29 Comments
User's avatar
Mrs Bucket's avatar

The idea of popping pills to 'cure' lifestyle problems is a modern curse.

george's avatar

They were called "Snakeoilsmen" back in the day. Some were called Alchemists. There is nothing new under the sun.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Scary shit, maybe just get a couple more covid vaccines instead.

Mike's avatar

Could not be more spot on. Almost every portly or overweight person in my orbit the past few years all of a sudden melted away.

Idk. As a laman it seemed obvious to me that shooting something intravenously, largely for vanity, was not gonna end well.

Walker's avatar

I'm 77. I am in excellent health and am told that I am in better health and physical condition than 90% of people my age. What's my secret? I think it has a lot to do with the fact I take no pharmaceuticals. I take no vaccines.

James's avatar

One of the things they don’t tell you is that you’re not just losing fat, but muscle and bone when you take these GLP-1 inhibitors. For older people, sarcopenia (muscle loss) is a big problem that require higher protein intake and resistance training. Greater muscle mass is correlated with longevity (as is higher LDL cholesterol levels, but that’s another story).

Stronger core muscle means reduced chance of hip fractures, a real killer of the elderly. Unfortunately, GLP-1s also cause loss of bone and there is a correlation of GLP-1 use with higher incidence of hip fractures.

Instead of drugs, eat a proper human diet, carnivore/ketovore, and do resistance training.

Andrew P's avatar

All weight loss by dieting will cause the loss of both muscle and fat. Exercise can help prevent much of the muscle loss.

James's avatar

People who have resorted to injecting themselves with a drug have already shown that they’ve given up on exercise.

You don’t need to diet (calorie restrict) to lose weight; that’s a loser strategy in the long run. Just eat a diet high in animal protein and fat and greatly restrict your carb intake.

Andrew P's avatar

The easy way to diet is to simply cut out 1 (or 2) meals a day, and no snacking. You don't need 3 meals a day unless you are doing heavy physical labor like farm or construction work.

James's avatar

Was reviewing an old interview with Dr. Paul Mason. Almost 40% of the weight loss from the GLP-1 trials came from muscle and bone.

Andrew P's avatar

The overall risk of dying of COVID was about 3-4 per 1000. For someone young, 1 in 10,000 or less is about right. One reason there was so much panic is so many were dying at once, since it was contagious and the most vulnerable died first. It also caused very long (expensive) hospitalizations for the vulnerable.

Every big wave of weight loss drugs produces side effect stories, then come restrictions and bans. The uppers used for weight loss in the 1970s worked too, then later they were banned.

Steve Mudge's avatar

My friends Mom said the weight loss pills in the late 50s were even more potent, lol.

Say It Aint So's avatar

Similar to when the Covid vaccines came out...my neighbor, a victim of TDS, was exuberant about the vaccines...My thoughts were, "Do they really have enough of a track record or history with these? Was time really of the essence...vaccines usually take years to develop...even in this day and age...From Discover Magazine:

Salk's Polio Vaccine

Armed with the knowledge of the three types of poliovirus, as well as a steady supply of all three, American virologist Jonas Salk developed the first promising vaccine against polio in 1952. After several small trials, the vaccine was tested in the Francis Field Trial, which was then the most massive medical field test in the U.S.

Named after Thomas Francis, the administrator of the test, the trial involved almost 2 million individuals who received injections of a vaccine or a placebo, or who received nothing at all. After observing the participants to determine whether the vaccine reduced their chances of contracting polio, Francis concluded in April 1955 that the vaccine was 60 to 70 percent effective against PV1 and 90 percent effective against PV2 and PV3.

These weight loss drugs are the Pharmaceutical industry developing a "cure" for the country's poor nutrition and eating habits...

Randy's avatar

When these GLP-1 drugs are finally withdrawn from the market, as fen-phen was decades ago, all the weight people lost will return. That fact is already in the fact sheet. Enjoy your weight loss while you can, because you’re paying big bucks for a temporary benefit.

Terry's avatar

Perhaps in 15-20 years from now we will be inundated with Camp Lejeune type ads due to the side effects of the GLP1s.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Add in the fact that the weight loss is primarily from muscle loss and these drugs are another dose of Russian Roulette from our beloved Pharmaceutical-Industrial Death Complex.

fab's avatar

People like a free lunch so much. These drugs act on the pancreas. It's frightening.

Judy Mariuz's avatar

I've been suspicious of these weight loss drugs from the get go and thankfully have no need for them. Thank you for calling attention to this "rare" potential complication. Not only do you provide a valuable service, but you make me laugh as I read your articles. You are a very talented writer as well as a gifted investment analyst. I don't know how you manage to generate so much content, but I definitely appreciate your work!

george's avatar

They'll just find a drug with a side effect which addresses this, and then find a drug..........

STEVE SHIRLEY's avatar

This was a particularly sad non-scientific commentary on GLP-1 agonists. There is no attempt at risk-benefit comparisons, which is the true measure of any drug interventions. GLP-1 drugs were found to reduce the risk of major adverse cardiovascular events like cardiovascular death, nonfatal heart attack, and nonfatal strokes. That doesn’t matter apparently to those obsessed with fat shaming, or making fun of people with metabolic disorders. Go ‘Murica!!! I don’t take the drug, btw, but worked as a healthcare provider for 32 years.

Steve S's avatar

Prescribing GLP-1s for weight control seems nuts to me. It was originally researched and tested as a means of glucose control for folks that had Type 2 Diabetes, or were headed in that direction. Drug testing also showed weight loss across the board for folk taking the drugs. This was a good essay but didn't address its effectiveness towards lowering blood sugar short and long term, and how it compares in that regard to other drugs, or to maintaining glucose control strictly through dieting. Most folk taking GLP-1 for glucose control have either tried dieting, reducing or eliminating carbs, and it didn't work. Same with taking metformin and SLGPT-2 drugs like Jardiance. Uncontrolled Type 2 Diabetes is worse than side effects from any of these drugs.

Randy's avatar

There’s a whole lot more fat folks than those with diabetes, so it is better for the manufacturers’ bottom line to market the drug for weight loss. Fortunately, after GLP-1 drugs are withdrawn from the market, there are many other drugs for diabetes that people can take — including insulin, which has been around for 95 years — that don’t kill you or make you blind.

Jonathan Polloni's avatar

Excuse me, did this author just compare the risk factor to Covid, and then use that to blame a lack of oversight whilst at the same time blaming Covid reactions as being horrifically overblown and tyrannical??