Yep, the revenue is always less than projected and the spending is always higher than projected leading to greater deficits. Yet politicians continue to believe their own blather.
The purpose of so-called wealth taxes isn' to raise significant revenue from the wealthy - who can always use "clout", "pull" and tax avoidance schemes to avoid or minimize its effects. NO - it's to slowly ratchet down the effective start point to strip the Middle Class of their remaining assets - after the income tax and fiat debt currency debasement have reached their maximum "effectiveness" (beyond which further exactions will collapse the economy entirely).
There is so much to be said about how the wealth tax is such an insane idea, space doesn't allow it here. But one thing those like Mamdani and Sanders don't tell you, or maybe they don't understand themselves, is that almost everyone who has any measurable wealth has most of it invested. Assets like real estate, bonds, stocks, etc. No one keeps millions of Dollars in checking accounts to pay bills.
Now imagine what happens when everyone is forced to sell in order to pay "their fair share" via wealth taxes? What happens when real estate investments all hit the market at the same time? What happens to the stock market when everyone is selling at the same time? The same will be true for bonds too. Prices for all these assets will go down, and not just a few percent, it will create a downward spiral. In the stock market alone, all this selling will force more selling as margin requirements kick in.
These people are either morons or evil, take your pick.
This is just another case of how these supposedly smart people who run our government, have no clue as to how the economy really works.
Yeah, let's create a new source of revenue for the nitwits who've already pissed away 150% of the revenue they've collected from all of their other sources.
It's like giving a drunk driver a case of vodka and the keys to all the cars on the lot of a Ferrari dealership. Yeah, he's going to eventually kill you, but it's for your own good.
Any policy the government hopes to fund that does not address the real issue of income inequality is noise. As it will lead to social unrest, and I don't mean mostly peaceful protests.
I'm not a billionaire and I don't blame the billionaires that are creators and builders for their success. Those that created their wealth are likely in the best position to use their wealthfor the greater good...how many Mega lottery winners have contributed to society...most lose it all. Some billionaires will use their fortunates to better society (build space travel capabilities or purchase a heavily censored social media platform (X) or newspaper (WAPO, LA Times) and restore some level of free speech), while others are creeps at best (push for mandating experimental and dangerous jabs on the public just after purchasing a jab company, and only to sell his stake for quick millions as soon as the jabs fail).
And the very rich have been fleeing California long before the billionaire wealth tax. I don't give handouts to drug addicts begging in the street, but some do and if it makes them feel good so be it. So I can't blame successful folks for not handing over money to political junkies. The state of CA has not only wasted taxpayers money, but continues to make bad decisions that will cost taxpayers more (e.g., the last oil refinery in northern CA will soon be shut down and the state will be importing its gas from the other side of the world...can't blame the rich for that).
We need policies for helping the working class.
* Open borders doesn't help the working class, as excessive migrants compete for jobs, housing and social services they rely upon...while the rich enjoy cheaper labor in their Michelin Star restaurants and lawn/pool maintenance services.
* Inflation doesn't help the working class, as prices increase faster than wages...while the rich enjoy inflated asset prices (real estate, stocks, precious metals)
* Globalization doesn't help the working class, as good paying jobs have left for cheaper labor markets....while the rich enjoy cheaper goods and services
You don't have to like Trump, few do, but closing borders, lowering inflation and getting foreign markets to invest in America to create good paying jobs are all positive for the working class. (not so much higher gas prices if this war continues for an extended period). While his well promoted programs of no tax on social security and tips, kids saving accounts, education credits are popular and may help. What exactly is the Uniparty's plan? Oh yeah, raising property taxes by 10% in NYC to pay for free buses and healthcare, that should work out well, giving money to a city where it costs $35K per pupil to secure a subpar public education...think about that...that's nearly $1M per classroom...my granddaughter attends a private school and a class size about half the public school with a teacher and assistant for only $11.5K per pupil (well under 150K a classroom), but most importantly securing an excellent education. And her school stayed opened during the teachers union covid/vacation shutdown.
The Uniparty's days may be numbered as they continue to hold on to the magic of mail-in ballots and legacy media promoting that this is 1933 Germany and taxing the rich makes sense.
I'd like to see a law passed that no new tax approved (or existing program continued to be funded) if the state or federal department overseeing it hasn't had an independent and thorough financial audit in the last 3 years and has addressed any fraud, waste and abuse issues found. There seems to be plenty of dollars to be found in them hills.
Maybe then we can have a conversation of who to tax.
You lost me when suggesting Trump would lower inflation. Nearly everything this administration does feeds inflation (yes, they make targeted attempts to lower the cost of a few specific things, but 1) it's rounding error, and 2) usually doesn't work). Inflation is now running higher than when he came into office (monthly basis, run rate, not the misleading annual rates).
Agreed, though, that inflation doesn't help the working class. The Fed could raise rates, the administration could cut spending, which would stamp out inflation, the 10/30yr bonds (and therefore mortgages, and all other longer term financing) would drop. That would be very good for the working class.
But no. I think this administration's plan is to "run it hot" with inflation as high as they can get away with, to shrink the debt in real dollars, sticking everyone -- especially the working class -- with a hidden tax.
Just how much inflation would it take to shrink the debt, relatively? I mean did the Biden era inflation even make a blip in that regard? What's worse is how little we have to show for spending so much money, pissing it away on inane wars, tax cuts, too much stimulus, and such.
Honesty about how government is financed and what it is spending money on would be refreshing. However, if the politicians were to contribute to educating the average citizen about how government and civics actually works then they would lose their greatest tool for getting reelected - voter ignorance and apathy.
I think for many people it’s not so much a matter of money as a matter of fairness. Tax code is way over complicated and choke full of loop holes for wealthy individuals and corporations that the average taxpayer can’t access. When they see they pay a higher percentage of taxes on their income than the ultra wealthy they feel they’re getting screwed. Personally, I think a graduated straight tax without deductions would be the cleanest fairest most transparent way to tax the American people, but the wealthy and powerful ain’t gonna let that happen.
Yep, the revenue is always less than projected and the spending is always higher than projected leading to greater deficits. Yet politicians continue to believe their own blather.
I don't believe that the politicians actually believe what they are saying. They just believe that saying it will get them elected.
You are more correct than I am! They say what they have to say. It’s all about the next term in office.
The purpose of so-called wealth taxes isn' to raise significant revenue from the wealthy - who can always use "clout", "pull" and tax avoidance schemes to avoid or minimize its effects. NO - it's to slowly ratchet down the effective start point to strip the Middle Class of their remaining assets - after the income tax and fiat debt currency debasement have reached their maximum "effectiveness" (beyond which further exactions will collapse the economy entirely).
There is so much to be said about how the wealth tax is such an insane idea, space doesn't allow it here. But one thing those like Mamdani and Sanders don't tell you, or maybe they don't understand themselves, is that almost everyone who has any measurable wealth has most of it invested. Assets like real estate, bonds, stocks, etc. No one keeps millions of Dollars in checking accounts to pay bills.
Now imagine what happens when everyone is forced to sell in order to pay "their fair share" via wealth taxes? What happens when real estate investments all hit the market at the same time? What happens to the stock market when everyone is selling at the same time? The same will be true for bonds too. Prices for all these assets will go down, and not just a few percent, it will create a downward spiral. In the stock market alone, all this selling will force more selling as margin requirements kick in.
These people are either morons or evil, take your pick.
This is just another case of how these supposedly smart people who run our government, have no clue as to how the economy really works.
Yeah, let's create a new source of revenue for the nitwits who've already pissed away 150% of the revenue they've collected from all of their other sources.
It's like giving a drunk driver a case of vodka and the keys to all the cars on the lot of a Ferrari dealership. Yeah, he's going to eventually kill you, but it's for your own good.
Any policy the government hopes to fund that does not address the real issue of income inequality is noise. As it will lead to social unrest, and I don't mean mostly peaceful protests.
I'm not a billionaire and I don't blame the billionaires that are creators and builders for their success. Those that created their wealth are likely in the best position to use their wealthfor the greater good...how many Mega lottery winners have contributed to society...most lose it all. Some billionaires will use their fortunates to better society (build space travel capabilities or purchase a heavily censored social media platform (X) or newspaper (WAPO, LA Times) and restore some level of free speech), while others are creeps at best (push for mandating experimental and dangerous jabs on the public just after purchasing a jab company, and only to sell his stake for quick millions as soon as the jabs fail).
And the very rich have been fleeing California long before the billionaire wealth tax. I don't give handouts to drug addicts begging in the street, but some do and if it makes them feel good so be it. So I can't blame successful folks for not handing over money to political junkies. The state of CA has not only wasted taxpayers money, but continues to make bad decisions that will cost taxpayers more (e.g., the last oil refinery in northern CA will soon be shut down and the state will be importing its gas from the other side of the world...can't blame the rich for that).
We need policies for helping the working class.
* Open borders doesn't help the working class, as excessive migrants compete for jobs, housing and social services they rely upon...while the rich enjoy cheaper labor in their Michelin Star restaurants and lawn/pool maintenance services.
* Inflation doesn't help the working class, as prices increase faster than wages...while the rich enjoy inflated asset prices (real estate, stocks, precious metals)
* Globalization doesn't help the working class, as good paying jobs have left for cheaper labor markets....while the rich enjoy cheaper goods and services
You don't have to like Trump, few do, but closing borders, lowering inflation and getting foreign markets to invest in America to create good paying jobs are all positive for the working class. (not so much higher gas prices if this war continues for an extended period). While his well promoted programs of no tax on social security and tips, kids saving accounts, education credits are popular and may help. What exactly is the Uniparty's plan? Oh yeah, raising property taxes by 10% in NYC to pay for free buses and healthcare, that should work out well, giving money to a city where it costs $35K per pupil to secure a subpar public education...think about that...that's nearly $1M per classroom...my granddaughter attends a private school and a class size about half the public school with a teacher and assistant for only $11.5K per pupil (well under 150K a classroom), but most importantly securing an excellent education. And her school stayed opened during the teachers union covid/vacation shutdown.
The Uniparty's days may be numbered as they continue to hold on to the magic of mail-in ballots and legacy media promoting that this is 1933 Germany and taxing the rich makes sense.
I'd like to see a law passed that no new tax approved (or existing program continued to be funded) if the state or federal department overseeing it hasn't had an independent and thorough financial audit in the last 3 years and has addressed any fraud, waste and abuse issues found. There seems to be plenty of dollars to be found in them hills.
Maybe then we can have a conversation of who to tax.
You lost me when suggesting Trump would lower inflation. Nearly everything this administration does feeds inflation (yes, they make targeted attempts to lower the cost of a few specific things, but 1) it's rounding error, and 2) usually doesn't work). Inflation is now running higher than when he came into office (monthly basis, run rate, not the misleading annual rates).
Agreed, though, that inflation doesn't help the working class. The Fed could raise rates, the administration could cut spending, which would stamp out inflation, the 10/30yr bonds (and therefore mortgages, and all other longer term financing) would drop. That would be very good for the working class.
But no. I think this administration's plan is to "run it hot" with inflation as high as they can get away with, to shrink the debt in real dollars, sticking everyone -- especially the working class -- with a hidden tax.
Just how much inflation would it take to shrink the debt, relatively? I mean did the Biden era inflation even make a blip in that regard? What's worse is how little we have to show for spending so much money, pissing it away on inane wars, tax cuts, too much stimulus, and such.
Honesty about how government is financed and what it is spending money on would be refreshing. However, if the politicians were to contribute to educating the average citizen about how government and civics actually works then they would lose their greatest tool for getting reelected - voter ignorance and apathy.
Many government policies tend to have the opposite impact then intended. At least they tried…
I think for many people it’s not so much a matter of money as a matter of fairness. Tax code is way over complicated and choke full of loop holes for wealthy individuals and corporations that the average taxpayer can’t access. When they see they pay a higher percentage of taxes on their income than the ultra wealthy they feel they’re getting screwed. Personally, I think a graduated straight tax without deductions would be the cleanest fairest most transparent way to tax the American people, but the wealthy and powerful ain’t gonna let that happen.