"Do we have ANY idea who we are even negotiating with". Answer : yes, yes we do. The idea that Iran has nobody to negotiate with is a propaganda point.
Abbas Araghchi is their foreign minister. Mohammad Ghalibaf is their Parliament Speaker. Ali Akbar Ahmadian is the Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council. Abdolnaser Hemmati is the Central Bank Governor. Other members of pariliament are reported to be in attendance.
For those killed in this war:
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei replaced by his son
Ali Larijani replaced by Mohammad Bagher Zolghadr, former deputy commander of the IRGC.
Amir Ali Hajizadeh replaced by Majid Mousavi (formerly his deputy)
To me all of these are just names, but CIA/Mossad would have comprehensive intelligence on every one of the replacements, since they have intent to target and kill them. It's also clear that when the leaders of Iran are killed, they are being replaced by individuals already embedded in the highest levels of the government. For all of Israel's faults, I do think Mossad is good at collecting intel - what is done with that is another matter.
Trump intends this to be his historical contribution to the civilized world. I don't see him backing down and he will probably be on hand as the uranium and plutonium are delivered to us. He is not running for re-election and cares little for the other Republicans. The guy is dug in.
His military is having a field day with a costless campaign of precision utter destruction of a generation's worth of Iranian military assets. Those flyboys live for this. Shooting fish in a barrel. It's been compared to a high school team up against the NFL.
This will be two weeks to reload and refresh. EU nations are sending minesweepers for the strait because they have to since the EU is where the oil pain is concentrated. The same EU leaders who made fun of him are now feeling the sting of the lash from their own constituients. Bonus for that.
And if Iran hasn't agreed to hand over their refined material and to inspections on IAEA's terms then the shooting will start right up again. Elon's Starlink is running a cell service with access to a Telegram-style encrypted text service for ordinary Iranians. Out of their homes for two weeks they'll provide coordinates for a whole new set of targets to hit.
And Congress will trip over its own feet when Trump announces that the cease fire resets the 60 day clock. Trump will dare the Congress to take a vote to rewind the progress made in Iran (and the greater MidEast generally). They won't.
Your Glorious Leader has ALREADY left them with their uranium AND control of the Strait.
Last July Trump said he “destroyed Iran’s nuclear program, never to be rebuilt.” Then 7 months later, in February, he said they were “2 weeks away from making a nuclear bomb.” MAGAbots clapped like trained seals at both proclamations. No one has yet asked, “Did Trump lie in July, or did he lie in February?”
“Trump is their last hope.” What a shame you could not see what Trump was after the first four years of his grift. Self-aggrandizement. Toxic narcissism. Lie after lie. (Lock her up. I’ll build a big, beautiful wall all across the southern border. Repeal and replace Obamacare. Two weeks to flatten the curve.) You voted for Trump a second (third?) time, and you’re finally getting what you voted for — massive inflation caused (First) by his declaration of an illegal tariff war against the whole world (and Second) by causing massive fuel price increases due to closing the Strait. Not to mention worldwide food shortages caused by stopping fertilizer shipments through the Strait, and just maybe — because he sent massive munitions to Ukraine and exhausted the U.S. arms surplus in Iran — a U.S. invasion by China that we cannot stop because we have nothing left but nukes (can’t nuke invaders on American soil. Duh!). Yes, Trump did that.
You brainless MAGAbots see everything as binary — if i don’t support Trump then i must support Biden/Harris, etc. Delusional! Your complete lack of awareness is astounding. I have not voted for a Democrat since my young and stupid college days, when i voted for Carter in 1976. In 2024, I voted for Ron DeSantis, a true conservative (not a life-long New York Democrat who magically became a “Republican” during an escalator ride in 2015). With DeSantis, we would have had a rock-solid conservative running America for 8 years, instead of an 80-year-old grifter with cognitive issues (explained by his toadies as “4D chess” or “strategic unpredictability”) who likely will not even complete his 4 year term. What do I mean?
Trump will certainly lose the House in the Midterms, leading to his impeachment yet again. The difference this time will be the Senate, which may flip Democrat over Trump’s adventurism in Iran, but even if not, there will be a few Republicans — those who actually believe in the Constitution instead of tribalism — who will join the Democrats in removing Trump from office. Then we’ll get Vance, who is not smart enough to be President. (Trump picks people like Pence and Vance specifically because they’re dumber that he is, just like Biden did with Harris.)
As i said above, Republicans could have had 8 years of rock-solid conservative leadership, but no, it was more important for MAGA to get revenge for 2020 than choose the best person in 2024. Frankly, Republicans suck at strategic thinking, and America — far from being “First” — is circling the drain because of Trump. And yes, THAT is what you voted for.
The outcomes of the negotiations will hardly be the end of conflict. Regardless of the promises from both sides, you can count on Israel to be left unsatisfied, and precedents show that their interests will eventually be supported by the US.
America has been killing people all over the world my whole life. Please stop with the "murdering regimes" nonsense, especially when you now know how USAID was applied.
A shame you haven't lived in Iran for a few years spouting opinions, see how long you'd last. It's very easy cursing the US from inside the US or some other safe western country where you can say what you like.
I'd do alright. People (men AND women) post things on social media and Telegram all the time. Perhaps you should be more concerned with what's happening in your own backyard rather than some spot on the other side of the world?
I saw what I needed to when photos of "human shields" appeared after Trump threatened destruction of electrical and water plants. The shields were all women and girls. Expendable for them, I guess.
I've never read such rubbish from an 'intelligent' person. If you've read what Japan did in the 1930's, murdering and torturing across Asia on a vast scale, considered what German Nazis did in Europe (25 million dead in Russia alone) then Trump's very brave and noble move to stop Iran before it becomes a REALLY big problem should be massively supported by all sensible people. Whining armchair critics of Trump (90% of the Communist US media) have yet to tell us what the alternatives are. You think you can 'negotiate' with religious fanatics, bent on getting nukes?? That's for children. WW2 could have been/should have been stopped in 1936 when Hitler reoccupied the Rhineland but European leaders didn't have the balls. If Trump had been around at the time, WW2 would never have happened.
I was thinking the same thing, except in a very different direction. Schiff has it wrong because he believes in U.S. lies spun re: the extent of damage done to Iran and apparently believes Iran is "objectively obliterated". Hurt to be sure, but they are winning.
They are winning in the same sense the The Black Knight defeated King Arthur in Monty Python's Holy Grail, while armless and legless the knight still refuses to concede defeat and declares victory over King Arthur, who simply steps around him because who gives a shit what the Black Knight fool has to say.
Only if you define winning as hunkered down in a bunker while your entire arsenal, acquired over decades, is reduced to a smoking ruin. Maybe winning doesn't require being still alive. I don't know.
You need to find better sources of analysis to understand what is happening re: this war. Schiff is terrific when it comes to economics and precious metals, but clearly knows little re: Iran and the current military situation. Iran is hurt but certainly not "objectively obliterated". It is a huge country with distributed infrastructure. Tel Aviv and the Arab states are much more badly hurt as Iran's strikes geographically concentrate within the much smaller territory of Israel and specific high-value military and energy assets in GCC countries.
Iran appears likely to be able to continue punching for at least several more months if not years, with material stockpiled for decades and resupply from Russia/China. There's no evidence Iran's military has been significantly weakened by any measure that matters, and their government appears strengthened as the citizens have rallied nightly. Worse for U.S./Israel, we are running out of the standoff munitions that so far have allowed us to strike deep without putting our aircraft at great(er) risk. The aircraft losses late last week appear likely to be the result of a failed uranium extraction operation (another reason Trump is desperate). We would see much worse if we try to do deep bombing missions directly over Tehran. Iran is not impervious, but still appears to possess significant air defense capability.
Frankly, I'd go so far as to suggest Schiff exposes a significant anti-Iranian bias. He mocks Iranians seeing us as the 'evil empire'. Well, it fits. We kill over 160 children with a Tomahawk with zero accountability. We call Iranians liars - claim they bombed their own children, and appear to not even want to investigate the matter.
'better sources', hilarious, and you believe them? Yes Iran is an evil empire by any measures, most clearly expressed by Iranians suffering there, plenty of evidence. Iran has had 47 years building its murderous systems, it will take more than a few weeks to defang them, to the huge benefit of Iranian people. Sadly some innocents will suffer in that process but ultimately, the entire region will be safer.
Maybe If the CIA hadn't overthrown the democratic Iranian government in 1953 and installed a brutal dictator none of this would be happening now. But speaking of evil empires how do you categorize the US invasions of Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya. Millions of civilians killed or displaced. To quote Ricky Watters former NFL player "For who, for what?".
No, it's not always our fault. Oh hey, Cartero, let's add Ukraine to the list. Got it? Great! Oh sorry, so as I was saying Cranky, you may be right there could be a few wars that aren't our fault.
So true. I voted for Trump and a I want him to succeed — still. I hope JD Vance wins in 2028. Many of those sources supported Trump too. Some still do.
They are all serious thinkers and I would say Patriots too. I’d put John Mearsheimer on the list and Jeffrey Sachs, though I am not tying either to any politician.
We can be “for Trump” and opposed to these military adventures.
There were two successful regime change wars in American history,
1) Civil War
2) WW2
The rest were Smedley Butler style shit fights. Or they were Red Tide scares. You look at Vietnam in past 30 years and you’d think USA won that one,.
That’s it. Both permanent regime changes required a ground invasion and occupation. Is somebody willing to ground invade Iran and occupy it till we bend a 3000 year old culture to our largely British Isles style of Enlightenment political theory?
Cause that’s what it would take. Hello?
Right “NO” that’s what I thought.
Oh but aren’t we teaching them a lesson and kicking their ass? Hmm. Geopolitics isn’t a boxing match. Or a cage fight. Get real.
“…what happens during negotiations over the next few weeks is crucial.” The biggest problem is that there is no one on the Iranian side to negotiate with, because he was killed within the first 24 hours of bombing. Iran’s president is a figurehead, the IRGC units are running on autopilot, and their “Supreme Leader” is a piece of cardboard representing a comatose guy in Russia. Maybe Biden should send cardboard Khomeini his autopen.
Being only an engineer I always have an answer and sit in wonder why Trump's Dept. of War is not consulting with me.
-- use the long-time Medieval, Genghis Khan siege: cut off their water and supply lines(blockade all their protected harbors on their shores with sunken ships)
-- Close the spigot on Kharg the easy way: special forces closes the valves out to the load docks; install a fortress FOB there and support with overwhelming Predator and warthog and Navy forces; blockade on ALL shipping into / out of Kharg.
-- start at two extremes both North and South of Kharg on the shore and turn every town and military installation to DUST
-- Kill every power plant in Kharg and surrounding the strait of Hormuz in Iran
-- Warn ALL ships away for 10 miles; anything floating will be sunk-- period.
-- use Israeli intelligence and agents inside Tehran to continue to target ALL Iranian IRGC and politicals; massive elimination of ALL.
-- Bomb mercilessly all roads into Tehran and Kharg.
-- After all this, assess; if possible go in and get the U238.
-- Walk away and let the local countries clean up the mess, arming them with OUR missiles(land to land only)
Too bad the UN and Europe were not around in Genghis Khan‘s time. The UN would have voted to sanction him and send him frowny faces over his conquests. Then they would have convened a tribunal in Nuremberg to examine his actions against “humanity.” Europe, who had nothing to do with his battles (just like they eschewed getting involved in the Iran conflict), would afterward bitch and moan about how “unfair” he was being and tell him what he SHOULD be doing to make things right.
But most anyone, does not have to be an engineer, would design backup generator systems that cannot be flooded under the most extreme circumstances. Tsunami's are common in the Pacific. Fukishima is right on the ocean, so. . .
The Reactor kept running until they could not be cooled; the generators were not keeping the cooling pumps running. Reactors working just fine all the time. . .
Right, I jest re: Fukashima but have you thought about why we haven't implemented your plan? We are capable of destroying every Iranian oil terminal and taking Kharg, but we cannot defend against the retaliation or escape the economic consequences when ME oil generation is destroyed for a generation.
Well, I am more optimistic than you are apparently. I believe Trump DOES, in fact, have America's interest at heart. Probably not out of his own altruism but out of his own greed, partially, and then some REAL sense too of what America means.
My belief about Trumpie's intent is that he is a smart human; he will not shoot his businesses in the foot by wrecking the world economy via allowing all ME oil to be destroyed for a generation. He has shown many actions(my way of evaluating his intent, action) indicating this. He means to get in and return with the nuclear material at this point and do no more damage if reasonably possible.
He WILL do as much damage to Iran as necessary to accomplish this, and has in words, stated as such.
Exactly. It's a plan for disaster without considering downstream consequences. Kharg isn't the only Iranian oil terminal (5 I think?) and they can reroute to any of the others. Of course we can destroy all of them, resulting in the same retaliatory outcome.
We need months to prepare for a ground invasion and the window to launch one before the seasonal Mediterranean heat dome becomes unbearable for troops is quickly closing.
There is little doubt the US has inflicted massive damage to Iran as well they should be able to given the US spends more on "defence" than the next ten countries combined. However, IF the US was 'winning' this war, they wouldn't be going to the negotiating table, would they?
This is a rhyme of what happened in Vietnam - the US lost. And what happened in Afghanistan - the US lost, and the Russians and French before that.
The Iranians are 'all in'. For them, it's life or death and death isn't so bad because that's martyrdom (and who knows maybe 72 virgins. God help them with that!).
But for Americans, it's the price of gas.
Trump isn't making 'the deal' here. The Iranians are. Trump changed the world order by waging this war, but not in America's favour. You can bet Saudi Arabia is negotiating with Iran now, and that the petrodollar just became something else...perhaps the petroyuan.
The US dollar status as the world's reserve currency was already declining. This war has accelerated a trend already in motion. Meanwhile, France, Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and the Philippines have all negotiated passage through the Strait directly with Tehran. Payments are going through Chinese banks. These aren't the traditional BRIC states that were already moving away from the US reserve currency. These are (former) US allies.
I don't know how the Idiot Savant con man will try to spin this but eventually the US loses this chess match...unless they do decide to commit genocide or put a million plus troops on the ground (neither of which will be palatable options to the American people, hopefully). He is already talking about walking away and leaving his mess for Europe to deal with, and says stupid shit like the US has all the oil they need (but neglecting to mention or not realizing that it will still cost as much as it does in the rest of the world).
As Trump told Zelensky once upon a time, Iran is telling Trump - you have no cards. Karma, baby.
Sending Vance as the point man rather than the Rubio permahawk leaves me a little bit more optimism than this essay presents, but not enough to stridently dispute the wise words expressed.
Is there anyone left on the Iranian side who can be meaningfully negotiated with, or has the country already devolved into post-decapitation rival factions?
FYI - word is, via Mahyar Tousi (TousiTV) that the anti-Islamic groups have pledged to support a single, unified Iran after the fall of the Islamic regime. Even the Iranian Kurds(Kurds inside Iran) have rejected splitting to become part of the Iraqi Kurds. I think the ethnic Persians make up about 50-60% of the population in Iran. So there are various other groups. Tousi is a very pro Prince Pahlavi - but has info on stuff happening inside Iran. Seems to be a good source. Showed videos of Regime hardliners protesting the "moderates" that were talking to Trump! The IRGC protesting the IRGC. Rebellion groups are being told to what until the active fighting is over before moving.
When trying to analyse these events from our place, far away from any real information, the best thing is to assess the motivation of the participants and not to take their declarations for cash money. War is all about motivation. Shrael is motivated, Iran is motivated, the US ? If we believe The Don, not so much ; we have all the oil we need. The US is motivated by Shrael but it's getting costly in domestic politics. When people start to read that SS and Medicare benefits have to be reduced for the health of the Pentagon votes are going to switch. One that should be motivated is China. Apart from the fact that they get a good portion of their energy needs from Iran, China invested a lot in this belt and road initiative. And these investments (railroads and bridges) are being destroyed. I think that if there is no agreement soon, China's motivation will rise the stakes in this conflict.
With the Bozos we have "negotiating" I fear the worst. We need to refit, refresh, and convince the Artesh that they'd be better off without the mullahs and pay them.
I respect Peter Schiff alot, but I think he's wrong here.
My personal belief is that this war was launched in an effort to splinter Iran into factions that Israel could play off against each other. That was the reason for the (disgusting and dishonorable) decapitation strike in the midst of peace talks, the subsequent encouragement by the US and Israel for revolution within Iran, the efforts to arm so-called "protestors," etc. Post-Venezuela, Trump thought he could achieve this with a massive initial strike and effort, and Israel hoped to exploit the power vacuum that would exist post-Iran. They were wrong.
If one accepts this as the chief war aim (and I realize there are many who don't), then the US and Israel have not won. Realistically, at this point, they can't win.
For Iran, victory is preventing the US and Israel from achieving their objectives, as outlined above. So far, they are winning. Yes, their navy and air force have been destroyed. No one objectively looking at this conflict expected anything less. Yes, the US and Israel have destroyed a significant amount of infrastructure, although probably much less than people expect. No, the US and Israel have not eliminated Iran's ability to respond. That's why, despite the bluster, the US is asking Iran to negotiate, not the other way around.
One need only look at Trump's pompous bluster about wiping a civilization off the face of the earth. It was calculated to intimidate Iran into surrendering. It failed. At the 11th hour, Trump said "We received a 10 point proposal from Iran, and believe it is a workable basis on which to negotiate. Almost all of the various points of past contention have been agreed to between the United States and Iran, but a two week period will allow the Agreement to be finalized and consummated." Really? That 10-point proposal has been out there for weeks and has been extensively covered by Drop Site News. It is Iran's wish list for how the war should end. Trump now claims there was some other 10-point proposal that he is referring to. It's noteworthy that he hasn't produced anything to back this up. That's because his bluff was called, and he caved at the 11th hour. There was no other proposal.
It doesn't mean this two week cease fire will last or it will lead to a peace agreement. I'm pretty confident it won't. But, tally one for Iran. They called the bluff of a moron and won. Whether that proves pyrrhic remains to be seen.
Schiff writes a sensible essay and gets blasted for it by fools. Hilarious.
Brian, I would just add that everything this administration says is also propaganda.
"Do we have ANY idea who we are even negotiating with". Answer : yes, yes we do. The idea that Iran has nobody to negotiate with is a propaganda point.
The negotiators for Iran are notable.
Abbas Araghchi is their foreign minister. Mohammad Ghalibaf is their Parliament Speaker. Ali Akbar Ahmadian is the Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council. Abdolnaser Hemmati is the Central Bank Governor. Other members of pariliament are reported to be in attendance.
For those killed in this war:
Ayatollah Ali Khamenei replaced by his son
Ali Larijani replaced by Mohammad Bagher Zolghadr, former deputy commander of the IRGC.
Amir Ali Hajizadeh replaced by Majid Mousavi (formerly his deputy)
To me all of these are just names, but CIA/Mossad would have comprehensive intelligence on every one of the replacements, since they have intent to target and kill them. It's also clear that when the leaders of Iran are killed, they are being replaced by individuals already embedded in the highest levels of the government. For all of Israel's faults, I do think Mossad is good at collecting intel - what is done with that is another matter.
Trump will not leave them with their Uranium or control of the strait. If he gets those things done he HAS won. If not, there will be no walking away.
Trump intends this to be his historical contribution to the civilized world. I don't see him backing down and he will probably be on hand as the uranium and plutonium are delivered to us. He is not running for re-election and cares little for the other Republicans. The guy is dug in.
His military is having a field day with a costless campaign of precision utter destruction of a generation's worth of Iranian military assets. Those flyboys live for this. Shooting fish in a barrel. It's been compared to a high school team up against the NFL.
This will be two weeks to reload and refresh. EU nations are sending minesweepers for the strait because they have to since the EU is where the oil pain is concentrated. The same EU leaders who made fun of him are now feeling the sting of the lash from their own constituients. Bonus for that.
And if Iran hasn't agreed to hand over their refined material and to inspections on IAEA's terms then the shooting will start right up again. Elon's Starlink is running a cell service with access to a Telegram-style encrypted text service for ordinary Iranians. Out of their homes for two weeks they'll provide coordinates for a whole new set of targets to hit.
And Congress will trip over its own feet when Trump announces that the cease fire resets the 60 day clock. Trump will dare the Congress to take a vote to rewind the progress made in Iran (and the greater MidEast generally). They won't.
Your Glorious Leader has ALREADY left them with their uranium AND control of the Strait.
Last July Trump said he “destroyed Iran’s nuclear program, never to be rebuilt.” Then 7 months later, in February, he said they were “2 weeks away from making a nuclear bomb.” MAGAbots clapped like trained seals at both proclamations. No one has yet asked, “Did Trump lie in July, or did he lie in February?”
“Trump is their last hope.” What a shame you could not see what Trump was after the first four years of his grift. Self-aggrandizement. Toxic narcissism. Lie after lie. (Lock her up. I’ll build a big, beautiful wall all across the southern border. Repeal and replace Obamacare. Two weeks to flatten the curve.) You voted for Trump a second (third?) time, and you’re finally getting what you voted for — massive inflation caused (First) by his declaration of an illegal tariff war against the whole world (and Second) by causing massive fuel price increases due to closing the Strait. Not to mention worldwide food shortages caused by stopping fertilizer shipments through the Strait, and just maybe — because he sent massive munitions to Ukraine and exhausted the U.S. arms surplus in Iran — a U.S. invasion by China that we cannot stop because we have nothing left but nukes (can’t nuke invaders on American soil. Duh!). Yes, Trump did that.
You brainless MAGAbots see everything as binary — if i don’t support Trump then i must support Biden/Harris, etc. Delusional! Your complete lack of awareness is astounding. I have not voted for a Democrat since my young and stupid college days, when i voted for Carter in 1976. In 2024, I voted for Ron DeSantis, a true conservative (not a life-long New York Democrat who magically became a “Republican” during an escalator ride in 2015). With DeSantis, we would have had a rock-solid conservative running America for 8 years, instead of an 80-year-old grifter with cognitive issues (explained by his toadies as “4D chess” or “strategic unpredictability”) who likely will not even complete his 4 year term. What do I mean?
Trump will certainly lose the House in the Midterms, leading to his impeachment yet again. The difference this time will be the Senate, which may flip Democrat over Trump’s adventurism in Iran, but even if not, there will be a few Republicans — those who actually believe in the Constitution instead of tribalism — who will join the Democrats in removing Trump from office. Then we’ll get Vance, who is not smart enough to be President. (Trump picks people like Pence and Vance specifically because they’re dumber that he is, just like Biden did with Harris.)
As i said above, Republicans could have had 8 years of rock-solid conservative leadership, but no, it was more important for MAGA to get revenge for 2020 than choose the best person in 2024. Frankly, Republicans suck at strategic thinking, and America — far from being “First” — is circling the drain because of Trump. And yes, THAT is what you voted for.
The outcomes of the negotiations will hardly be the end of conflict. Regardless of the promises from both sides, you can count on Israel to be left unsatisfied, and precedents show that their interests will eventually be supported by the US.
'US interests' are the interests of all civilised people...unless you want a world dominated by brutal, murdering regimes.
America has been killing people all over the world my whole life. Please stop with the "murdering regimes" nonsense, especially when you now know how USAID was applied.
A shame you haven't lived in Iran for a few years spouting opinions, see how long you'd last. It's very easy cursing the US from inside the US or some other safe western country where you can say what you like.
I'd do alright. People (men AND women) post things on social media and Telegram all the time. Perhaps you should be more concerned with what's happening in your own backyard rather than some spot on the other side of the world?
I saw what I needed to when photos of "human shields" appeared after Trump threatened destruction of electrical and water plants. The shields were all women and girls. Expendable for them, I guess.
What happened to that populist uprising we were guaranteed once the mullahs were killed? Israel folds before Iran.
These things happen in Hemingway time: slowly, then suddenly.
True. I'm old and still waiting on that fish.
I've never read such rubbish from an 'intelligent' person. If you've read what Japan did in the 1930's, murdering and torturing across Asia on a vast scale, considered what German Nazis did in Europe (25 million dead in Russia alone) then Trump's very brave and noble move to stop Iran before it becomes a REALLY big problem should be massively supported by all sensible people. Whining armchair critics of Trump (90% of the Communist US media) have yet to tell us what the alternatives are. You think you can 'negotiate' with religious fanatics, bent on getting nukes?? That's for children. WW2 could have been/should have been stopped in 1936 when Hitler reoccupied the Rhineland but European leaders didn't have the balls. If Trump had been around at the time, WW2 would never have happened.
I was thinking the same thing, except in a very different direction. Schiff has it wrong because he believes in U.S. lies spun re: the extent of damage done to Iran and apparently believes Iran is "objectively obliterated". Hurt to be sure, but they are winning.
Wow, you're lucky to have special inside info, to know 'they are winning' - tell us more, tell us your sources...or is it just CNN, Bloomberg etc?
Look up at my other post. There's your starting point for getting educated.
They are winning in the same sense the The Black Knight defeated King Arthur in Monty Python's Holy Grail, while armless and legless the knight still refuses to concede defeat and declares victory over King Arthur, who simply steps around him because who gives a shit what the Black Knight fool has to say.
Only if you define winning as hunkered down in a bunker while your entire arsenal, acquired over decades, is reduced to a smoking ruin. Maybe winning doesn't require being still alive. I don't know.
You need to find better sources of analysis to understand what is happening re: this war. Schiff is terrific when it comes to economics and precious metals, but clearly knows little re: Iran and the current military situation. Iran is hurt but certainly not "objectively obliterated". It is a huge country with distributed infrastructure. Tel Aviv and the Arab states are much more badly hurt as Iran's strikes geographically concentrate within the much smaller territory of Israel and specific high-value military and energy assets in GCC countries.
Iran appears likely to be able to continue punching for at least several more months if not years, with material stockpiled for decades and resupply from Russia/China. There's no evidence Iran's military has been significantly weakened by any measure that matters, and their government appears strengthened as the citizens have rallied nightly. Worse for U.S./Israel, we are running out of the standoff munitions that so far have allowed us to strike deep without putting our aircraft at great(er) risk. The aircraft losses late last week appear likely to be the result of a failed uranium extraction operation (another reason Trump is desperate). We would see much worse if we try to do deep bombing missions directly over Tehran. Iran is not impervious, but still appears to possess significant air defense capability.
Frankly, I'd go so far as to suggest Schiff exposes a significant anti-Iranian bias. He mocks Iranians seeing us as the 'evil empire'. Well, it fits. We kill over 160 children with a Tomahawk with zero accountability. We call Iranians liars - claim they bombed their own children, and appear to not even want to investigate the matter.
Better sources:
- The Duran
- Colonel Douglas MacGregor
- Colonel Daniel Davis (Daniel Davis Deep Dive)
- Larry Johnson (Sonar21.com)
- Scott Ritter
- Judge Nap
- Simplicius the Thinker
'better sources', hilarious, and you believe them? Yes Iran is an evil empire by any measures, most clearly expressed by Iranians suffering there, plenty of evidence. Iran has had 47 years building its murderous systems, it will take more than a few weeks to defang them, to the huge benefit of Iranian people. Sadly some innocents will suffer in that process but ultimately, the entire region will be safer.
Maybe If the CIA hadn't overthrown the democratic Iranian government in 1953 and installed a brutal dictator none of this would be happening now. But speaking of evil empires how do you categorize the US invasions of Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya. Millions of civilians killed or displaced. To quote Ricky Watters former NFL player "For who, for what?".
It's always our fault. Got it. Maybe just post that and save us the unnecessary additional words.
We did install a like minded patriot in Syria most known and photographed for decapitated heads.
No, it's not always our fault. Oh hey, Cartero, let's add Ukraine to the list. Got it? Great! Oh sorry, so as I was saying Cranky, you may be right there could be a few wars that aren't our fault.
So true. I voted for Trump and a I want him to succeed — still. I hope JD Vance wins in 2028. Many of those sources supported Trump too. Some still do.
They are all serious thinkers and I would say Patriots too. I’d put John Mearsheimer on the list and Jeffrey Sachs, though I am not tying either to any politician.
We can be “for Trump” and opposed to these military adventures.
There were two successful regime change wars in American history,
1) Civil War
2) WW2
The rest were Smedley Butler style shit fights. Or they were Red Tide scares. You look at Vietnam in past 30 years and you’d think USA won that one,.
That’s it. Both permanent regime changes required a ground invasion and occupation. Is somebody willing to ground invade Iran and occupy it till we bend a 3000 year old culture to our largely British Isles style of Enlightenment political theory?
Cause that’s what it would take. Hello?
Right “NO” that’s what I thought.
Oh but aren’t we teaching them a lesson and kicking their ass? Hmm. Geopolitics isn’t a boxing match. Or a cage fight. Get real.
Absent oil revenue denominated in rubles or renmenbi they have nothing to spend on new stuff. Certainly their credit is dubious.
“…what happens during negotiations over the next few weeks is crucial.” The biggest problem is that there is no one on the Iranian side to negotiate with, because he was killed within the first 24 hours of bombing. Iran’s president is a figurehead, the IRGC units are running on autopilot, and their “Supreme Leader” is a piece of cardboard representing a comatose guy in Russia. Maybe Biden should send cardboard Khomeini his autopen.
Being only an engineer I always have an answer and sit in wonder why Trump's Dept. of War is not consulting with me.
-- use the long-time Medieval, Genghis Khan siege: cut off their water and supply lines(blockade all their protected harbors on their shores with sunken ships)
-- Close the spigot on Kharg the easy way: special forces closes the valves out to the load docks; install a fortress FOB there and support with overwhelming Predator and warthog and Navy forces; blockade on ALL shipping into / out of Kharg.
-- start at two extremes both North and South of Kharg on the shore and turn every town and military installation to DUST
-- Kill every power plant in Kharg and surrounding the strait of Hormuz in Iran
-- Warn ALL ships away for 10 miles; anything floating will be sunk-- period.
-- use Israeli intelligence and agents inside Tehran to continue to target ALL Iranian IRGC and politicals; massive elimination of ALL.
-- Bomb mercilessly all roads into Tehran and Kharg.
-- After all this, assess; if possible go in and get the U238.
-- Walk away and let the local countries clean up the mess, arming them with OUR missiles(land to land only)
Two months or so. . .
Too bad the UN and Europe were not around in Genghis Khan‘s time. The UN would have voted to sanction him and send him frowny faces over his conquests. Then they would have convened a tribunal in Nuremberg to examine his actions against “humanity.” Europe, who had nothing to do with his battles (just like they eschewed getting involved in the Iran conflict), would afterward bitch and moan about how “unfair” he was being and tell him what he SHOULD be doing to make things right.
Did you design the Fukashima reactor? Just curious. Solid plan. I'm sure the Pentagon hasn't thought about any of this.
No, I did not.
But most anyone, does not have to be an engineer, would design backup generator systems that cannot be flooded under the most extreme circumstances. Tsunami's are common in the Pacific. Fukishima is right on the ocean, so. . .
The Reactor kept running until they could not be cooled; the generators were not keeping the cooling pumps running. Reactors working just fine all the time. . .
Right, I jest re: Fukashima but have you thought about why we haven't implemented your plan? We are capable of destroying every Iranian oil terminal and taking Kharg, but we cannot defend against the retaliation or escape the economic consequences when ME oil generation is destroyed for a generation.
Well, I am more optimistic than you are apparently. I believe Trump DOES, in fact, have America's interest at heart. Probably not out of his own altruism but out of his own greed, partially, and then some REAL sense too of what America means.
My belief about Trumpie's intent is that he is a smart human; he will not shoot his businesses in the foot by wrecking the world economy via allowing all ME oil to be destroyed for a generation. He has shown many actions(my way of evaluating his intent, action) indicating this. He means to get in and return with the nuclear material at this point and do no more damage if reasonably possible.
He WILL do as much damage to Iran as necessary to accomplish this, and has in words, stated as such.
Iran clearly has missiles left that can hit Israel. Flip your advice around & ask how Iran might respond to it.
Then ask Grok or your AI of choice what would happen if Israel lost it's six or seven (I think it's 7) desalination plants.
Exactly. It's a plan for disaster without considering downstream consequences. Kharg isn't the only Iranian oil terminal (5 I think?) and they can reroute to any of the others. Of course we can destroy all of them, resulting in the same retaliatory outcome.
We need months to prepare for a ground invasion and the window to launch one before the seasonal Mediterranean heat dome becomes unbearable for troops is quickly closing.
There is little doubt the US has inflicted massive damage to Iran as well they should be able to given the US spends more on "defence" than the next ten countries combined. However, IF the US was 'winning' this war, they wouldn't be going to the negotiating table, would they?
This is a rhyme of what happened in Vietnam - the US lost. And what happened in Afghanistan - the US lost, and the Russians and French before that.
The Iranians are 'all in'. For them, it's life or death and death isn't so bad because that's martyrdom (and who knows maybe 72 virgins. God help them with that!).
But for Americans, it's the price of gas.
Trump isn't making 'the deal' here. The Iranians are. Trump changed the world order by waging this war, but not in America's favour. You can bet Saudi Arabia is negotiating with Iran now, and that the petrodollar just became something else...perhaps the petroyuan.
The US dollar status as the world's reserve currency was already declining. This war has accelerated a trend already in motion. Meanwhile, France, Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and the Philippines have all negotiated passage through the Strait directly with Tehran. Payments are going through Chinese banks. These aren't the traditional BRIC states that were already moving away from the US reserve currency. These are (former) US allies.
I don't know how the Idiot Savant con man will try to spin this but eventually the US loses this chess match...unless they do decide to commit genocide or put a million plus troops on the ground (neither of which will be palatable options to the American people, hopefully). He is already talking about walking away and leaving his mess for Europe to deal with, and says stupid shit like the US has all the oil they need (but neglecting to mention or not realizing that it will still cost as much as it does in the rest of the world).
As Trump told Zelensky once upon a time, Iran is telling Trump - you have no cards. Karma, baby.
Excellent, concise wrap up of where we are at. Bravo!
Pump prices and private credit cracks are hastening the wrap up IMHO.
Gonna be an interesting year possibly. 😌
Sending Vance as the point man rather than the Rubio permahawk leaves me a little bit more optimism than this essay presents, but not enough to stridently dispute the wise words expressed.
Is there anyone left on the Iranian side who can be meaningfully negotiated with, or has the country already devolved into post-decapitation rival factions?
FYI - word is, via Mahyar Tousi (TousiTV) that the anti-Islamic groups have pledged to support a single, unified Iran after the fall of the Islamic regime. Even the Iranian Kurds(Kurds inside Iran) have rejected splitting to become part of the Iraqi Kurds. I think the ethnic Persians make up about 50-60% of the population in Iran. So there are various other groups. Tousi is a very pro Prince Pahlavi - but has info on stuff happening inside Iran. Seems to be a good source. Showed videos of Regime hardliners protesting the "moderates" that were talking to Trump! The IRGC protesting the IRGC. Rebellion groups are being told to what until the active fighting is over before moving.
Thank you. Much appreciated. Cheers Graeme.
When trying to analyse these events from our place, far away from any real information, the best thing is to assess the motivation of the participants and not to take their declarations for cash money. War is all about motivation. Shrael is motivated, Iran is motivated, the US ? If we believe The Don, not so much ; we have all the oil we need. The US is motivated by Shrael but it's getting costly in domestic politics. When people start to read that SS and Medicare benefits have to be reduced for the health of the Pentagon votes are going to switch. One that should be motivated is China. Apart from the fact that they get a good portion of their energy needs from Iran, China invested a lot in this belt and road initiative. And these investments (railroads and bridges) are being destroyed. I think that if there is no agreement soon, China's motivation will rise the stakes in this conflict.
With the Bozos we have "negotiating" I fear the worst. We need to refit, refresh, and convince the Artesh that they'd be better off without the mullahs and pay them.
I respect Peter Schiff alot, but I think he's wrong here.
My personal belief is that this war was launched in an effort to splinter Iran into factions that Israel could play off against each other. That was the reason for the (disgusting and dishonorable) decapitation strike in the midst of peace talks, the subsequent encouragement by the US and Israel for revolution within Iran, the efforts to arm so-called "protestors," etc. Post-Venezuela, Trump thought he could achieve this with a massive initial strike and effort, and Israel hoped to exploit the power vacuum that would exist post-Iran. They were wrong.
If one accepts this as the chief war aim (and I realize there are many who don't), then the US and Israel have not won. Realistically, at this point, they can't win.
For Iran, victory is preventing the US and Israel from achieving their objectives, as outlined above. So far, they are winning. Yes, their navy and air force have been destroyed. No one objectively looking at this conflict expected anything less. Yes, the US and Israel have destroyed a significant amount of infrastructure, although probably much less than people expect. No, the US and Israel have not eliminated Iran's ability to respond. That's why, despite the bluster, the US is asking Iran to negotiate, not the other way around.
One need only look at Trump's pompous bluster about wiping a civilization off the face of the earth. It was calculated to intimidate Iran into surrendering. It failed. At the 11th hour, Trump said "We received a 10 point proposal from Iran, and believe it is a workable basis on which to negotiate. Almost all of the various points of past contention have been agreed to between the United States and Iran, but a two week period will allow the Agreement to be finalized and consummated." Really? That 10-point proposal has been out there for weeks and has been extensively covered by Drop Site News. It is Iran's wish list for how the war should end. Trump now claims there was some other 10-point proposal that he is referring to. It's noteworthy that he hasn't produced anything to back this up. That's because his bluff was called, and he caved at the 11th hour. There was no other proposal.
It doesn't mean this two week cease fire will last or it will lead to a peace agreement. I'm pretty confident it won't. But, tally one for Iran. They called the bluff of a moron and won. Whether that proves pyrrhic remains to be seen.