the fifth paragraph.
If YOU are a minimum wage worker, then it’s reasonable to compare YOUR job to a “robot” following you around 8 to 12 hours a day. But is the “lube shop at Walmart” staffed with minimum-wage, entry-level employees? Or any of the Fortune 500 companies referenced in your links?
If you have to battle a strawman instead of the argument posed, you have already failed.
Humanoid robots are already here. Musk’s company makes one, and there are others. But my point is that AI doesn’t need to look “humanoid” to replace minimum-wage workers. My local Checkers has a voice-operated AI drive-thru order station. That’s one $15/hr worker gone. My local Taco Bell has announced they will be updating their in-store order kiosks to be voice-operated within the next 6 months. That’s 2 or 3 $15/hour workers gone. More AI/robotics already in production:
There’s no point in responding to you when I say “AI robotics are replacing minimum-wage workers” and you come back with stupid statements like “You imagine robots are going to take over the world?”
We move forward towards the world of William Gibson's "Neuromancer", apparently. The only obvious difference between your vision and Gibson's is that in his society AI has been outlawed.
This is brilliant observation and commentary. Once again, substack shows the true (original) promise of the internet (I've bookmarked The Honest Broker for future reference). Thank you, Mike!!
As it relates to AI, I can't help but smirk at how ridiculously inadequate AI is to anyone with any critical thinking experience.
George Carlin 50 years ago: "They call it the American Dream because you gotta be asleep to believe it." Chuck Palahniuk: "When did the future change from being a promise to a threat?"
I want everyone reading the blog to take a minute and look up the derivation of the word "sabotage" (if you don't already know it). The Industrial Revolution has been ongoing for @250 years and there has been no change in the message of the doomsayers (while the average standard of living world-wide has done nothing but skyrocket higher for the entire time)
The ONLY real problem is EROEI - easily soluble with nuclear as a bridge to fusion plants and solar arrays located in geosynchronous orbit and beaming the power produced to fixed ground stations. These make possible the colonization of the near Solar System (the Moon, Mars, the Asteroid Belt and eventually (through terra-forming), Venus), providing opportunity for "upward mobility" for centuries to come.
As for AI that is potentially inimical to the human race the answer has already been jointly found in the 1940s by Isaac Asimov and John W. Campbell, Jr. (Asimov writing for Campbell in the pages of Astounding Science Fiction Magazine) in Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics".
It seems the premise is that AI will either become the enemy and destroyer of mankind, or it will be used by the <insert boogie man name> to control and ultimately destroy mankind. Why is it that the worst case scenario and the fear of it is assumed likely to happen?
I use AI frequently to save time and be more productive. It generates contract templates, lease summaries and market descriptions for me. It would otherwise take me many hours to have done so. I am now able to work on more projects in an expeditious manner. When will it turn against me? Why can't I as a human evolve and adapt to new and more powerful tools availed to me?
Maybe fear porn sells better than Who Moved My Cheese?
Another issue is the majority of elected officials aren’t bright enough to see potential paradoxes here. They’ll posture, hold endless hearings and end up with nothing constructive. While I hear stories of some terrific results through the addition of AI to businesses, lately a contractor had some impressive time savings on required filings, the overall evolution of it concerns me. Old school and too many Terminator/Orwell hours I guess.
Perhaps it’s that old school or maybe farm raising but I don’t believe humans were meant to fool around with sentience. Just seems like potentially a Pandora’s box imo.
My last thought is potential weaponization of it. Historically, man has never created a weapon that hasn’t been used. That is an obvious worry.
As the Transnationals take over the medias and forment division and fracture....the American experiment will balkanize and fall apart.
No amount of munitions or armies could achieve this aim of destroying the Amerucan dream..it's happening right in front of us by entities that hate the US but are being coddled by our "influenced "government representatives.
Now we can clearly see why the illegals were allowed in and how well they were organized into cadres with taxpayer funds.
Would real US citizens take to the streets to protest the removal of illegals?
Thank you for some common sense. This article makes some good points about corporatism but really went off the rails when it started invoking Skynet scenarios.
More government and/or communism is never the answer.
"It takes away any realistic hope of the vast majority of people making money because eventually 80-90% won’t/don’t work because they can’t compete with a machine."
Not all machines are connected to a keyboard. The modern machine age didn't start with the computer, it started about two centuries ago with the development of steel, communications, and modern transportation.
All buildings used to be built with hand-cut lumber, from the forest to the final product. Efficient production didn't reduce the need for carpenter/woodworkers, it increased the demand due to the affordability of housing and furniture that was previously too expensive for the average person.
Same for clothing, food and even healthcare.
Same for books. Modern printing didn't reduce the demand for authors, it increased it thousands fold.
The downside is that quality and uniqueness often suffers. Efficient productivity does not promote individuality. We al have a sense of that, even when we're not sure why. So, here we are, at the crossroads of AI. It will destroy some jobs, but it will create others that we aren't even aware of yet. And, without doubt, it will lower the quality and the uniqueness of the product. But that is nothing new. For some, average levels of quality, and high levels of conformity are what make them feel comfortable. AI has found its niche.
It is possible to live mostly outside of all of that. I have done it. It ain't easy, but it is rewarding. AI is no threat to me, any more than a table saw or a drill press is a threat to me. I use them all to my advantage.
AI has been around in concept for decades, mostly as a single-task computer program. For example, in 1996 IBM built a computer, named Deep Blue, that beat the world-renowned chess player Gary Kasparov.
When did AI become a general-purpose human-replacing machine? When humans became too expensive. The campaign to raise the minimum wage to $15 began in 2012, growing out of fast food worker strikes. This movement became widely recognized as the "Fight for $15.”
“Large language model" AI development became prominent about the same time, with the advent of deep learning and the development of models like GPT-3, which was released in 2020. From there, it was a short step to marry AI to robotics, and one of the first targets of that marriage was fast food workers, who are now demanding (and in Blue States, receiving) $20+ per hour. (LA just passed a law mandating minimum wage+benefits of $38/hour for foodservice and hospitality workers for the 2028 Olympics.)
While “intelligent robots” are not cheap, it’s more-or-less a once-and-done expense. At $20/hour, a year’s worth of minimum wage costs an employer $41,600, plus matching FICA, plus benefits. Then, with a human, the meter starts running again next year.
Let’s face it, a teen-age stock boy is not worth $15-$20 per hour. Nor is a restaurant greeter of the same age. Had bleeding-heart liberals had not championed absurd wages for part-time, entry-level positions, AI would not be replacing workers at alarming rates.
Perhaps you should take a high school reading comprehension class. It would certainly help you understand what you read. The term “minimum wage” is LITERALLY In the second, third, and fourth paragraphs, with the synonym “entry-level” in the fifth paragraph.
If YOU are a minimum wage worker, then it’s reasonable to compare YOUR job to a “robot” following you around 8 to 12 hours a day. But is the “lube shop at Walmart” staffed with minimum-wage, entry-level employees? Or any of the Fortune 500 companies referenced in your links?
If you have to battle a strawman instead of the argument posed, you have already failed.
Humanoid robots are already here. Musk’s company makes one, and there are others. But my point is that AI doesn’t need to look “humanoid” to replace minimum-wage workers. My local Checkers has a voice-operated AI drive-thru order station. That’s one $15/hr worker gone. My local Taco Bell has announced they will be updating their in-store order kiosks to be voice-operated within the next 6 months. That’s 2 or 3 $15/hour workers gone. More AI/robotics already in production:
https://spectrum.ieee.org/chef-robotics-food-robots
https://fhafnb.com/blog/robots-in-food-service/
https://builtin.com/robotics/robots-in-restaurants-food-service
https://www.restaurantbusinessonline.com/technology/ai-powered-self-service-kiosks-offer-benefits-customer-operator
https://voiceplug.ai/solutions/kiosk-ai/
https://grubbrr.com/conversational-ai-technology-in-kiosks/
There’s no point in responding to you when I say “AI robotics are replacing minimum-wage workers” and you come back with stupid statements like “You imagine robots are going to take over the world?”
Interesting read, might have to try to get copyrights and register the name Skynet.
We move forward towards the world of William Gibson's "Neuromancer", apparently. The only obvious difference between your vision and Gibson's is that in his society AI has been outlawed.
I think this free press piece dovetails nicely with yours.
https://open.substack.com/pub/bariweiss/p/the-knowledge-system-collapse?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=2n9rzo
This is brilliant observation and commentary. Once again, substack shows the true (original) promise of the internet (I've bookmarked The Honest Broker for future reference). Thank you, Mike!!
As it relates to AI, I can't help but smirk at how ridiculously inadequate AI is to anyone with any critical thinking experience.
Apparently, I'm not alone: https://machinelearning.apple.com/research/illusion-of-thinking
So, getting past the hype...who is right? Apple...or Anduril (https://www.anduril.com/)?
George Carlin 50 years ago: "They call it the American Dream because you gotta be asleep to believe it." Chuck Palahniuk: "When did the future change from being a promise to a threat?"
I want everyone reading the blog to take a minute and look up the derivation of the word "sabotage" (if you don't already know it). The Industrial Revolution has been ongoing for @250 years and there has been no change in the message of the doomsayers (while the average standard of living world-wide has done nothing but skyrocket higher for the entire time)
The ONLY real problem is EROEI - easily soluble with nuclear as a bridge to fusion plants and solar arrays located in geosynchronous orbit and beaming the power produced to fixed ground stations. These make possible the colonization of the near Solar System (the Moon, Mars, the Asteroid Belt and eventually (through terra-forming), Venus), providing opportunity for "upward mobility" for centuries to come.
As for AI that is potentially inimical to the human race the answer has already been jointly found in the 1940s by Isaac Asimov and John W. Campbell, Jr. (Asimov writing for Campbell in the pages of Astounding Science Fiction Magazine) in Asimov's "Three Laws of Robotics".
It seems the premise is that AI will either become the enemy and destroyer of mankind, or it will be used by the <insert boogie man name> to control and ultimately destroy mankind. Why is it that the worst case scenario and the fear of it is assumed likely to happen?
I use AI frequently to save time and be more productive. It generates contract templates, lease summaries and market descriptions for me. It would otherwise take me many hours to have done so. I am now able to work on more projects in an expeditious manner. When will it turn against me? Why can't I as a human evolve and adapt to new and more powerful tools availed to me?
Maybe fear porn sells better than Who Moved My Cheese?
Another issue is the majority of elected officials aren’t bright enough to see potential paradoxes here. They’ll posture, hold endless hearings and end up with nothing constructive. While I hear stories of some terrific results through the addition of AI to businesses, lately a contractor had some impressive time savings on required filings, the overall evolution of it concerns me. Old school and too many Terminator/Orwell hours I guess.
Perhaps it’s that old school or maybe farm raising but I don’t believe humans were meant to fool around with sentience. Just seems like potentially a Pandora’s box imo.
My last thought is potential weaponization of it. Historically, man has never created a weapon that hasn’t been used. That is an obvious worry.
As the Transnationals take over the medias and forment division and fracture....the American experiment will balkanize and fall apart.
No amount of munitions or armies could achieve this aim of destroying the Amerucan dream..it's happening right in front of us by entities that hate the US but are being coddled by our "influenced "government representatives.
Now we can clearly see why the illegals were allowed in and how well they were organized into cadres with taxpayer funds.
Would real US citizens take to the streets to protest the removal of illegals?
Thank you for some common sense. This article makes some good points about corporatism but really went off the rails when it started invoking Skynet scenarios.