“The assassination of Charlie Kirk is a tragedy on several levels… It is a tragedy to Charlie” It’s obvious this author, Mr Licon, is not a Christian. Charlie’s death is certainly a tragedy to those left behind, especially his wife and children, but also the Republican Party, America, and all humanity. But it is certainly NOT a tragedy to Charlie. If Mr Licon believed the Bible, he would believe the words of 2 Corinthians 5:6-8, “while we are at home in the body we are absent from the Lord. I prefer rather to be absent from the body and to be at home with the Lord.” Charlie is currently experiencing the supreme happiness that many Christians dream of but must wait for, and that some people dream of but will never have.
As Robert D. Kaplan said in his book “The Coming Anarchy”: “Democracies are value-neutral. Hitler and Mussolini each came to power through democracy. Democracies do not always make societies more civil - but they do always mercilessly expose the health of the societies in which they operate.”
I think the authors miss a critical point. The perpetrators are nut jobs. Near as I can tell, their political loyalties range between ambivalent and non-existent.
It is human nature to want to have a cause to live, and perhaps die for. From what I see, the dangerous nut jobs are dangerous nut jobs FIRST, and THEN go looking for a rationale to justify murder. If they can't quite justify killing someone simply because they have a need to kill (typically suicidal/homicidal), then they need only come up with a cause to justify it. Any cause will do, so whatever is circulating in the news becomes their cause. But it was always fundamentally about their desire to kill.
Yes they are nut jobs. The people who radicalized and recruited him through online chats are specifically looking for nut jobs, and there are plenty of nut jobs to be found. Robinson is just a patsy who could be persuaded to do the dirty work for the organized Left, which is desperate to regain power in the Midterm elections. But his handlers will probably never be found, as long as they followed their instructions and protocols exactly to maintain their anonymity on the internet. And if they are found, the layer above them won't be. That is why the masterminds use so many layers of cutouts when they organize color revolutions and regime change.
There is no evidence to support that he was recruited online. I know it makes it easier to assume that there is some cabal behind everything. However the reality is that these new political terrorist are not like they were in the 60s and 70s. There is no organization. These are lost men broken by the dark online universe that exists. The FBI even has a new term for these types of actors, I can not remember the exact acronym but it is something like nihilistic violent extremism which is more terrifying than any ideology.
We know he chatted in advance with many others. Nobody else has been charged, so the FBI isn't saying much, and they won't say anything unless someone else is charged. Even if he wasn't recruited by organizers, he was certainly egged on by his friends.
From back in history - Oswald was almost certainly egged on by Soviet agents, but they were never found. The same themes repeat again and again throughout history.
Democracy does diffuse political power, but only among the citizenry. Money in politics concentrates political power among the politicians controlling the government checkbook. The ability to extract $5 trillion per year from the citizenry under penalty of imprisonment, combined with the ability to shackle that same citizenry with $38 trillion in debt, creates an inverted power structure no amount of voting can overcome. We are controlled by a wealthy, powerful elite who uses our own money to enslave us.
The core issue is separation of powers, not so much "democracies". Democracies can generate into mob rule -- such as the vaunted Athenians who executed Socrates, which spurred Plato to write "The Republic". Republics more than democracies are classically more aligned with separation of power and inalienable rights. To be sure Democracies who have constitutionally structured separations of power do achieve a measure of diffusion, but not due to the "democracy" side of the equation.
And I'm not sure humanity's tendency to acts such as this one is easily parsed with the quasi-mathematical logic of rationality. Humans are not rational beings. Blaise Pascal -- probably one of the more prominent of history's mathematicians -- quipped "The heart has reasons that reason itself can't understand."
Probably the best chronicler and mapper of these psychological energies that foment such wild acts of irrational utility maximization was Albert Camus in "The Rebel". As usual, economists are erudite but their field of view and tool set always -- at least to me -- seems too narrow and incomplete for many of the topics their self-confidence inspires them to take on.
If you read that paper on how likely is it for your vote to count, what it says is essentially true, but the thing is you can't know in advance if your vote will count or not. The analysis uses an old electoral college map, and the states in play have changed. They will change again. And it isn't just Presidential elections. I can remember several instances at the state and local level where someone's vote has counted. In 2017 we had a state legislative election where one district was tied and decided by a coin toss, and that decided the majority in the Virginia House of Delegates.
Let's cut it all down to Occam's Razor - what is the simplest explanation for the Kirk assassination, because that is probably the correct one. Charlie Kirk was effective. He arguably delivered several states for Trump in 2024 through his persuasion, voter registration and get out the vote efforts. The Midterms are coming up next year, and Trump was depending on Kirk to help him keep the House. As you said, one person's vote rarely counts for much. But taking a super-effective organizer off the playing field can take millions of votes out of that playing field, and that matters. Simply, Tyler Robinson exercised a super vote that negated millions of votes that would have otherwise been directed to the polls by Charlie Kirk. He certainly knew that, and more importantly, the shadowy figures who radicalized and directed him through online chats knew that. This is a political war, and Antifa are the Democratic party's soldiers.
“The assassination of Charlie Kirk is a tragedy on several levels… It is a tragedy to Charlie” It’s obvious this author, Mr Licon, is not a Christian. Charlie’s death is certainly a tragedy to those left behind, especially his wife and children, but also the Republican Party, America, and all humanity. But it is certainly NOT a tragedy to Charlie. If Mr Licon believed the Bible, he would believe the words of 2 Corinthians 5:6-8, “while we are at home in the body we are absent from the Lord. I prefer rather to be absent from the body and to be at home with the Lord.” Charlie is currently experiencing the supreme happiness that many Christians dream of but must wait for, and that some people dream of but will never have.
I had a similar thought.
As Robert D. Kaplan said in his book “The Coming Anarchy”: “Democracies are value-neutral. Hitler and Mussolini each came to power through democracy. Democracies do not always make societies more civil - but they do always mercilessly expose the health of the societies in which they operate.”
Coming?
Excellent essay.
At this stage of time , I don't think there is anyone/anything that represents the electorate inside the Beltway.
The Beltway crowd are too busy looking for check$ and the majority of the electorate doesn't pack the punch of 5 or 6 figure "donation".
Whoever does have that punch most likely doesn't care about the electorate.
I think the authors miss a critical point. The perpetrators are nut jobs. Near as I can tell, their political loyalties range between ambivalent and non-existent.
It is human nature to want to have a cause to live, and perhaps die for. From what I see, the dangerous nut jobs are dangerous nut jobs FIRST, and THEN go looking for a rationale to justify murder. If they can't quite justify killing someone simply because they have a need to kill (typically suicidal/homicidal), then they need only come up with a cause to justify it. Any cause will do, so whatever is circulating in the news becomes their cause. But it was always fundamentally about their desire to kill.
Yes they are nut jobs. The people who radicalized and recruited him through online chats are specifically looking for nut jobs, and there are plenty of nut jobs to be found. Robinson is just a patsy who could be persuaded to do the dirty work for the organized Left, which is desperate to regain power in the Midterm elections. But his handlers will probably never be found, as long as they followed their instructions and protocols exactly to maintain their anonymity on the internet. And if they are found, the layer above them won't be. That is why the masterminds use so many layers of cutouts when they organize color revolutions and regime change.
There is no evidence to support that he was recruited online. I know it makes it easier to assume that there is some cabal behind everything. However the reality is that these new political terrorist are not like they were in the 60s and 70s. There is no organization. These are lost men broken by the dark online universe that exists. The FBI even has a new term for these types of actors, I can not remember the exact acronym but it is something like nihilistic violent extremism which is more terrifying than any ideology.
We know he chatted in advance with many others. Nobody else has been charged, so the FBI isn't saying much, and they won't say anything unless someone else is charged. Even if he wasn't recruited by organizers, he was certainly egged on by his friends.
From back in history - Oswald was almost certainly egged on by Soviet agents, but they were never found. The same themes repeat again and again throughout history.
Oswald was a CIA minor "asset" used as a patsy for the real CIA shooters.
Currencies. All I saw come out from the words was currencies. Poilitics in the USA are undergoing a price discovery.
The philosophies pointed out did not fall on deaf ears. Time to take a step back and chill.
I think we will find out the price is much higher than most people think.
In a counterrevolutionary milieu "expressive politics" enables us to identify the respective partisans for appropriate future action.
Democracy does diffuse political power, but only among the citizenry. Money in politics concentrates political power among the politicians controlling the government checkbook. The ability to extract $5 trillion per year from the citizenry under penalty of imprisonment, combined with the ability to shackle that same citizenry with $38 trillion in debt, creates an inverted power structure no amount of voting can overcome. We are controlled by a wealthy, powerful elite who uses our own money to enslave us.
The core issue is separation of powers, not so much "democracies". Democracies can generate into mob rule -- such as the vaunted Athenians who executed Socrates, which spurred Plato to write "The Republic". Republics more than democracies are classically more aligned with separation of power and inalienable rights. To be sure Democracies who have constitutionally structured separations of power do achieve a measure of diffusion, but not due to the "democracy" side of the equation.
And I'm not sure humanity's tendency to acts such as this one is easily parsed with the quasi-mathematical logic of rationality. Humans are not rational beings. Blaise Pascal -- probably one of the more prominent of history's mathematicians -- quipped "The heart has reasons that reason itself can't understand."
Probably the best chronicler and mapper of these psychological energies that foment such wild acts of irrational utility maximization was Albert Camus in "The Rebel". As usual, economists are erudite but their field of view and tool set always -- at least to me -- seems too narrow and incomplete for many of the topics their self-confidence inspires them to take on.
If you read that paper on how likely is it for your vote to count, what it says is essentially true, but the thing is you can't know in advance if your vote will count or not. The analysis uses an old electoral college map, and the states in play have changed. They will change again. And it isn't just Presidential elections. I can remember several instances at the state and local level where someone's vote has counted. In 2017 we had a state legislative election where one district was tied and decided by a coin toss, and that decided the majority in the Virginia House of Delegates.
Let's cut it all down to Occam's Razor - what is the simplest explanation for the Kirk assassination, because that is probably the correct one. Charlie Kirk was effective. He arguably delivered several states for Trump in 2024 through his persuasion, voter registration and get out the vote efforts. The Midterms are coming up next year, and Trump was depending on Kirk to help him keep the House. As you said, one person's vote rarely counts for much. But taking a super-effective organizer off the playing field can take millions of votes out of that playing field, and that matters. Simply, Tyler Robinson exercised a super vote that negated millions of votes that would have otherwise been directed to the polls by Charlie Kirk. He certainly knew that, and more importantly, the shadowy figures who radicalized and directed him through online chats knew that. This is a political war, and Antifa are the Democratic party's soldiers.