23 Comments
User's avatar
Bill Lacey's avatar

With only a few exceptions, whenever the government undertakes an effort to solve a problem, the problem only gets worse. The list is long - the war on drugs, the war on poverty, affordable care, the Department of Education, homelessness, Dodd-Frank, etc.

Why? Because the creation of the government-funded solution creates the incentive for the problem to grow. A new agency generously staffed with 6-figured salaries, benefits, retirement plans and expense accounts. Needing an army of foot soldiers to carry out the mission. Extensive travel to parts unknown to divine "root causes". Junkets to the Napa Valley for retreats to "whiteboard" possible solutions. Offices, laptops, cellphones, maybe even a cafeteria.

And guess what? If they do their job and solve the problem, it all goes away. Poof. Gone. Bye-bye. No one on the inside wants that. Why would they? Who would work themselves into obsolescence? As Stafford Beer said "the purpose of a system is what it does". So the problem grows.

So, for example, the effort to solve the homeless problem turns into people farming. The larger the crop (the homeless), the more farmers you need (government). And around and around it goes with the only thing changing is the ever-growing number of government agencies and employees.

Bob Nixon's avatar

No federal agency wants its budget cut. No incentive for efficiency.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 30Edited
Comment deleted
Steve Mudge's avatar

Speaking of AI maybe it could do a better job...at least with the scanners

Michael Woods's avatar

A lesson that has to be learned again and again and again. If you want a business to be dysfunctional, with motivations against improvement, ensuring failure, give it to a government to run. Maybe the longest term example of this is Amtrak. High prices, low service, marginal equipment and poor schedules. In addition, it has never covered its costs, and never will. In summary, its station locations take people from where they don’t live to places they don’t want to go.

Harley Oien's avatar

Why should govt provide a supposed security service for safety of an airline at taxpayer expense. The airlines should directly provide this "service" just to help ensure that their airplane has some minimum level of security. Nothing gets the airline attention more than to have a flight disappear in a puff of smoke. The users of airline service should be the ones to pay for that security service. Modern airline service has devolved to the level of Greyhound bus service, all created by the drive for $$$ on the bottom line and by pawning off security service expense on a non-functional government security effort. By cleverly doing this, airlines avoid legal settlement responsibility for those "puffs of smoke." Same goes for the banking system, where FDIC insures deposits and when needed the FDIC funds never come close to covering depositor losses, so taxpayer is again required to kick in the additional government needed funds.

erik bjorseth's avatar

What has our government done well, efficient and had no wasted spending? Ever

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Now that I think of it, what is the point of TSA? A regular sales agent can check ID. Anybody can operate the equipment for screening. The federal government could just set some requirements and leave it to the private sectors like it used to be.

Crimson Possum's avatar

I said it from day one. The TSA is a Monument to bin Laden's success.

Catahoula Cur's avatar

Everything the government touches turns to garbage.

Mezzanotte's avatar

Fun libertarian academic argument.

In the real world, I hardly think airlines would find ways of performing the task more efficiently and with higher customer satisfaction. Airlines struggle to board/de-plane people efficiently, provide basic services on board, etc. How would we determine who does security well enough, to choose carriers? The feedback loop would be imperfect (e.g., one error could bring down an airline, while another airline that makes countless errors but doesn't have an incident continues on with a "perfect record").

This isn't an endorsement for TSA. Hardly. Just an argument against trusting airlines.

Dena's avatar

An airline I recently used started loading passengers first from the front instead of the back. It results in a bottleneck as they can’t begin more boarding until those in the front are in their seats. It takes longer now to board. I don’t fly much so maybe this isn’t that new.

Greg's avatar

Truer words never written.

Eric Porter's avatar

It's security theater like you say. With TSA Precheck you go through a metal detector. Anyone could take a ceramic knife through and probably even a boxcutter. They've enhanced the bag scanners but with how much stuff goes through someone could get a blade past them if it looked similar enough to a common object.

It's not the workers' fault. Nobody can process 15-20 bags per minute without making a mistake. They can't take apart every object that could possibly be a weapon.

rtko's avatar

Run by the airlines - yes., great solution. Government bureaucracies always grow. If the government hired private companies to do the job, then we’d end up with politicians owned by the industry just like we have with healthcare.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Always the same! that's why the current fedgov is in a financial "Doom Loop"!

Steve S's avatar

Ridiculous essay. Why not argue to privatize all the law enforcement agencies around the country, police, troopers, sheriffs, marshals, all federal LEOs get privatized. The fire departments also, privatize them all. Nonsense. These security functions are best run by the government, not be entities that put dollars and profit over the mission and public service function of the organization. TSA does a good job, as I can attest by the number of Swiss Army Knives I've lost by forgetting they were in my carry on or on my person. TSA caught them everytime.

ReadingRainbow's avatar

TSA does a good job if your metric is harassing Americans for things that aren’t crimes, sure. You realize air travel occurred for decades without the TSA and everything was fine?

Steve S's avatar

If you think having four planes taken over by terrorists on 9/11 who smuggled weapons aboard and resulted in thousands of dead Americans, then nothing I say will change your mind. The fact it hasn't happened again despite many attempts is all owing to TSA.

ReadingRainbow's avatar

Did you read the article? You know they have a 90% failure rate on their own tests? Scratch that, have you been through TSA? Have you seen the people working there? A mix of Chipotle drop outs bus drivers and aspiring middle school principals who got fired for being too unpleasant. Seal team six it isn’t.

Leaving aside the specifics of 9/11, the fact that one single tragedy justifies millions of wasted lifetimes in man hours and billions of wasted dollars in your eyes is why we aren’t going to make it.

Steve S's avatar

One single event? 9/11 was one single event?? That is how you minimize and describe the largest attack on American soil since Pearl Harbor. You sound like an imbecile.