12 Comments
User's avatar
The Radical Individualist's avatar

Have you ever noticed that the most die-hard supporters of socialism/communism work for government? That would included teachers at public supported colleges and universities, of which Harvard is one. (Suggesting that Harvard is not publicly supported is laughable.)

On the other hand, the most dedicated free-market capitalists exist (surprise!) in the free market.

Those government employed Marxists cannot survive on their own. They must receive 'public' funds, which come from free market capitalists.

HonestJon's avatar

One of the best articulated discussions of capitalism and marxism. True.

Boris Petrov's avatar

Bringing religious lunacy into economics 🤡

Rick Brown's avatar

If one is going to going to put a spotlight on ideologies or philosophies founded on bases which are antithetical to Christianity, and undoubtedly marxism is one such ideology or philosophy, in my view one should be selective, but rather apply the spotlight to all philosophies or ideologies in that category. Take liberalism, for example, which predates Marxism and at the foundation of which sits Jean Jacques Rousseau from whose theories the ideas of Karl Marx, among others, derive their legitimacy.

Like Marxism, liberalism is founded in atheism and has and continues to undermine Christian principles and values. Yet I have rarely seen the same clinical and comprehensive analysis of the foundations and consequences of liberalism.

I think that having a clear and informed understanding of ideologies and philosophies which are incompatible with Christian principles and values is important. However that extends to all ideologies and philosophies.

edmundlasch

Brandy's avatar

Yes! Even in my youth when I was more of a liberal, the ideas of Marxism, Communism, Socialism...they never made sense to me. I am someone who tries to understand why people believe what they believe. I want to know what it is they think they see. I can't grasp it as anything other than an envy that breeds resentment so large that one can't see straight. I understand some of it when one is young, but over 30??? There are old people who believe in this. I don't get it.

MR's avatar

Wait until this guy figures out that Capitalists funded The Bolsheviks. And Neocons are admitted Trotskyites.

Capitalism and Communism are not "opposed" to each other. They are two methods to reach the same end goal. Today we see the two blended.

Most people will never understand this.

Read Tragedy and Hope by Carroll Quigley for a start.

Steve Mudge's avatar

There has never been true communism in major countries, only on kibbutzes. They were good at overthrowing the yoke of Monarchial capitalism but never got farther along in Marx's process than install his temporary dictatorship.

There are two more or less pure capitalistic countries that I can think of---Somalia, which shows that pure capitalism devolves into a thugocracy, and Honduras' experiment, more libertarian, that seems to have lost its way.

Pure communism, capitalism, and libertarianism are ideals, utopian extremes, and the best countries incorporate the more reasonable aspects of all three.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

Define "country". Do you perhaps really mean "governments", as in the 'best governments'?

In my book, government answer to the citizens, not the other way around. My idea of the best government is one that does not make my decisions for me, but acknowledges my right to make my own plans, economics included.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jun 9, 2025
Comment removed
Steve Mudge's avatar

For sure. If we get a big reset, if it's bad enough we may get a sober consensus on amending our constitution/government to prevent some of this crap.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

For Communist "True Believers" any amount of suffering, pain and death (HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS IN THE 20TH CENTURY) is justified if there is even a theoretical possibility of the "immanetization of the Eschaton" (hat tip to Wm. F. Buckley, Jr.).

JTS's avatar

I have been going deep into the conflict between a exclusive deterministic causality that says we live in a clockwork universe. The La Place conjecture. I address the overwhelming scientific agreement based on math and logic that we live in a world of both some determinism (defined by algorithms and well defined parameters like mass, energy, time and acceleration). It is shared by another causality - emergence/self-organization. The latter is like magic compared to determinism. Pretending that modern the pure sciences looking at living things, behavior, consciousness and religion can explain everything is a myth with absolutely no logical or mathematical basis. They can not explain what is going to happen in a pandemic or guess what RNA therapy can do in all possibilities without testing. Biology, humanities, behavioral science etc have a completely different epistemology and method of validating truth.

Neither of these causalities can explain why anything exists.

Their false claims are un-based smugness that is the current face of the materialism. It has no valid claim to be more correct/scientific than peoples belief in religion and God. It, like socialists, communists, left ideologues, most academia and media are anti-religion.They flourish in jobs with no feedback from reality. Most people with long experience know that having more faith in government is totally divorced from experience.

My blog is thethirdmillennium.com. I have always believed that the link between religion and our constitution starts with "We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal that they are endowed by their creator..." Its all about the power starting with people and communities and families. Small to big vs big to small.

Tim Blum's avatar

Capitalism is not based on Judeo-Christian values but rather on man's inherent nature as a conceptual being requiring absolute liberty to choose which values are necessary for his long-term happiness, provided he does not infringe on the liberty of others. Self-sacrifice is central to all religious values, not just Christianity. Capitalism can not last if man's liberty is sacrificed, even on the margins, as it simply sets the principle from which the degree of self-sacrifice is parsed politically, thus leading us down the road to serfdom.