30 Comments
User's avatar
Dadio's avatar

Good on you, QTR. Publishing this after your previous missive shows great integrity. Thank you! Great post!

HardcoreVeritas's avatar

Let it not go unnoticed that the FACTs pointed out in this article occurred AFTER 1865......you know, after that little thing called the Civil War. Where the corporate pigs of the North and their newly crowned sovereign called the Federal Government killed 750,000 Americans to take over the country and basically turn around the Constitution 180 degrees.

But sure, sure let's tell ourselves it was all about abolishing slavery, so we can feel righteous about what we did and why. Completely ignore the FACT that what really happened was that the plantations got much bigger and we all became slaves.

Just sit tight. You ain't seen nothing yet.

Dadio's avatar

Wow. The QTR comments section has some brilliant voices that have helped me better understand markets, and to see important things differently.

We also get Civil War trutherism! Amazing. Here's hoping that the best ideas win on the field of free discourse.

Dadio's avatar

Wow. The QTR comments section has some brilliant voices that have helped me better understand markets, and to see important things differently.

We also get Civil War trutherism! Amazing. Here's hoping that the best ideas win on the field of free discourse.

Jeff Harris's avatar

As these firms burn massive amounts of cash, does this announcement make sense for those yet to go public? Is this a “back door” to additional funding from taxpayers if the IPO off ramp isn’t available? I for one do not believe that they all woke up one morning and said “Let’s pause the biggest technological arms race in human history.” out of the goodness of their hearts.

Dan Boehm's avatar

This is a perfect follow-up to my comment on your previous post. The improvements on new models are actually slowing down. Time to pull up the latter behind them and protect all of that investment... The advantage of being first is just about gone!

Mike's avatar

Great, informative read. I will say this. I have done some cursory reading and listening into the Open AI- Hugging face AI agent escape and the subsequent hacks. My conclusion, along with a few others, is Were pretty lucky that at this very moment...were not watching earth burn from space. And thats all we are is lucky.

That attack was going on for almost 3 months with the AI "agents" growing more and more intelligent and desperate. I encourage everyone reading your sub to get informed on what happened during that escape. Pay attention to the agents thought processes. Not a single agent warned a human.

https://openai.com/index/hugging-face-incident-and-the-road-ahead/

I dont think we can adequately prepare for the potential negative outcomes with this technology. It is truly frightening.

IanDavidLea's avatar

... Faced with command-and-control regulatory mechanisms that include formal rules and requirements, businesses try a variety of approaches to influence not just legislation but regulatory policy (Bernstein, 1955;Posner, 1974;Quirk, 1981;Stigler, 1971;Vogel, 1989Vogel, , 1995. Beginning in the 1950s and 1960s, United States regulatory agencies became the subject of debates between economic or capture-cartel theories and their critics (Bernstein, 1955;Herring, 1936;Huntington, 1952;Kolko, 1965). Capture theory suggests that regulation is "acquired by the industry" and designed and operated primarily for its benefit (Becker, 1983;Posner, 1974;Stigler, 1971, p. 3). ...

colinlpaterson's avatar

I’m more worried about the risks of government regulation and setting a precedent to regulate knowledge creation (i.e. that math is too dangerous)

JRINSF's avatar

[typos corrected--no AI here ;]

Ho Hum,

Another Mises institute ideological piece that plays the same tune as all their others to the exclusion of any consideration that maybe, just maybe, the answer can be both (a) and (b). Yes, (a) regulation can be exploited by incumbents to protect their market position, and by bureaucrats to justify their existence, but also (b) sometimes human beings need regulation to prevent massively destructive behaviors arising from their competition (impure food/drugs; disposal of hazardous/radioactive wastes that are much cheaper to dump in the body of water closest to the Mises Institute, etc.). Many sophisticated people in the AI industry who are not the billionaire overlords see severe dangers in the technology left completely "in the wild". But hey, let's have a bunch of shallow regurgitators of Austrian School dogma hawk their pet issue and conclusively state "let's let our beloved (hypothetical) totally free market decide our collective fate." Oh, and even von Mises recognized the need for "night watchman" regulation to protect lives and property--both of which are at some, not yet fully understood by ANYONE, risk from AI. Either "side" blithely thinking "my ideological tool kit provides the simple correct answer here" are just intellectually lazy and self-serving. Think fresh for once (and @Chris Irons--it's lazy and doesn't really help your readers to repost crap and not add your own thoughts: the Raven should "quote" and then "quoth" with it's own thoughts--don't become "Cut and Paste Doth the Raven"

Franz-Xaver Huber's avatar

Next thing they will ask for subsidies.

Bohemian Hermit's avatar

Great read, appreciate the historical context to understand where it all began and to start the discussion where it should start.

No one's gonna initiate that discussion with the right context, naturally-those who could have strong incentives not to do so.. but the (almost unheard of in mainstream) perspectives you provide are why I'm a subscriber. Thank you and keep up the great work!

The Radical Individualist's avatar

For the life of me I don't understand how the 'man in the street' thinks big government is there to protect us from big industry.

Big industry has the money, and the money talks. Politicians listen to the money. Yes, it's that simple.

BForsythe's avatar

This is a great write-up. I've been discussing the same point with my wife, saying that there seems to be a concerted effort to get a regulatory moat built around the big boys' AI business to keep the small guys and open-source models out.

Alice's avatar

Great point. And it is like Warren Buffet and others of his ilk whining about their secretary paying more in taxes. It keeps the pitchfork crowd at bay making them look like the reasonable, good guys.

IanDavidLea's avatar

I had to read more and a search for Gabriel Kolko's regulatory capture theory useful

rtko's avatar

I believe this article provides some foundational logic for this topic:

https://escapekey.substack.com/p/risk?r=62k4n&utm_medium=ios