77 Comments
User's avatar
Energy Engr's avatar

I was just speaking to a friend about this yesterday, and I told him that I’ve realized many people are not really anchored to reality as much as they are anchored to incentives, hopes, and narratives.

As an engineer, my whole career is based on physical limitations. You do not design a system around optimistic loads. You design around worst-case scenarios, volatility, failure modes, and margins of safety. You do that because intermittent and extreme events do happen, and the system has to survive both the average case and the outlier.

Our economic system often seems to run in the opposite direction. It runs on optimism, leverage, and the assumption that bad outcomes are unlikely or manageable. Many bulls struggle to seriously price in downside because doing so conflicts with their own self-interest. But physics and economic gravity eventually reassert themselves, whether through corrections, inflation, layoffs, reduced activity, or some other forced adjustment.

The strange part is that indices no longer merely measure the system. Increasingly, they drive the system.

When people emotionally disagree with someone pointing out risks, I think it is often tied to a conflict of interest. They are invested in X or Y, financially or psychologically, and facts that challenge that investment feel like opposition. I’ve learned to be less blunt with people who are sensitive to that, especially when I care about the relationship. Otherwise, I tend to be pretty direct.

Keep up the great work

Denis Cowley's avatar

What a great sentence; "many people are not really anchored to reality as much as they are anchored to incentives, hopes, and narratives."

John Dumke's avatar

"The system has to survive both the average case and the outlier".

I love the engineering design analogy, but then again of course I would, I am an engineer.

If only our politicians and monetary leaders were held to similar principles.., ah but yes, eventually they will.

El Doco's avatar

Hi Chris, I'm a new paid subscriber, and I pretty much never comment on Substack articles, but I'll comment on this one. You won't lose me as a subscriber for being skeptical and questioning things, nor do I think it makes you a "doomer." Frankly, we live in very stupid times. If you lose paid subscribers for not cheerleading SpaceX or Microstrategy, that says a lot more about them than about you. Don't sweat it too much. If you do or say ANYthing in public, some people will hate you for it. Goes with the territory.

I appreciated your post some weeks ago where you discussed stepping back, disconnecting from things a bit, and taking on a calmer and more thoughtful mindset. We're about the same age; I think I'm 1-2 years older. We're clearly very different people in some ways -- you're a self-described "tattooed former bartender" while I have no tattoos and don't even drink, let alone tending bar. But like you, I have also found that embracing calm, acceptance, and humility has greatly improved my mental and emotional life as I've gotten older. I think it's a type of maturation. And like you, I also think of modern markets, and really modern society and culture in general, as one big degenerate casino. I think in some ways we are intellectual fellow travelers despite many superficial differences.

Regardless, keep fighting the good fight and don't let haters get you down.

Cheers.

CashWarper's avatar

Stay the course. Don't mix personal with business. We each have a business persona that asks the tough questions and performs due diligence. Let's face it. We don't agree with anyone on 100% of all issues. That is okay. If you tone it down, I will cancel my subscription :)

Mike's avatar

If the fact that Iran is walking us around like a leashed Golden Doodle doesn't tell these people the story behind the curtain, then they are beyond reach.

QTR to the bitter end. 🍻

dk's avatar

Bro, this is the “Age of Rage”, where either you walk lockstep with bad ideas, or you’re “cancelled”.

I became a paid sub EXACTLY for your honesty. I enjoy reality.

Lawrence Fossi's avatar

When a National Review subscriber would become angry at William F. Buckley, Jr. over something he wrote, and write a letter to the editor demanding he cancel their subscription, his response was always, "Cancel your own damned subscription!"

I think that's the right attitude.

Skepticism is healthy. Civil disagreement is healthy. Changing one's views when evidence compels a change is healthy.

Keep fighting the good fight.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

I’ll have to remember that one.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

Keep going. Your opinions have value precisely because they question the status quo. If that pisses some group or individual off, so be it. Uncomfortable questions lead to knowledge frequently. I enjoy your writing and opinions.

As far as the ones that left? Meh. They probably want another Bitcoin sycophant. That’s not objective or of value in a decision matrix.

Carry on please Chris.

I’ll leave with this.

"You have power over your mind — not outside events. Realise this, and you will find strength."

Marcus Aurelius.

Paine Of Glass's avatar

Keep fighting the good fight! I happen to disagree with you on a few things, like Tesla-but so fucking what? I could end up being totally wrong, you could end up being totally wrong-either way I want, and NEED the balance of a reasoned logical counter argument. With some “fucks” thrown in still please. Keep up the good work sir

Mark Hepburn's avatar

Hiya Chris - you'll never lose me either. At 65 I've I've more than fair share of manias; the human mind has a distinct ability to convince itself of whatever gives itself validation. It's a bug, not a feature. Just knowing that makes you a better investor. Warren B. has seen many of these cycles, he can see the BS and the crowd convincing themselves that current conditions are creating the age-old "this time it's different", and he's stacking cash.... with Jeremy Grantham, Howard Marks et al telling us the king has no clothes your missive is 100% on point. MSTR is the posterchild for the malfeasance of the current mania. Your piece on stepping back from trading and this piece should be tattoo'd on the foreheads of all wannabe investors. Keep up the great work of calling BS where it deserves to be called!

Brett Howser's avatar

I’m a paid subscriber because of all the reasons you are being criticised for. Listen to me, not them. Carry on.

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Its a burden you have to bear for being logical.

The Color Of Air's avatar

Things change. One man's doom is another man's riches. Question everything. There is no other way to live sanely.

RS Carvey's avatar

This is 100% relatable and maybe the dumbest thing about how Western society has evolved over the past 20 years: “Yesterday I nearly lost a dear longtime friend who I respect immensely because he was upset that I criticized Strategy CEO Phong Le on Twitter. The worst part is this is a friend who I agree with on literally almost everything…”

Lisa Price's avatar

Hey Chris, perhaps you could also discuss the theory that the stock market is no longer an indicator (leading) but now a policy tool. From a taxation standpoint, the government will protect cap gains tax revenues at all costs. It is what prevents the sustained corrections you and others have been warning may be coming is direct intervention. In a fixed market there can be no true correction.

Eduardo Peña's avatar

May I recommend 'Extraordinary Popular Delusions And The Madness Of Crowds' by Charles MacKay, first published almost 200 years ago, republished in multiple volumes since. It's on Amazon.

What was true 400 years ago with Tulip Mania (fucking tulips??), 300 years ago with the Mississippi swindle & the John Law Company, and the South Seas bubble...is still true today. The more things change, the more they stay the same. History says this ends in tears.

Andrew P's avatar

What is different today is not only does the government need to keep the bubble going, but they have the tools necessary to make this happen. Back in the South Seas bubble days, the UK Parliament didn't know what they were doing. They were just riding the bubble with the general public. Today they have modern knowledge and modern tools. The only thing that could break the bubbles is a permanent change in psychology that would cause people to put all their retirement funds in government bonds - en masse. And the government has the legal tools to make sure that can't happen, since they can make stocks and corporate debt the only legal options. Even natural disasters wouldn't stop the bubbles because the money printer would go to 1E11. The only thing that could break this is a mass die-off of old people, forcing 50-100 million estates to be liquidated simultaneously. New pandemic anyone?

Manny P's avatar

Another great piece. Yes being skeptical is not in fashion