15 Comments
User's avatar
The Radical Individualist's avatar

No matter how smart AI gets, it will never predict the roll of the dice any better than a guy playing craps.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

"Un coup de des jamais n'abolira le hasard" (Mallarme)

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Apr 6Edited
Comment deleted
The Radical Individualist's avatar

It's not the market that I'm worried about.

It's a fed and a federal government that makes sit up as they go along.

Frenchy's avatar

Then what is the solution to the growing polarization of wealth? Or is it a reality that we have to live with in your opinion?

george's avatar

end slavery. The word "slavery" was introduced to mask the first illegal immigrants.

Corvo Nero's avatar

"Gold is the money of kings, silver is the money of gentlemen, barter is the money of peasants – but debt is the money of slaves."

Corvo Nero's avatar

Isn't the insane percentage on your credit card debt very much a form of slavery ?

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Market economics dictated their importation but one could argue that their trajectory and that of their decendants is superior to those who remained behind. Markets ruthlessly put resources to their highest and best use when allowed to. Slaves learned skills with market value.

george's avatar

"Market Economics" is just another word for being too lazy and elitist to do the work yourself. You should revisit the history of the first Georgia Colony.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Everybody is getting richer, just some more than others. Sanding down the edges of that mutes innovation and risk taking while consuming resources in the process.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Not necessarily, some of our greatest innovations came post WWII when tax rates were sky high for the uber-wealthy. The thinking was, as I understand it, was not to punish the rich but rather encourage reinvestment of profits into new businesses as well as disincentivising a return to the Roaring 20s class divide.

Cranky Frankie's avatar

Nobody paid those rates. They were used to leverage those who would have had to pay them but for their ability to carve out exemptions of various kinds in exchange for support of incumbents. If you check you'll find that the overall tax take versus GDP has always hovered right around 19%.

Maybe the best example, used by Ronald Reagan to argue for tax simplification, was the loophole engineered by the Gallo Family of wine fame to skirt the inheritance tax laws.

The Technical and Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988, allowed grandparents to transfer up to $2 million per grandchild (totaling millions for the Gallo family) with reduced generation-skipping transfer taxes. This 1988–1989 loophole, which expired on December 31, 1989, was basically written for the Gallos. The clear intent was as a one-time use vehicle. There were many others similarly created to benefit particular families or industries based on their clout.

Tom's avatar

This author was (still is maybe?) an AAU basketball coach. My brother used to play on his team. Small world. Did not know he was an Econ prof with Austrian economics influence. Anyways, thanks for the article.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Prices are an "emergent" phenomenon resulting from the entire universe of inter-actions among and between every single human being on the planet. There is no conceivable computational matrix capable of duplicating that "universe" of factors. The reason, at least at present (and as far as we know, for good): the speed of light is a limit!

Dnevermore's avatar

I assume that any aliens that visit us are vastly advanced in AI and that got them here. However with AI that good and that advanced they don’t know how it works and if something breaks they don’t know how to fix it. Therefore aliens must be as dumb as rocks and barely able to function in the real world. If we ever get to a point where AI tries to run an economy we will be in that same situation. Perhaps not much different than today.