Let's make one thing abundantly clear: By September 2024 the latest, everyone should have been 100% confident, that the FED is a political actor and its main motivations are NOT employment and inflation but rather:
1. Maintaining US geopolitical positions
2. Making sure the treasury remains liquid.
I mean, a quick glimpse at the CPI shows, that the CPI actually bottomed in May 2020. It took the FED a whole TWENTY-TWO MONTHS to realize inflation is back on the menu, all the while we were hearing things like "we are not even thinking about thinking" and "it's transitory" from the same Powell who is Mr. Super Hawkish FED chairman today.
So when exactly did the FED begin to hike? March 2022. What happened then? Hmmmm... let's see, what happened on the 22nd of February, 2022. Yup, that's right, Russia invaded Ukraine. The whole rate hike (Which was the most agressive hike in FED's history given the shortage of time and extent of rate hikes) was about causing global recession and pushing down oil prices, and NOT about the CPlie being 9.6% at the top. If anything, the US NEEDS high inflation because of the high debt burden. Except, the geopolitical alpha was more important at the time.
Then exhibit no. 2 was when Jim Bianco on a Macrovoices podcast said in May 2022 that the FED has to cut in June, otherwise, if they cut in September, it will be a blatant support for the dems in the election. TA-DAAAA, they cut 0.5% in September. Again, the FED is a political animal, and not an independent actor in US finance and economy.
Now, we have this situation extended, because 1. Powell likes the dems and hates Trump and 2. Powell wants to be Paul Volcker and not Arthur Burns. He wants to go retire as the FED chairman who broke the back of inflation, not the one who cut to support the economy.
So this could culminate into quite a risk off period in Q3 and Q4 2025. Q2 earnings of the Mag 7 will likely disappoint in August, because of the trade wars in April (which were very neatly timed exactly at the beginning of Q2, so that they don't show off in Q1 earnings). If the stock market goes, so does the US treasury, and of course, if hedge funds have to liquidate something because of equities losses, they will sell bonds. April 2025 reloaded: stocks go, and rates go up. If the FED doesn't come in with the FED put, we can get REALLY screwed.
More concerning than the political bias is the fact that most of the people on the Fed board seem to be incompetent morons. For example this gem:
"Inflation is too low relative to the FOMC's 2 percent objective. In fact, it has been too low for the past six years, and it is hard to see inflation heading up to target any time soon. This worries me quite a bit." - Chicago Fed Chair Charles Evans, 2015
There are a lot of similar quotes from other Fed members complaining about low inflation prior to 2022.
Hold the line Powell. Ask me rates need to be a little higher and kept there for as long as humanly possible.
We need an opposite policy to reflect true risk pricing. I know thats a goldilocks scenario but we've been so far removed from normalization, we have become stuck in the political necessity of dirt cheap money.
I love your commentary and generally agree with most of your takes. But I also do follow many other thinkers and am always interested when they view similar issues differently. Tom Luongo and his GGG Market Reports are fantastic and I listen to them every week.
His take on the Trump/Powell dynamic is a different one. I’m not sure I’m convinced, but I think it’s worth considering. His sense is that all the verbiage (“numskull”) is pure theater. Supposedly, Bessent and Powell have coffee almost every day, and are in far greater communication than one might think. Luongo’s theory is that Powell has been waiting for Trump to put some ‘wins on the board’, something the Israel/Iran at-least-temporary detante may qualify for, and now has the cover (with the weak jobs report, etc.) to drop rates. He thinks he’ll drop 50 BPS; this seems a little overconfident to me, but I’m very curious to see if it happens. I am willing to accept Luongo’s premise that all the bluster from Trump is simply meant to play to the base and doesn’t really reflect anything that is going on behind the scenes. We shall see!
We discuss FED independence, but how can that be done in the face of the banks interests? Which are not necessarily full employment and low inflation…. Blows one’s mind…
“risk losing credibility” uh, that ship has sailed with the transitory fairytale and twenty other politically motivated decisions of the fed in the last five years
Let's make one thing abundantly clear: By September 2024 the latest, everyone should have been 100% confident, that the FED is a political actor and its main motivations are NOT employment and inflation but rather:
1. Maintaining US geopolitical positions
2. Making sure the treasury remains liquid.
I mean, a quick glimpse at the CPI shows, that the CPI actually bottomed in May 2020. It took the FED a whole TWENTY-TWO MONTHS to realize inflation is back on the menu, all the while we were hearing things like "we are not even thinking about thinking" and "it's transitory" from the same Powell who is Mr. Super Hawkish FED chairman today.
So when exactly did the FED begin to hike? March 2022. What happened then? Hmmmm... let's see, what happened on the 22nd of February, 2022. Yup, that's right, Russia invaded Ukraine. The whole rate hike (Which was the most agressive hike in FED's history given the shortage of time and extent of rate hikes) was about causing global recession and pushing down oil prices, and NOT about the CPlie being 9.6% at the top. If anything, the US NEEDS high inflation because of the high debt burden. Except, the geopolitical alpha was more important at the time.
Then exhibit no. 2 was when Jim Bianco on a Macrovoices podcast said in May 2022 that the FED has to cut in June, otherwise, if they cut in September, it will be a blatant support for the dems in the election. TA-DAAAA, they cut 0.5% in September. Again, the FED is a political animal, and not an independent actor in US finance and economy.
Now, we have this situation extended, because 1. Powell likes the dems and hates Trump and 2. Powell wants to be Paul Volcker and not Arthur Burns. He wants to go retire as the FED chairman who broke the back of inflation, not the one who cut to support the economy.
So this could culminate into quite a risk off period in Q3 and Q4 2025. Q2 earnings of the Mag 7 will likely disappoint in August, because of the trade wars in April (which were very neatly timed exactly at the beginning of Q2, so that they don't show off in Q1 earnings). If the stock market goes, so does the US treasury, and of course, if hedge funds have to liquidate something because of equities losses, they will sell bonds. April 2025 reloaded: stocks go, and rates go up. If the FED doesn't come in with the FED put, we can get REALLY screwed.
It's Prime Day, time to buy a new keyboard to fix the T changing to CH.
More concerning than the political bias is the fact that most of the people on the Fed board seem to be incompetent morons. For example this gem:
"Inflation is too low relative to the FOMC's 2 percent objective. In fact, it has been too low for the past six years, and it is hard to see inflation heading up to target any time soon. This worries me quite a bit." - Chicago Fed Chair Charles Evans, 2015
There are a lot of similar quotes from other Fed members complaining about low inflation prior to 2022.
Hold the line Powell. Ask me rates need to be a little higher and kept there for as long as humanly possible.
We need an opposite policy to reflect true risk pricing. I know thats a goldilocks scenario but we've been so far removed from normalization, we have become stuck in the political necessity of dirt cheap money.
Powell is only protecting his.."share holders" who are collecting the interest.
Trump nominated Powell. so live with it and wait for May 26
Chris,
I love your commentary and generally agree with most of your takes. But I also do follow many other thinkers and am always interested when they view similar issues differently. Tom Luongo and his GGG Market Reports are fantastic and I listen to them every week.
His take on the Trump/Powell dynamic is a different one. I’m not sure I’m convinced, but I think it’s worth considering. His sense is that all the verbiage (“numskull”) is pure theater. Supposedly, Bessent and Powell have coffee almost every day, and are in far greater communication than one might think. Luongo’s theory is that Powell has been waiting for Trump to put some ‘wins on the board’, something the Israel/Iran at-least-temporary detante may qualify for, and now has the cover (with the weak jobs report, etc.) to drop rates. He thinks he’ll drop 50 BPS; this seems a little overconfident to me, but I’m very curious to see if it happens. I am willing to accept Luongo’s premise that all the bluster from Trump is simply meant to play to the base and doesn’t really reflect anything that is going on behind the scenes. We shall see!
Interesting & plausible.
We discuss FED independence, but how can that be done in the face of the banks interests? Which are not necessarily full employment and low inflation…. Blows one’s mind…
The vast majority of the electorate has no clue about any of this. All they care about is not included in the inflation calculations.
If rates go to near zero again. Who buys treasury bonds to finance our debt? Are banks required to buy them with their deposits or something?
“risk losing credibility” uh, that ship has sailed with the transitory fairytale and twenty other politically motivated decisions of the fed in the last five years