This piece gets so many things wrong it is difficult to know where to begin. Who is the author referring to when she mentions "neoconservatives?" Why not specifically name them? If anything, the United States has been overly patient with putting up with attacks by the Houthis on its assets in the region. Disappointing to see such a misinformed and trashy piece given space by QTR.
“Already, US involvement in the Israeli-Palestinian war has cost taxpayers $3.3 billion annually, with an additional $14.5 billion check following October 7. This involvement isn’t only costly to American taxpayers, but it threatens American national security as well.” What? The US provides Israel with $3.3 billion in military aid annually, spent in the US. This statement is demonstrably false. The $14.5 billion is supplemental aid is pending.
Compare that cost to keeping troops in Germany and South Korea. Why doesn’t the author rail about why we’re spending many billions to “ protect allies” who erect non tariff barriers to trade and mooch off of us?
There’s a war against Palestinians? Is the author talking about the response to the October 7th massacre? If 90,000 Americans were killed in a gory brutal way and 12,000 taken hostage, what would the US do? It’s hard to respond without descending into my Miami auto junkyard roots, but suffice it to say that the “war” is against Hamas, who taken over Gaza, and almost everyone has been involved in aiding them in spending billions in “aid” in building concrete reinforced tunnels, converting every UN facility, hospital, masjid and school into an armed camp, teaching kindergartners to hate Jews (and all other people outside the Ummah), and prepare for war.
Yes, the Constitution must be obeyed, but no armed conflict has had a declaration of war by Congress since when, 1941? Why is this exceptional? Because it involves Israel? There is concrete harm being caused by these people who have no dog in the fight. The world is full of cowards. The Houthis are poking the non slumbering giant and filling it with a terrible resolve. FAFO is what happens in today’s world.
This is Woke Mises at work. They are free to write and you to publish whatever they want, but take it with a box of salt. I call BS, except on the lack of Congressional activity to bless further involvement. That ain’t going to happen and I guarantee that there will not be two US boots on the ground in that conflict. I’ve rambled too long. I call BS.
The reason there’s such an emphasis on Israel-Palestine globally is because it’s one of the most deadly conflicts in the 21st century. As Oxfam states, “ Using publicly available data, Oxfam calculated that number of average deaths per day for Gaza is significantly higher than any recent major armed conflict including Syria (96.5 deaths per day), Sudan (51.6), Iraq (50.8), Ukraine (43.9) Afghanistan (23.8) and Yemen (15.8).” It’s 250 Palestinians killed daily, 70% women and children (https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/daily-death-rate-gaza-higher-any-other-major-21st-century-conflict-oxfam). Americans aren’t living under a 16 year blockade and a 75 year occupation.
Gaza was NOT occupied and their fellow Sunni Muslim brothers in Egypt could have had an open border with them. Why is that hermetically sealed? Hamas hijacked the entire enclave and made it into a irredentist, open sore, armed to the teeth, brainwashing the people with the fantasy that they will one day slaughter all the Kuffirs (that includes you, Vadim) and take over Israel. Hamas is solely to blame for what's going on in Gaza. #FAFO. "There's lies, damn lies, and statistics." Mark Twain
They could have been like Singapore. Instead they have been hijacked. My son was a paratrooper in the IDF and voted for Tzipi Livni. Bibi is scum, but that's all beside the point. They chose Hamas. Live by the sword die be the sword.
So now you’re going on about the 2005 “withdrawal” from Gaza. Even Israeli human rights group B’Tselem admits, “ Yet the fact is that Israel still holds almost all powers pertaining to Gaza residents and determines what their daily lives look like, in no small part due to its near-complete control over the movement of people and goods in and out of the Gaza Strip.” You’re also totally ignoring Israel’s role in assisting Hamas. “ “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas. This is part of our strategy — to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” That’s your likely beloved Bibi for you. The Sunnis in the UAE and Saudi don’t give a damn about Palestinians and that’s obvious. There, Allah isn’t God; the Riyal is.
Can't let it go without correcting another misleading statement made by the author of this piece. One can make a true statement that misleads, and that is what the writer does whe she correctly says the Constitution gives Congess, not the president, the power to declare war. So yes, the president cannot initiate any large-scale military action on his own. But that is not happening in Yemen. The US strikes are not initiating a war, but responding to attack. For weeks, the Houthis had been launching indiscriminate attacks on shipping in the Red Sea, and we finally have started countering in a meaningful way.
The president does not need advance congressional authorization to respond to attacks on US troops, territory, or American ships on the high seas. If that were so we would sit helplessly mired in political back and forths while enemies rained havoc upon our troops, territories, or other assets. Regarding the Houthis, it was not the US that that initiated the conflict, but the Houthis. Defensive responses may include offensive actions, such as targeting the bases and other facilities the Houthis used to launch their attacks on shipping.
Hopefully a forceful response by the United States will give pause to the Houthis, and to other hostile nations or entities, before they take arms against us or our interests.
As for any interest we might have in supporting Israel, aside from being an ally, Americans were killed in the October 7th Hamas invasion of Israel, and about two dozen taken hostage and then later killed by Hamas or because of Hamas. Some Americans have remained captive in Gaza for 90+ days, and IDF efforts to procure their release spares the need for the United States to send American soldiers into that region to free them. Houthi efforts to thwart such efforts by the IDF directly impact attempts to free Americans still held hostage.
I would like to clarify a point for the author of the article. A strike on the Houthi is not a strike on Yemen. The Houthi are not recognized as the legal government by anyone except the Houthi and Iran since they are paying the bills and salaries. Did the US get permission from the recognized Yemeni government for a strike on their sovereign soil? I don’t know, but I would guess no. That is the problem, not the fact there was a strike on the Houthi, but there was a strike on Yemeni soil, and we don’t know if permission was gained.
I haven’t heard of the Yemen government rounding up Houthi terrorists, so there must be tacit approval of the Houthi’s actions by the Yemeni government. Do you think the US government would sit passively by while terrorists from a Texas militia fire rockets into Mexico? And if the US government did nothing to stop them, would we blame the Federales for wiping out the Texas militia’s headquarters and arms depot?
The “legitimate government of Yemen” is hiding out in Saudi Arabia. How was Hadi, the “legitimate President of Yemen” during the Arab spring protest elected? Only his name was in the ballot. It was Ansarallah that invited the UN to sign a peace deal between all major parties resulting in the signing of a “Peace and National Partnership” agreement. And as you said, I’m pretty sure the US isn’t asking the current recognized president for permission to strike the Yemeni homeland
The last good governance ended in 2014 with the death of the president. the Hadid government stepped down in 2017. There is a three way civil war going on with no end in site... Ansarallah or Ansarullah is not a person. it is what Houthi means in Arabic.
Hadi took office in 2012. And he was not a good president. Lol, again it was a totally sham election. Ansarallah is what the movement is actually called, that is what their supporters will call themselves. No one there calls themselves “Houthis,” as houthi is just the last name of the movement’s leader. What? Houthi is not a translation of Ansarallah. Ansarallah means in Arabic supporters of God.
Not a fan of this, despite generally liking the Mises Institute. The author gets a lot wrong and omits critical background info. They are a vitamin entrepreneur with what likely amounts to zero relevant experience in military analysis.
The Houthi Red Sea activity has already forced shipping costs higher via increased insurance premiums and longer routes. The US waited to take action until what... the 100th attack?
For another perspective, check out the guys at FDD’s Long War Journal. In particular, their podcast, Generation Jihad. You are my favorite financial podcast. They are my favorite re the Middle East and the forever wars.
If you actually want the Red Sea attacks to stop, consider what Trita Parsi (Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft researcher and Iran expert) said on the topic: “ A few thoughts on the US and UK's plans to imminently bomb Yemen in retaliation for Houthi attacks on ships in the Red Sea, which the Houthis have struck to pressure Israel to cease its slaughter in Gaza.
First of all, the UN resolution that condemns the Houthis does not authorize the use of force, though it acknowledges the right of self-defense for the countries whose vessels have been attacked.
Secondly, if the objective is to stop Houthi attacks without escalating matters toward a full war, then bombing them has proven quite inefficient in the past. Just ask the the Saudis.
Moreover, bombing them very likely will escalate matters, which means that not only will the attacks not be stopped, but the broader war that Biden seeks to prevent will likely become a reality.
Indeed, if the objective is to stop them, a ceasefire in Gaza is far more likely to succeed. The Houthis have declared that they will stop if Israel stops, and during the 6 days there was a ceasefire (in November), there was only one attack in the Red Sea that can be attributed to the Houthis.
A ceasefire would also pacify tensions in Iraq/Syria vis-a-vis the US, not to mention win the release of the Israeli hostages held by Hamas.
The question then is why the US and the UK are so adamant about rejecting the policy that is most likely to succeed and instead pursuing the policy that is the most likely to escalate matters even further?
This shows, once more, that for every day that there is no ceasefire in Gaza, we will move closer and closer to the war spreading and the US once again fighting a war of choice in the Middle East.”
I'm not going to get sucked in to a political battle with key-board warriors, but I will stand on the fact that as a USMC Veteran who has been to more countries than I can remember, the USA needs to STOP constantly immersing itself into conflicts everywhere. The damage that has been done to this nation over the last 35 years is irreparable, and it's only getting worse. The slippery slope get's steeper, and the descent increases in velocity. NO empire lasts forever.
“In response to the Israeli assault on Gaza,” starts the article. Thus ending any semblance of real analysis. Here is the summary- oppressors bad, oppressed good, now write whatever nonsense you want to justify that truth.
"According to the War Powers Resolution of 1973, "Only Congress can extend any foreign military action taken beyond the initial involvement," yet the rhetoric from Washington doesn’t acknowledge this. Instead, we get the following from Pentagon spokesman Patrick Ryder: “Our military will not hesitate to take action where we deem it necessary and appropriate, including to protect against actions in the maritime domain that could threaten our troops.”"
The president acted within his rights under the Naval Act of 1794 as a legitimate response to the January 9th attack on 4 U.S. flag merchant ships.
Furthermore:
"Section 8.2.d of the War Powers Act explicitly state that the Act does not alter the constitutional authority of either the President or Congress.
Further, the Supreme Court has affirmed that the President is acting under his constitutional authority when he is "bound to resist force by force" in the event of enemy-initiated hostilities (Prize Cases of 1863).
This piece gets so many things wrong it is difficult to know where to begin. Who is the author referring to when she mentions "neoconservatives?" Why not specifically name them? If anything, the United States has been overly patient with putting up with attacks by the Houthis on its assets in the region. Disappointing to see such a misinformed and trashy piece given space by QTR.
Yes, the US has been putting up with the Houthi’s ongoing attacks — UNTIL they attacked US-flagged ships. As soon as they did that, we responded. RedState’s Streiff explains the difference between Houthis attacking “international commerce” and their attacking “US ships”: https://redstate.com/streiff/2024/01/12/a-morning-after-look-at-the-strike-on-yemen-and-what-it-is-likely-to-mean-n2168651
The author doesn't even mention the October 7th massacre in which 30+ Americans were killed.
Please remove this Jihadi symphatizer drivel propaganda.
One has NOTHING to do with the other.
Yeah, its justa coincidence that houthi goes alla-snackbar right after hamas.
“Already, US involvement in the Israeli-Palestinian war has cost taxpayers $3.3 billion annually, with an additional $14.5 billion check following October 7. This involvement isn’t only costly to American taxpayers, but it threatens American national security as well.” What? The US provides Israel with $3.3 billion in military aid annually, spent in the US. This statement is demonstrably false. The $14.5 billion is supplemental aid is pending.
Compare that cost to keeping troops in Germany and South Korea. Why doesn’t the author rail about why we’re spending many billions to “ protect allies” who erect non tariff barriers to trade and mooch off of us?
There’s a war against Palestinians? Is the author talking about the response to the October 7th massacre? If 90,000 Americans were killed in a gory brutal way and 12,000 taken hostage, what would the US do? It’s hard to respond without descending into my Miami auto junkyard roots, but suffice it to say that the “war” is against Hamas, who taken over Gaza, and almost everyone has been involved in aiding them in spending billions in “aid” in building concrete reinforced tunnels, converting every UN facility, hospital, masjid and school into an armed camp, teaching kindergartners to hate Jews (and all other people outside the Ummah), and prepare for war.
Yes, the Constitution must be obeyed, but no armed conflict has had a declaration of war by Congress since when, 1941? Why is this exceptional? Because it involves Israel? There is concrete harm being caused by these people who have no dog in the fight. The world is full of cowards. The Houthis are poking the non slumbering giant and filling it with a terrible resolve. FAFO is what happens in today’s world.
This is Woke Mises at work. They are free to write and you to publish whatever they want, but take it with a box of salt. I call BS, except on the lack of Congressional activity to bless further involvement. That ain’t going to happen and I guarantee that there will not be two US boots on the ground in that conflict. I’ve rambled too long. I call BS.
The reason there’s such an emphasis on Israel-Palestine globally is because it’s one of the most deadly conflicts in the 21st century. As Oxfam states, “ Using publicly available data, Oxfam calculated that number of average deaths per day for Gaza is significantly higher than any recent major armed conflict including Syria (96.5 deaths per day), Sudan (51.6), Iraq (50.8), Ukraine (43.9) Afghanistan (23.8) and Yemen (15.8).” It’s 250 Palestinians killed daily, 70% women and children (https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/daily-death-rate-gaza-higher-any-other-major-21st-century-conflict-oxfam). Americans aren’t living under a 16 year blockade and a 75 year occupation.
Gaza was NOT occupied and their fellow Sunni Muslim brothers in Egypt could have had an open border with them. Why is that hermetically sealed? Hamas hijacked the entire enclave and made it into a irredentist, open sore, armed to the teeth, brainwashing the people with the fantasy that they will one day slaughter all the Kuffirs (that includes you, Vadim) and take over Israel. Hamas is solely to blame for what's going on in Gaza. #FAFO. "There's lies, damn lies, and statistics." Mark Twain
And you ignored my comment Egypt has a border and they seal it. Blame them for lack of access, food, wevr.
They could have been like Singapore. Instead they have been hijacked. My son was a paratrooper in the IDF and voted for Tzipi Livni. Bibi is scum, but that's all beside the point. They chose Hamas. Live by the sword die be the sword.
So now you’re going on about the 2005 “withdrawal” from Gaza. Even Israeli human rights group B’Tselem admits, “ Yet the fact is that Israel still holds almost all powers pertaining to Gaza residents and determines what their daily lives look like, in no small part due to its near-complete control over the movement of people and goods in and out of the Gaza Strip.” You’re also totally ignoring Israel’s role in assisting Hamas. “ “Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas. This is part of our strategy — to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” That’s your likely beloved Bibi for you. The Sunnis in the UAE and Saudi don’t give a damn about Palestinians and that’s obvious. There, Allah isn’t God; the Riyal is.
Mr. Irons, your rubbish publish attracts binladens and sinwars to your substack.
You sure OK with that ?
…because apparently being against US support of Israel makes you Bin Laden. Got it. Notice how you didn’t actually respond to what I said.
I didn’t know the Mises Institute is a pro-terrorist organization. Thanks for the clarification.
Can't let it go without correcting another misleading statement made by the author of this piece. One can make a true statement that misleads, and that is what the writer does whe she correctly says the Constitution gives Congess, not the president, the power to declare war. So yes, the president cannot initiate any large-scale military action on his own. But that is not happening in Yemen. The US strikes are not initiating a war, but responding to attack. For weeks, the Houthis had been launching indiscriminate attacks on shipping in the Red Sea, and we finally have started countering in a meaningful way.
The president does not need advance congressional authorization to respond to attacks on US troops, territory, or American ships on the high seas. If that were so we would sit helplessly mired in political back and forths while enemies rained havoc upon our troops, territories, or other assets. Regarding the Houthis, it was not the US that that initiated the conflict, but the Houthis. Defensive responses may include offensive actions, such as targeting the bases and other facilities the Houthis used to launch their attacks on shipping.
Hopefully a forceful response by the United States will give pause to the Houthis, and to other hostile nations or entities, before they take arms against us or our interests.
As for any interest we might have in supporting Israel, aside from being an ally, Americans were killed in the October 7th Hamas invasion of Israel, and about two dozen taken hostage and then later killed by Hamas or because of Hamas. Some Americans have remained captive in Gaza for 90+ days, and IDF efforts to procure their release spares the need for the United States to send American soldiers into that region to free them. Houthi efforts to thwart such efforts by the IDF directly impact attempts to free Americans still held hostage.
I would like to clarify a point for the author of the article. A strike on the Houthi is not a strike on Yemen. The Houthi are not recognized as the legal government by anyone except the Houthi and Iran since they are paying the bills and salaries. Did the US get permission from the recognized Yemeni government for a strike on their sovereign soil? I don’t know, but I would guess no. That is the problem, not the fact there was a strike on the Houthi, but there was a strike on Yemeni soil, and we don’t know if permission was gained.
I haven’t heard of the Yemen government rounding up Houthi terrorists, so there must be tacit approval of the Houthi’s actions by the Yemeni government. Do you think the US government would sit passively by while terrorists from a Texas militia fire rockets into Mexico? And if the US government did nothing to stop them, would we blame the Federales for wiping out the Texas militia’s headquarters and arms depot?
https://www.memri.org/reports/yemens-iran-backed-houthi-movement-–-brief-primer-view-recent-escalation-against-israel-and
The Yemen government has been in a civil war with the Houthis for a decade.
The “legitimate government of Yemen” is hiding out in Saudi Arabia. How was Hadi, the “legitimate President of Yemen” during the Arab spring protest elected? Only his name was in the ballot. It was Ansarallah that invited the UN to sign a peace deal between all major parties resulting in the signing of a “Peace and National Partnership” agreement. And as you said, I’m pretty sure the US isn’t asking the current recognized president for permission to strike the Yemeni homeland
The last good governance ended in 2014 with the death of the president. the Hadid government stepped down in 2017. There is a three way civil war going on with no end in site... Ansarallah or Ansarullah is not a person. it is what Houthi means in Arabic.
Hadi took office in 2012. And he was not a good president. Lol, again it was a totally sham election. Ansarallah is what the movement is actually called, that is what their supporters will call themselves. No one there calls themselves “Houthis,” as houthi is just the last name of the movement’s leader. What? Houthi is not a translation of Ansarallah. Ansarallah means in Arabic supporters of God.
Not a fan of this, despite generally liking the Mises Institute. The author gets a lot wrong and omits critical background info. They are a vitamin entrepreneur with what likely amounts to zero relevant experience in military analysis.
The Houthi Red Sea activity has already forced shipping costs higher via increased insurance premiums and longer routes. The US waited to take action until what... the 100th attack?
For another perspective, check out the guys at FDD’s Long War Journal. In particular, their podcast, Generation Jihad. You are my favorite financial podcast. They are my favorite re the Middle East and the forever wars.
The problem with groups like Mises is that they think of war as if it were a business, and the two are very different.
If you actually want the Red Sea attacks to stop, consider what Trita Parsi (Quincy Institute for Responsible Statecraft researcher and Iran expert) said on the topic: “ A few thoughts on the US and UK's plans to imminently bomb Yemen in retaliation for Houthi attacks on ships in the Red Sea, which the Houthis have struck to pressure Israel to cease its slaughter in Gaza.
First of all, the UN resolution that condemns the Houthis does not authorize the use of force, though it acknowledges the right of self-defense for the countries whose vessels have been attacked.
Secondly, if the objective is to stop Houthi attacks without escalating matters toward a full war, then bombing them has proven quite inefficient in the past. Just ask the the Saudis.
Moreover, bombing them very likely will escalate matters, which means that not only will the attacks not be stopped, but the broader war that Biden seeks to prevent will likely become a reality.
Indeed, if the objective is to stop them, a ceasefire in Gaza is far more likely to succeed. The Houthis have declared that they will stop if Israel stops, and during the 6 days there was a ceasefire (in November), there was only one attack in the Red Sea that can be attributed to the Houthis.
A ceasefire would also pacify tensions in Iraq/Syria vis-a-vis the US, not to mention win the release of the Israeli hostages held by Hamas.
The question then is why the US and the UK are so adamant about rejecting the policy that is most likely to succeed and instead pursuing the policy that is the most likely to escalate matters even further?
This shows, once more, that for every day that there is no ceasefire in Gaza, we will move closer and closer to the war spreading and the US once again fighting a war of choice in the Middle East.”
I'm not going to get sucked in to a political battle with key-board warriors, but I will stand on the fact that as a USMC Veteran who has been to more countries than I can remember, the USA needs to STOP constantly immersing itself into conflicts everywhere. The damage that has been done to this nation over the last 35 years is irreparable, and it's only getting worse. The slippery slope get's steeper, and the descent increases in velocity. NO empire lasts forever.
“In response to the Israeli assault on Gaza,” starts the article. Thus ending any semblance of real analysis. Here is the summary- oppressors bad, oppressed good, now write whatever nonsense you want to justify that truth.
Another ‘tell’ of where this author is coming from is citing Human Rights Watch & Amnesty International as though the6 are credible organizations.
"According to the War Powers Resolution of 1973, "Only Congress can extend any foreign military action taken beyond the initial involvement," yet the rhetoric from Washington doesn’t acknowledge this. Instead, we get the following from Pentagon spokesman Patrick Ryder: “Our military will not hesitate to take action where we deem it necessary and appropriate, including to protect against actions in the maritime domain that could threaten our troops.”"
The president acted within his rights under the Naval Act of 1794 as a legitimate response to the January 9th attack on 4 U.S. flag merchant ships.
Furthermore:
"Section 8.2.d of the War Powers Act explicitly state that the Act does not alter the constitutional authority of either the President or Congress.
Further, the Supreme Court has affirmed that the President is acting under his constitutional authority when he is "bound to resist force by force" in the event of enemy-initiated hostilities (Prize Cases of 1863).
The War Powers Act is more about limiting a president's ability to commit the nation to protracted wars and campaigns without Congressional authorization." https://x.com/maphumanintent/status/1745860078568132825?s=20