Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MoodyP's avatar

A repeal of the 17th amendment would be a great place to begin. The Founders rejected direct election of Senators for a reason. Senators were intended to represent the specific interests of their states, providing a bulwark against Federalism being bent back against the interest of the states. Senators no longer represent their states interest. Instead, they are beholden to the special interests (some of whom you mentioned) who pour massive amounts of money (most of it coming from outside the state) into Senatorial campaigns.

Just imagine the difference in the politics of the Senate if direct election was abolished. Billions of influence dollars could no longer be spent by corporate interests. An entirely different set of characters (yes there would still be characters) would ultimately comprise the Senate. And Senators would be forced to represent the interests of their state first, or be guaranteed to be shown the door.

Lastly, the Founders understood the tendency of a federal governmental apparatus to expand over time…much of it done in ‘secret’ and usually to the detriment of the states. Part of the idea behind having State Legislators choose their Senator was to provide an always open window into the machinations in DC.

When one examines where Senatorial campaign contributions originate, more acutely of course in the less populated states, the percentage of money coming from outside the state is astonishing. A Senator elected from a less populated state might owe a fleeting allegiance to the voters. But his or her real benefactors are the corporations, special interests, think tanks, etc…that donated the tens of millions of dollars to the campaign…and have zero interest in the wellbeing of the Senator’s state.

It should come as no surprise (although it usually does given actual history has been memory holed) that the 17th amendment preceded the passage of the Federal Reserve Act by a mere 8 months. The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 directly contravened the interest of individual states. Although one can only speculate, the FRA might never have made it through the Senate if direct election had not been in place.

Jeanette's avatar

Add- get rid of the Dept of Education. There must be term limits for politicians.

31 more comments...

Ready for more?