17 Comments
User's avatar
RKO's avatar

Sorry, this is just repeating the same old story - you want to change it, IMO is bring back being able to discharge student debt through bankruptcy. Put the risk of nonpayment back on the banks and schools.

erik bjorseth's avatar

Banks are not going to give an 18 year old with zero down payment a loan for $100K. Put the risk on the schools and their endowment funds.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Seven years after a BK you can start borrowing again. Kids who borrow recklessly for college should have that yoke around their necks if for no other reason than as a warning to peers.

erik bjorseth's avatar

Many issues with college:

1. The government should have never got into the business of student loans. An 18 year with no collateral should not have access to 100's of thousands of dollars. Once an industry sees their consumer with endless money - just keep raising the prices.

2. Colleges sit on billion dollar endowments, make them finance the kids education. If it's such a great deal - let them put their money where their mouths are.

3. Parents and public education - they are not teaching these kids when they are teenagers what a "Return on Investment" means. Spending $100K at 8% interest rate to get a degree in XYZ that pays $50K / year is not a got investment on their part. PERSONAL example. My grandparents went to Michigan University (great school) - but 25 years ago it was going to cost me $25K / year for out of state tuition versus staying in Iowa and spending $3K. I asked them if they would spot me the $88K difference - they said NO, so i stayed home and went to school.

4. These schools are more luxury hotels now than basic living. I thought living in a shit hole in college was a driving factor of succeeding and getting the fuck out of there. I know parents paying $2K / month for their kids housing.

5. With the future of AI - is going to college to get a basic degrees worth it? Parents are better off giving their kids $100K to invest at 18 and tell them to get a trade or skill and start working.

6. Kids can get a job too. When I was in school, i worked 4 days a week and made good money. I graduated with $10K in my account and no debt. I was taught as a kid that debt is bad.

Bill Lacey's avatar

What bank or lender grants loans to a borrower with no income and no collateral? In the real world the answer is NONE. In academic fantasyland, the gullible would say the loan is premised on future earnings. But where on a college loan application does it ask for the student’s intended major or area of study? If future earnings are the basis of the loan, that’s the key question, no? Yet that question isn’t asked because the lender doesn’t care. Like herpes, student loans are forever, not dischargeable under any circumstances (other than payment in full). It’s not wrong to conclude the student loan industry does not exist to help the student, but to funnel money to the Academic Industrial Complex. Until there are reforms, legislative and market-based, slavery by debt will continue. Putting normal market risk back on the lender via bankruptcy discharge would be a start. Requiring colleges to allocate a percentage of their endowments toward administrative costs would stop the expansion of non-academic functions such as DEI. In cases where family collateral is available, it should be used to secure the loan (when your house is on the line, parents will make sure Winnie and Theo are studying hard in a viable academic field). Lastly, the government being involved in the private sector only distorts the economics of that sector. Stop all Federal guarantees to Sallie Mae under FFELP.

ronetc's avatar

I was shocked, just a few minutes ago, visiting with my wife, to find out that her 57 year old sister is still paying off a student loan. Said sister has no college degree to show for it and only works temp jobs, so she will never make enough to pay off the loans. But I suppose she had a swell time for a couple of years playing at going to college with all the costs "paid" from the student loan. I do wonder if her debt will disappear with her death. She won't leave enough estate to pay it off, I am pretty sure.

DLB's avatar

After reading this article, I tried to find the tuition charged by Ohio State University in 1968, my first quarter at the school. What I found was ambiguous at best, as a figure of $27,000 was quoted in one article. It didn't say what was included in this figure, but what I paid for tuition was no where near that. I worked all summer to pay for the tuition, at $2.25 @ hour, and by fall I had enough to pay tuition for the next 3 quarters, or my freshman year. My memory is telling me the tuition was $150 @ quarter or $450 for the year. Books, fees etc., were extra. I lived at home, so room and board were free.

So if you take my $90 @ week gross pay, you can determine the tuition was in that realm, not the $27,000 I found in one article.

Plus, it's hard to find anything specific that details the tuition in that era, it's just not easy to find. I wonder why?

The tuition only, quoted for the current year 2025, is $13,244 which seems to be in line with other state schools. But that is still 30 times what it was in 1968.

If you compare the median home prices in 1968 vs 2025 you will find they have increased 16 times. $26,600 vs $422,800

The question is, why have college tuition costs increased at twice the rate of housing?

The answer is, because it could. The government made it easy to do so. A college education was taken from being a free market activity to one being manipulated by the government.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Coincidentally, applications to even name brand universities have fallen off a cliff. Maybe the value proposition for non-professional education is finally seeing the well deserved shakeout.

Petty Rage Machine's avatar

Yep. This about covers it. Government subsidies for school need to go. At least in their current, awful incarnation. You expect me to pay some of some kids school tuition? Then that kid needs to pass some sort of “credit check” which involves a close audit of what they are studying. Want to study Cultural Causes of Monkeypox? Not on my dime.

Tim Kennedy's avatar

With the advent of AI and the rise of remote learning opportunities, combined with the ridiculous admin fees to attend a sports team called “university.” How do I short colleges?

Steve Mudge's avatar

The taxpayers are not getting shafted, during the same period of tuition growth taxes have been cut. If appropriate revenue had been collected to balance the federal budget then you have an argument.

ronetc's avatar

Do you need to edit your post? I cannot follow the logic and/or grammar of your statement. This is not snarky, I just cannot understand the meaning of the words.

Raymundo's avatar

This isn’t a budget issue. At what tax rate does it become morally acceptable to transfer private debts to the public?

Steve Mudge's avatar

That's exactly my point, let's be consistent---if we're not giving away money to students let's stop giving away free money with tax cuts.

Raymundo's avatar

When I earn money in return for my labor, who does that money belong to, me or the government? If I'm a free man, then a tax cut is not a gift, it's just theft at a lower rate. A tax cut is only a gift from the government if I'm a slave.

Steve Mudge's avatar

If you are going to argue the pure Libertarian scenario we can't go much further with this. I like the idea of Libertarianism but it's an ideal, something where some aspects can be incorporated into a larger framework but at the size and complexity of many countries these days I don't find it practical (same with pure capitalism which devolves into thugocracy and pure socialism which , well, Venezuela). I mean I'm sympathetic to the cause and have tried to incorporate libertarian ideas into my business for 40 years but I just can't run with it 100 percent in all practicality.