Washington responded to two crises with extraordinary monetary and fiscal interventions. Why did COVID-era stimulus produce soaring inflation when the response to the 2008 financial crisis did not?
As long as there is no disinflation, inflation continues to eat at the value of the dollar and spending capacity. 2007-09 inflation may have been rather tame, but we are still paying for it today. The Fed's 2% targets are stupid.
They should be set at a negative 2% for 2-3 decades and then at zero forever. Then again, having the Fed around is a recipe for disaster. The original intention of the Fed was to try and balance economic activities among the various regions of the country. My how that has failed.
If it were only 2-4 percent! So many things I buy have gone up at 50- 100 percent the last few years. Home Depot and Lowes are especially bad, they drove up prices during the pandemic home improvement boom and have never gone back.
This article misses the most direct explanation for why the QE years (2009 to 2022) brought only modest consumer inflation alongside a big run-up in asset prices.
When the Fed buys a bond on the open market, the seller’s bank is credited with a brand-new deposit: money that didn’t exist before. That new money goes straight to professional investors, the people who hold large amounts of Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. And what does a professional investor do with new money? He invests it, in more bonds, stocks, and other assets. This is the classic Cantillon Effect: new money creates new demand wherever it first enters the economy.
It doesn’t take a fast-growing money supply to push asset prices up if most of the new money goes into buying assets. And because asset buyers tend to keep reinvesting, the money circulates mostly among investors rather than flowing into consumer spending. It reaches consumer prices only slowly, as appreciated assets are eventually sold and paid out to investors and retirees.
Meanwhile, little of the modest growth in the money supply flowed into everyday economic activity, so consumer prices rose only modestly. Open global trade, especially cheap goods from China, helped keep them down.
That’s the straightforward explanation for how modest increases in the money supply led to high asset prices and only modest consumer inflation.
The contrast between 2008 liquidity going to banks that later repaid it and 2020 transfers landing directly in household accounts is the clearest explanation I've seen for why M2 growth turned into CPI this time. It makes me wonder how much of the post-GFC money stayed trapped as excess reserves rather than ever chasing goods.
I think the economy is shifting more to Main St. than Wall St if that makes any sense. The build out of Northern Jersey continues unabated. I just can't figure out what people are doing to make the amount of money required just to pay local taxes, let alone a minimum $500K for a tear down. All the Corporate HQ, farms and small industry are gone.
In 2008 the cash went to the banks to keep them from going under while economy was still functioning despite the housing crash. To the contrary, in Covid the economy ground to a halt creating a shortage of goods to absorb an excess of cash put directly into consumer’s hands. Voila! Inflation.
The 0.1% hovered up all of the money created by the GFC. It's why their share of global wealth increased 5-fold during the period. Inflation didn't occur because all of that money bypassed Main Street.
Little of that GFC $$$ found its way to consumers. It set in banks and found its way to hedge funds and connected investors. It was the single cause of the second leg of the shale revolution. It fueled the expansion of midstream companies to move this hydrocarbon bonanza to places it could be upgraded and exported. Then it filtered back to the inital lenders. Everyone skimmed 1-2% and the bankers were making 3-4% risk free.
This is not happening with the AI build out. Hyperscalers were working put of their own hip pockets but now are going to the credit market with their hats in their hands buying $$$ at 6+%. Any fool can make money when getting it is cheap. When it cost to buy money, that is where the nut cuttin starts.
It was a big step towards socialism..........shoot money out of a cannon for 6 years. Cause inflation - then interest rates triple.
Corporations take all that money in and are making record profits.
Now the lower end of the spectrum are struggling with housing / food cost and will rely on the government more than it has since the Great Depression.
In November you will see the Democrat Socialist start taking seats in Congress. Spreading their propaganda that we need to tax the rich so we can help people with housing / food.
The next few years could be the downfall of our country.
As long as there is no disinflation, inflation continues to eat at the value of the dollar and spending capacity. 2007-09 inflation may have been rather tame, but we are still paying for it today. The Fed's 2% targets are stupid.
They should be set at a negative 2% for 2-3 decades and then at zero forever. Then again, having the Fed around is a recipe for disaster. The original intention of the Fed was to try and balance economic activities among the various regions of the country. My how that has failed.
If it were only 2-4 percent! So many things I buy have gone up at 50- 100 percent the last few years. Home Depot and Lowes are especially bad, they drove up prices during the pandemic home improvement boom and have never gone back.
The fedgov "inflation" stats are ALL TOTAL FABRICATIONS!
is shadowstats.com still active? it seems defunct. no way to subscribe and no new updates lately..
It's still going strong! To subscribe just follow the instructions on the old website.
They should be focusing on growth at this point. The effects of inflation can be overcome/muted with a still low inflation rate.
No they can't - because of demographics
This article misses the most direct explanation for why the QE years (2009 to 2022) brought only modest consumer inflation alongside a big run-up in asset prices.
When the Fed buys a bond on the open market, the seller’s bank is credited with a brand-new deposit: money that didn’t exist before. That new money goes straight to professional investors, the people who hold large amounts of Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. And what does a professional investor do with new money? He invests it, in more bonds, stocks, and other assets. This is the classic Cantillon Effect: new money creates new demand wherever it first enters the economy.
It doesn’t take a fast-growing money supply to push asset prices up if most of the new money goes into buying assets. And because asset buyers tend to keep reinvesting, the money circulates mostly among investors rather than flowing into consumer spending. It reaches consumer prices only slowly, as appreciated assets are eventually sold and paid out to investors and retirees.
Meanwhile, little of the modest growth in the money supply flowed into everyday economic activity, so consumer prices rose only modestly. Open global trade, especially cheap goods from China, helped keep them down.
That’s the straightforward explanation for how modest increases in the money supply led to high asset prices and only modest consumer inflation.
The contrast between 2008 liquidity going to banks that later repaid it and 2020 transfers landing directly in household accounts is the clearest explanation I've seen for why M2 growth turned into CPI this time. It makes me wonder how much of the post-GFC money stayed trapped as excess reserves rather than ever chasing goods.
I think the economy is shifting more to Main St. than Wall St if that makes any sense. The build out of Northern Jersey continues unabated. I just can't figure out what people are doing to make the amount of money required just to pay local taxes, let alone a minimum $500K for a tear down. All the Corporate HQ, farms and small industry are gone.
In 2008 the cash went to the banks to keep them from going under while economy was still functioning despite the housing crash. To the contrary, in Covid the economy ground to a halt creating a shortage of goods to absorb an excess of cash put directly into consumer’s hands. Voila! Inflation.
The 0.1% hovered up all of the money created by the GFC. It's why their share of global wealth increased 5-fold during the period. Inflation didn't occur because all of that money bypassed Main Street.
Little of that GFC $$$ found its way to consumers. It set in banks and found its way to hedge funds and connected investors. It was the single cause of the second leg of the shale revolution. It fueled the expansion of midstream companies to move this hydrocarbon bonanza to places it could be upgraded and exported. Then it filtered back to the inital lenders. Everyone skimmed 1-2% and the bankers were making 3-4% risk free.
This is not happening with the AI build out. Hyperscalers were working put of their own hip pockets but now are going to the credit market with their hats in their hands buying $$$ at 6+%. Any fool can make money when getting it is cheap. When it cost to buy money, that is where the nut cuttin starts.
It was a big step towards socialism..........shoot money out of a cannon for 6 years. Cause inflation - then interest rates triple.
Corporations take all that money in and are making record profits.
Now the lower end of the spectrum are struggling with housing / food cost and will rely on the government more than it has since the Great Depression.
In November you will see the Democrat Socialist start taking seats in Congress. Spreading their propaganda that we need to tax the rich so we can help people with housing / food.
The next few years could be the downfall of our country.