26 Comments
User's avatar
MTS Observer's avatar

As Jeff Deist and Bob Murphy have explained, MMT is not modern, not monetary and not a theory. It's more appropriately viewed as political propaganda playing on the compelling (to some) fantasy of creating something out of nothing.

Kelton's book, the Deficit Myth, is recommended reading in the sense that it will demystify the premises behind MMT and reveal its thorough malignance.

RU's avatar

Hearing people like Kelton (and Francis Collins, Fauci, Yellen, et al) makes it very obvious the emperors have no clothes. We're currently led by incompetent scam artists. These people haven't grappled with the basic ideas of their own fields of study, much less broader societal impacts. Or if they did grapple with them, they lost. I can now fully appreciate the term "useful idiots."

Erl Happ's avatar

No worries, just inflate it away. Except for all those whose incomes don't increase at the same rate those relying on superannuation, social services, renters and the unemployed.

Inversion's avatar

"Time is cruel master. So is compound interest." - Lawrence Lepard

https://inverttheinversion.substack.com/p/ch-112-money

TheyLiveAndWeLockdown's avatar

"The economics of this are not complex. Every economist knows there’s no such thing as a free lunch. Printing mass amounts of money cannot solve the problem of scarcity. This fundamental economic reality, that we have limited resources and limitless wants, seems lost on Kelton.

“The carpenter can’t run out of inches,” she tweeted in 2019. “The stadium can’t run out of points. The airline can’t run out of [frequent flier] miles. And the USA can’t run out of dollars.”

Kelton’s tweet reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of scarcity. "

Artificial Scarcity manufacturing is the establishments main income generator. So Global-Feudalist mouthpieces and useful idiots are unlikely to say it's a bad thing.

Rond's avatar

NPR is just the DNC's Pravda. Of course their angle is the deficit doesn't matter - if the powers that be started to think it did they'd be first to meet the headsman.

Perplexed Pete's avatar

As usual, everyone ignores the elephant in the room: private banks create all dollars, and the only way to get new dollars into circulation is by borrowing from banks (proofs at bankLIES.org). We will be forever trapped in endless cycles of booms, busts, and debt-traps if we don't abolish the bank-controlled money scam. The power of money creation needs to be taken away from private banks and restored to the government OR the free market.

craazyman's avatar

Dude. Mainstream economists in the 1980s said Reagan's deficits would destroy the country. Every deficit scare monger across American history has -- so far -- been wrong. Wrong. Wrong.

Eventually they will be right. I agree. But when? That's the question.

So far, nobody has a systematic, lucid way of thinking about that with any empirical success.

Instead, it's all polemics.

Wake me up when you do.

Mark Heywood's avatar

It's the debt not the deficits, and the time when shit will blow up is when no one is buying treasuries except the Fed, and that time is now.

craazyman's avatar

You could be right. That's a very plausible idea, I agree.

Time will tell. But an equally "interesting" question is: why is nobody buying it except the Fed? That's not so easy, and in my view gets in to complicated cultural analysis. It's hard to reduce that to a threshold number, i.e. after the debt gets to "x" nobody buys it.

Michael Waldmeier DMD, PhD's avatar

It may increase until it reaches a panic-level. Then events happen quickly.

craazyman's avatar

Yep, the old Hemingway bankruptcy quote, "Gradually then suddenly".

I don't in any way dispute the size of the debt or the potential problem. But I'm a little burnt out from years of Doom&Gloom that never seems to come true. And I've believed it -- I'm a sucker for macro doom & gloom! I was gullible and credulous. Every doom & gloom I looked up and saw an asteroid. But it hasn't happened! Another one: We've had 10+ years of "Europe is going to implode any day now, Target 2 balances are off the charts. There'll be rebellions and revolutions among the PIGS. (Portugal, Italy, Spain, Greece_) The euro is toast." Yada yada. Never happened. Maybe some day, yes.

Everyone here knows US debt at end of WW2 was about where it is now as a % of GDP. What happened after? We know that too.

Will this time be different. Sure. Maybe. Maybe it will all explode next month. Or next year. Or in 10 years. Or the dollar will crater next year, or this year. I don't know. But one thing I've learned, I can imagine lots of things that never happen. Why they didn't happen? That gets complicated. And I rarely see anyone seriously grapple with that question.

Andrew Simpson's avatar

You're right: I remember that time – $100 billion deficit was going to end life as we knew it. But in hindsight, Reagan started with a debt/GDP - roughly 30% - that was the lowest in the last 80 years. For an empirical analysis, and a rough answer as to the "But when?" "This Time is Different: Eight Centuries of Financial Folly", is thorough, detailed, yet surprisingly readable. Are we richer today than then? Yes, but there's an argument that absent the pile of debt, we'd actually be even richer. See Hoisington Management's quarterly economic reviews - free on-line, some of which are readable.

Xingyi's avatar

NPR disgusts me. It absolutely is the case of extorting my money to purvey, preach, proselytize, and other spread putrid filth to which I reject at every level imaginable. It's very similar to the plan where, despite having no children, my money is stolen via property taxes and used to teach children to hate people like me and the values in which I believe (i.e., individual liberty, responsibility, and freedom).

They are the court or at least a significant layer or even stronghold of it, for the Court Intellectuals to be given the heir of legitimacy.

svboy's avatar

This article was well written at the start and then he/she moved into conspiracy theories and NPR! Gimme a break. They are showing an opposing point of view and for most people, who think, it is good to know all points of view to make informed decisions.

Jim L's avatar

Thanks for putting Murray Rothbard back on my radar. What an excellent summation of what I've suspected for decades.

Burnt taco's avatar

"It’s unclear why the media network chose to interview an economist with such discredited views to explain away the country’s mountain of debt."

Not really. NPR is the intellectual propaganda wing of the Dem party. And we must all know that the economy is just fine, there is no inflation, prices are not really high, and the debt never really comes due. Vote Blue... Morons!

Vanda Salvini's avatar

Kelton doesn't know anything about the rest of the world. Countries with command economies, i.e., communist, thought they could print money to infinity.

Money printers eventually break and so do the countries that used them. Bad management is bad management at any level, household or state level.

The US doesn't feel it right now because it's an election year and you-know-who will keep things looking pretty until at least the end of the year. After that, especially if DJT wins, look out world.

Ed Meyer's avatar

As I understand it, government has three ways to pay debt. Go bankrupt and collapse, pay it off, and thru the use of inflation. Seems like our government has chosen the third course, but I'm pretty sure we are headed for the first. Of course, the second option is completely out of the question....

Michael Waldmeier DMD, PhD's avatar

Craazyman raised a lot of good points that I thought about for quite awhile. In the Spring of 1914, there was significant discussion by the British that there would never be a war again on the Continent. We know how that turned out. Here in Germany, the Germans 30 years ago didn't have enough kids to replace themselves, Chancellor Merkel welcomed the migrants many of whom have a cultural background incompatible with civilization, voted for more socialism and fascism (Gov't control of information especially with regards to the virus and the lives of its citizens) and the impossible-to-achieve "green" energy and food goals. At the very least I see inflation and some defaults occuring and this could be gradual or a factor could spark a crisis. We will experience something.