This all checks out. Glad I'm not the only one who sees that our system has been slowly colonized and overtaken by something altogether incompatible with its original intent and which is deeply malevolent.
Well, the labels are all outdated. abused over the decades, and saddled with baggage. But, if we're going to use the old labels...capitalism would be the financial/economic correlate of democracy. It's economic voice and economic freedom for individuals. It's free association b/w parties exchanging goods or services with minimal micromanagement from the government's central planning busy-bodies. Allow the people to figure it out themselves, including how to punish the predatory actors.
It becomes not-capitalism when the government overrides foundational principles and the natural checks and balances of the system and uses its monopoly on violence to unnaturally favor some players over others. E.g., Pfizer wins; small farmers making healthy food must lose. Raytheon wins; the working poor of Appalachia lose their lives in wars. Big Ag wins; school kids get to eat poison for lunch via government mandate (artificial, forced "demand"). The MiC that we know is the root problem is also the government; and as such it is anti-capitalist.
The government has created barriers to entry, effected stifling operational costs, caused near monopolies, and punishes both new and existing market entrants who refuse to play the game or threaten the status quo. Ask any small business owner (the people leftists should be championing) what their #1 business problem is and 100% of them will tell you it's the labyrinth of government laws and regulations that favor massive businesses...massive businesses that just happen to be the biggest clients of government.
The parallels to personal freedom and democratic voice are obvious. It's the same way democracy ceases to be democracy when the government tramples on foundational rights like free speech, freedom of association, and the right to defend oneself, one's property, and one's loved ones.
This system we have inherited is not capitalism (just as we no longer have legitimate democracy). This is not what a government looking to foster capitalism would do. Instead of creating monopolies, forcing demand for bad products, and driving out competition and small players, a government fostering capitalism would do the exact opposite.
So, as he was with covid, J Tucker is right: this is best known as fascism. It's pretty much how Mussolini (originally a Socialist) designed his system. Ostensibly "private" companies actually acting on behalf of government carrying out the government's aims (and making all of them rich/powerful as hell in the process).
I don't trust anyone who wears a Bow Tie. We have socialized losses and privatized gains. ONE person went to jail after 2008, not Diamon, Pandit,Mozillo, Bernanke, or any of the people who sliced and diced money, sold them to us and bet against them. We have socialized mortgages, the EU has socialized health care, mortgages are private. Not better (maybe) but different. The Pentagon can't be audited. I am against a tax on unrealized gains, but didn't much of that come from the Cantillion effect, PPP fraud, 10 years of free money thanks to Fed policies, borrowing free and buying back stocks, few of which were available or perhaps dribbled onto us plebes? You're pissed off about college loans? (#Me too). That's a drible.
Where is the gold in Ft. Knox? Does it exist? Enquiring minds want to know.
I was thinking of going to see Oasis in the UK next year and I was looking at hotels in Manchester on the day of the concert and I checked a random day and they were about triple the regular price. I mentioned this to a friend and he said "That's capitalism for you" and I was like I'm pretty sure hotels/room renting and also the concept of charging a higher price for a good that is in higher in demand existed before capitalism. Like we don't say oh man this guy is charging more for a gold bar than an onion, that's capitalism for you!
Update: I did not get a ticket because I didn't feel like staying up until the middle of the night in North America when they went on sale in UK morning time and the demand was so high that they basically sold out right away. Thanks alot, capitalism.
I agree with the point you are making, but I think you are missing the mark on what constitutes 'capitalism.'
Capitalism is not some synonym for 'free markets'. 'Free markets' is intuitive. If you can buy and sell as you please, with only minimal regulation, that's a free market. We don't have much in the way of free markets these days.
Here's my definition of capitalism: Capitalism exists when there are concentrations of money, natural resources and manpower so as to create the most efficient production of goods and services possible. And obvious example is factories.
Factories, and therefore capitalism, exist everywhere. They exist in free market economies and in communist economies. It is not the capitalism that is bad. We can't have the lives we have without it. It is the oligarchic manipulation of it by political parties and the governments that they control that are the problem.
Unfortunately, subliminal behavioral modification (formerly known as brainwashing) becomes more powerful as people inhale the miasma of social media and allow their skills of verification and education to atrophy. Marx was the first to associate “capitalism” with elitism & suppression, and his subtle spices have been baked into the concept forever. If a word elicits immediate anger and reactivity, slamming the door of openness and curiosity, then the one who is reacting should immediately question if they are experiencing a conditioned response and are therefore a regurgitator- not a student of new & creative content. We are all susceptible. It is a purposeful and carefully constructed weapon of enlightenment used by authoritarians. Beware!!!!
Check out The Myth of Capitalism by Jonathan Tepper. I think it’s the most important book written in the last ten years. It’s a shame it’s not required reading in college classrooms.
It’s also a shame it hasn’t been picked up and translated by an international publisher. It would go a long way in terms of explaining our dysfunction to the rest of the world.
If you read it and like it, please spread word to your audience.
This all checks out. Glad I'm not the only one who sees that our system has been slowly colonized and overtaken by something altogether incompatible with its original intent and which is deeply malevolent.
Well, the labels are all outdated. abused over the decades, and saddled with baggage. But, if we're going to use the old labels...capitalism would be the financial/economic correlate of democracy. It's economic voice and economic freedom for individuals. It's free association b/w parties exchanging goods or services with minimal micromanagement from the government's central planning busy-bodies. Allow the people to figure it out themselves, including how to punish the predatory actors.
It becomes not-capitalism when the government overrides foundational principles and the natural checks and balances of the system and uses its monopoly on violence to unnaturally favor some players over others. E.g., Pfizer wins; small farmers making healthy food must lose. Raytheon wins; the working poor of Appalachia lose their lives in wars. Big Ag wins; school kids get to eat poison for lunch via government mandate (artificial, forced "demand"). The MiC that we know is the root problem is also the government; and as such it is anti-capitalist.
The government has created barriers to entry, effected stifling operational costs, caused near monopolies, and punishes both new and existing market entrants who refuse to play the game or threaten the status quo. Ask any small business owner (the people leftists should be championing) what their #1 business problem is and 100% of them will tell you it's the labyrinth of government laws and regulations that favor massive businesses...massive businesses that just happen to be the biggest clients of government.
The parallels to personal freedom and democratic voice are obvious. It's the same way democracy ceases to be democracy when the government tramples on foundational rights like free speech, freedom of association, and the right to defend oneself, one's property, and one's loved ones.
This system we have inherited is not capitalism (just as we no longer have legitimate democracy). This is not what a government looking to foster capitalism would do. Instead of creating monopolies, forcing demand for bad products, and driving out competition and small players, a government fostering capitalism would do the exact opposite.
So, as he was with covid, J Tucker is right: this is best known as fascism. It's pretty much how Mussolini (originally a Socialist) designed his system. Ostensibly "private" companies actually acting on behalf of government carrying out the government's aims (and making all of them rich/powerful as hell in the process).
I don't trust anyone who wears a Bow Tie. We have socialized losses and privatized gains. ONE person went to jail after 2008, not Diamon, Pandit,Mozillo, Bernanke, or any of the people who sliced and diced money, sold them to us and bet against them. We have socialized mortgages, the EU has socialized health care, mortgages are private. Not better (maybe) but different. The Pentagon can't be audited. I am against a tax on unrealized gains, but didn't much of that come from the Cantillion effect, PPP fraud, 10 years of free money thanks to Fed policies, borrowing free and buying back stocks, few of which were available or perhaps dribbled onto us plebes? You're pissed off about college loans? (#Me too). That's a drible.
Where is the gold in Ft. Knox? Does it exist? Enquiring minds want to know.
I was thinking of going to see Oasis in the UK next year and I was looking at hotels in Manchester on the day of the concert and I checked a random day and they were about triple the regular price. I mentioned this to a friend and he said "That's capitalism for you" and I was like I'm pretty sure hotels/room renting and also the concept of charging a higher price for a good that is in higher in demand existed before capitalism. Like we don't say oh man this guy is charging more for a gold bar than an onion, that's capitalism for you!
Update: I did not get a ticket because I didn't feel like staying up until the middle of the night in North America when they went on sale in UK morning time and the demand was so high that they basically sold out right away. Thanks alot, capitalism.
I agree with the point you are making, but I think you are missing the mark on what constitutes 'capitalism.'
Capitalism is not some synonym for 'free markets'. 'Free markets' is intuitive. If you can buy and sell as you please, with only minimal regulation, that's a free market. We don't have much in the way of free markets these days.
Here's my definition of capitalism: Capitalism exists when there are concentrations of money, natural resources and manpower so as to create the most efficient production of goods and services possible. And obvious example is factories.
Factories, and therefore capitalism, exist everywhere. They exist in free market economies and in communist economies. It is not the capitalism that is bad. We can't have the lives we have without it. It is the oligarchic manipulation of it by political parties and the governments that they control that are the problem.
Unfortunately, subliminal behavioral modification (formerly known as brainwashing) becomes more powerful as people inhale the miasma of social media and allow their skills of verification and education to atrophy. Marx was the first to associate “capitalism” with elitism & suppression, and his subtle spices have been baked into the concept forever. If a word elicits immediate anger and reactivity, slamming the door of openness and curiosity, then the one who is reacting should immediately question if they are experiencing a conditioned response and are therefore a regurgitator- not a student of new & creative content. We are all susceptible. It is a purposeful and carefully constructed weapon of enlightenment used by authoritarians. Beware!!!!
Thanks for posting this, Chris.
Check out The Myth of Capitalism by Jonathan Tepper. I think it’s the most important book written in the last ten years. It’s a shame it’s not required reading in college classrooms.
It’s also a shame it hasn’t been picked up and translated by an international publisher. It would go a long way in terms of explaining our dysfunction to the rest of the world.
If you read it and like it, please spread word to your audience.