8 Comments
User's avatar
Matt Benson's avatar

I remember the "sequester" in 2013 which automatically cut the US Federal Budget by 2%. This was portrayed by the media blob as some sort of dramatic slashing of spending when in fact the federal government's budget had doubled since the Clinton years. So increasing the federal government's budget by 100% in like 20 years was totally normal and fine but then increasing the government's budget by only 98% in 20 years was brutal austerity. Since then we have doubled the budget (and the budget deficit) again but of course literally almost nothing could possibly be cut from that without cries of "austerity!".

Julien Pervillé's avatar

The only austerity that I heard about (as an European) is what happened to Greece in the 2010s. For the rest of us there is no austerity, we can have worsening public services and growing public debt at the same time.

allen's avatar

While reading your piece, I wondered to what extent IQ levels at or below 84 might have justified growth in government spending. The number 84 is significant because it is the IQ that determines employability according the US Army. There is no meaningful correlation between the needs of the "unemployable" and the growth in spending from 1960 - 2020. Indeed the ratio of absolute growth is 2/10; i.e. the target population has doubled while government expenditures have decupled according to ChatGPT. Unfortunately, I am unable to provide the startling accompanying graph.

Indexed Growth: Federal Outlays Vs. U.S. Population ≤ IQ 84, 1960–2020

Here’s the visualization: it shows that while the population at or below IQ 84 roughly doubled (index ≈ 180–190 by 2020), real federal outlays increased more than tenfold (index > 1000).

This stark divergence illustrates how government spending has grown far faster than the sub-84 population alone — pointing to structural, policy, and economic factors beyond simple demographic expansion.

george's avatar

Austere adds aristocratic flavor to being dirt poor.

Mike's avatar

Hahahaha! Thank god in the first paragraph the nexus question was asked!! Phew.

Got concerned there for a second!

Can wait to finish it! ⚽️

erik bjorseth's avatar

The government spending / subsidizes the past 25 years is the main issue our next generation faces today.

#1 Federal Student Loan Programs. Allowing 18 years to blank checks to go to college was probably the dumbest thing we ever did. Colleges licked their chops and been raising their prices over the past 2 decades. College campuses look more like spas compared to 25 years ago - the housing and food options looked more like a prison. An 18 year old should not have access to 6 figure debt with no collateral. Now it is damn near impossible for a family to pay for a kid to go to school w/o borrowing.

Cut the Fed Student Loan program and watch applications dry up and force colleges to bring prices down.

#2: ACA - Obamacare. Same story, our government has been subsidizing health insurance for all - giving the appearance to citizens that health insurance is affordable. Well have 10 + years of ACA, we have all seen our insurance costs sky rocket. Now politicians are crying that the Affordable Care Act is NOT affordable anymore. Nope, they are paying the same as the rest of us now.

Where the government could have been negotiating with the buying power of the US Government, they did not. They just wrote the blank check and we watching insurance company stocks sore.

There would be short term pain to solving both these problems, but the long term reward would outweigh it.

DLB's avatar

In the late 60's, manufacturing as a % of GDP stood at 27%, whereas today, manufacturing accounts for approximately 10% of GDP.

Using the graph in the article for the same periods, government spending as a % of GDP has gone from 30% to 40%

Those manufacturing jobs were held by the middle class in America, and their numbers have been shrinking ever since. The government has tried to replace that loss with increased spending, along with a dramatic rise in the national debt. Even though the government spending increase has been overwhelming, it has not replaced the lost revenue the manufacturing base provided to the economy over 50 years ago.

There is a lot more that could be said on this subject, but to summarize it. Government spending is an effort to replace what has been lost in the manufacturing section of our economy.

If anyone wonders what Trump is doing today, and why. It appears he understands this issue.

Kevin's avatar

If printing more money (QE) is a significant cause of inflation, then normalizing the data for the rate of inflation would seem to eliminate one of the hidden sources of government spending from your chart.