86 Comments
User's avatar
J Heisen's avatar

This is a very practical take on the current situation. For those of us Gen X-ers and older Millenials, the state of affairs for the last couple decades has been as frustrating as it was predictable. Buying cheaper and cheaper consumer products while debt skyrockets seemed like the most short-sighted of trade-offs. Through a roundabout way, non U.S. products were being subsidized by future U.S. taxpayers. And we’re not talking about products that generate future revenue or have lasting value. Incentivize the behavior you want. We haven’t quite been doing that…

No easy way to put the toothpaste back in the tube, and while this may be a painful start, at least it’s a start. As a railroader, I spend a lot of time in long forgotten about parts of the U.S. that used to represent its backbone. It’s sad to see. And while they may not all flourish once again, it’s time we at least consider policies that give them a chance. Perhaps this strategy implodes. But we’ve been reinforcing the definition of insanity for too long. Good or bad, I’m grateful we’re taking a new direction.

Andy Fately's avatar

🎯 spot on Chris. What's remarkable is the same people who have tut-tutted that the $36 trillion debt is unsustainable are now crying that in an effort to change things, stock prices have fallen a few percent. the financialization of the economy since the response to the GFC has been toxic for at least 80% of the population. as much as the media may cry, those folks are happier today than they were on Monday

American Psycho's avatar

Andy, your comments (here and elsewhere) are consistently insightful and concise.

Cruising Economist's avatar

A relatively small minority will benefit from trade restrictions, though perhaps not as much as some imagine, but remember 100% of Americans are consumers and they are all going to suffer to one degree or another. We live as well as we do largely due to gains from free trade. Also, for many decades Americans have been enjoying the benefit of being able to conjure money out of thin air to buy real goods from overseas without having to work to produce anything of real value in return since a large portion of those dollars were simply held overseas (in addition to benefiting from exporting some of our inflation). Diminishment of those benefits will be painful.

In short, the majority of Americans are going to end up working harder for less which isn't a path to societal well-being and contentment.

Then of course there's the monstrous secular financial bubble which may have found it's pin (or hot knife in this case) along with inevitable detonation of DC's fiscal time bomb at some point, the fireworks likely now accelerated.

You better be holding your wealth in tangible assets folks!

Michael Woods's avatar

It's a beautiful and accurate summary. (my opinion obviously). I believe, over time, it will be recognized as prescient. Thanks

Alexis Kaiser's avatar

You are completely right. Caddo County Oklahoma is another victim of globalization. I was among those who believed that Clinton was right in offshoring industry, but I think that anyone who looks around now cannot say that this was the intended result. In rural Oklahoma, almost all lower middle-class marriages fail, because there are no jobs for the men except on the oil rigs, and very few men are cut out for that work. Consequently, women who can get jobs, teaching or nursing will end up making substantially more than their husbands, which is a recipe for failed marriage, which is a recipe for single parent households, which is a recipe for huge problems with the youth, especially the young men. It is a seemingly inescapable cycle. God bless Trump for trying this approach. We can't know whether it will work, but what we have been doing has not been working.

IcePickedSlim's avatar

No one is "completely (absolutely) right," about anything.

Greg Strebel's avatar

Sure, a shake-up is needed, but the tariff calculations were completely bonkers. https://www.moonofalabama.org/2025/04/white-house-lacks-financial-literacy-tariffs-show.html#more

How about we shake up our foreign policy and quit interfering in the internal affairs of other countries via regime change, invasion etc. We could invest a whole pile of the DoD budget into improvements in infrastructure and manufacturing technology here at home.

Andy Fately's avatar

arguably, it is irrelevant how they arrived at the tariff calculations. they could have simply drawn them out of a hat. no matter what tariffs were implemented, the same response would have occurred. Chris is correct, change is hard

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 6, 2025
Comment removed
Andy Fately's avatar

my point is that if you disagree with the tariff policy, which based on your comments seems clear, then what difference does it make how they arrived at the numbers. you would have been unhappy regardless. but since you are up here in the cheap seats with me and everybody else on the comment board, it also doesn't matter what we think. Trump was elected president on a platform and he has been following through on that platform. it's not as though tariffs came out of the blue.

in a Ricardian world, I agree that tariffs would result in a great deal of deadweight loss, but we don't live in a Ricardian world. we live in a world where 25 years ago, the US policy was that if they allowed a completely restrictive, command control economy into the world's free trading system, it would encourage China to become more democratic. well, that was a bad call, and there have been many knock on effects, the trade deficit being one of them. Trump is trying to address that via this policy. will it be worse than the previous mistake of allowing China in? I guess we'll find out.

Dogwalker2720's avatar

I’m not overly fond of Trump but I agree with your article. It’s been particularly vexing to see the pressure in rising costs, crazy market valuations that make one feel like we live in a world where pigs fly. I took a class from a Fed vice president in B school and used to think they were the objective guardians of the economy. However, through the years, I began to realize that they just didn’t want a pullback in the markets due to the pain experienced since the GFC. This has led to crazy BTFD behavior and led to nosebleed valuations. Thanks again for the article and I grudgingly am gaining respect for the courage it took to force this issue to the table via tariffs.

Phil Bak's avatar

Everyone claims they love the idea of reshoring, until it actually costs something. This is the cost.

There is no more coddled and spoiled person in the history of the world than the current US equity investor.

Mordecai Yell's avatar

I was ignorant and on autopilot until I turned 35 and read the entire “Dollar Endgame” series by Peruvian Bull. Then I read “Creature from Jekyll Island” by Edwards. Then I read both Bitcoin and Fiat Standard by Ammous. Then I started reading select works by Austrian economists like Hayek and Friedman and I realized… Modern Monetary Theory is just money magic. It financializes everything and strip mines wealth from the wage-earning class (90% of US) to the asset-owning class (10% of US). It fuels the Everything Bubble which makes us all run faster for the same piece of cheese. This phenomenon is demonstrated on the chart shared in this article. Bravo.

Not to mention these policies compromise our national security and make the US vulnerable and weak as outlined in this article. Bravo. Tariffs are exactly what will MAGA.

So I’m chuckling as the market craters and wipes out ill-gotten wealth of the top 10% of Americans who own 88% of the equities. And I’m waiting patiently to help rebuild the manufacturing base and the American Heartland which has been gutted since 1971.

Andy Parker's avatar

It has indeed been just one day. While you may not like Trump’s style, what he is doing is brave. Few other politicians, if any, would attempt it. The media largely hates Trump even though without him, their ratings would go to zero. So let’s see what plays out over the next couple of months without stupid panic. Or sell all your stocks and be quiet.

Quoth the Raven's avatar

Vietnam already ready to strike a deal. Do we honestly not think other countries won't follow suit once they start cutting deals?

User's avatar
Comment removed
Apr 6, 2025
Comment removed
Andy Parker's avatar

Actually likely will. Panic selling is rarely

Denis Cowley's avatar

WOOOOOW!!! Knocked it out of the park again. When I quit drinking, my mind got considerably clearer but I felt my creativity waned. It seems sobriety is your friend, as this article is laser-point on :)

craazyman's avatar

This market break is making Trump and Scott Bessent's jobs A LOT EASIER!

I bet they thought "What the hell do we have to do to pop this bubble??"

Now they can jawbone the Fed and get the whole yield curve down, lower rates and probably benefit from a drawdown in inflation pressures.

Then whatever budget magic they try or tarfiff-based revenue can maybe score up as a Win.

Early enough in Trump 2.0 to be able to blame it all on Biden (any presidential administration would do that), and re-rate the starting line for Trump 2.0.

Pass the popcorn. LOL!

Don C.'s avatar

This is by far the most important article you have written, and it goes hand in hand exactly with what I wrote in response to your article yesterday. (did you see it?) Good job! And good job President Trump! No more kicking the can - it's time for action.

Dewey Hildebrand's avatar

I believe it’s a head fake. Not that the tariffs aren’t real, more of a “hey,look, squirrel “. A distraction. A negotiation tool from a helluva negotiator. If the leverage applied is sufficient to make it financially feasible for manufacturers to relocate here then it’s successful. Trump is a master troll. He’s moving so fast on so many levels his detractors don’t have time to mount a defense before he’s on to three more things. In the meantime he randomly talks to the press and drops one or two items which gets the headlines off what he’s really doing and on to something else. Whether successful or not it’s certainly fun to watch. The alternative was to continue the fiscal, trade and foreign policies which was becoming Russian roulette with 4 loaded chambers.

Rienzo's avatar

Yes, one goddamn day, and the pampered are already whining all the way to the toilet, in ever increasing frequency. Thank you for the excellent mature take on some difficult medicine we as a nation will need to swallow. I may be a bit "pampered" now, but I came from the working class and Trump's Liberation Day lecture yesterday made me remember and appreciate that. The previous system was unsustainable and frankly immoral, if anyone still thinks about that. Let's just get on with saving this country.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

Incidentally - as Denis mentioned, "sobriety" is clearly doing you a lot of good. I can also speak from personal experience on that score.