Discussion about this post

User's avatar
craazyman's avatar

certainly enormous truth in this post. But I question even the basic premise of "scientific authority" in many health policy areas. The quantitative methods used to establish "Truth" originated with modeling physical systems in conditions of motion within gravitational fields (and gambling chances in games, LOL). In effect, deterministic systems with limited and obvious causal factors.

These were adopted -- along with the entire toolbox of statistical analyses, need for adequate data sets, confidence intervals and influencing factors that were believed to cause results but were themselves hypotheses. And it was used to measure Truth across human behavior.

The math is cogent for sure. But the application to wildly unstable social systems where data can be challenging, people have free will, there are potentially hundreds of seen and unmeasured causal factors and you have fairly pervasive non-determinism.

In short, you have a potential shit-show of superficial erudition with enough math to intimidate almost anybody, all papering over a messy swamp of reality.

If you're the bureaucrat you waive the paper in people's faces. Case closed and money flows.

The truthiness of all this isn't -- it seems to me -- close to what's represented. To be fair, there may be areas in healthcare-adjacent research chemistry, biology, epidemiology where these methods are better applied. And the folks applying them certainly understand the limitations.

But then the bureacracy and careerism kick in -- as this post remarks -- and the truthiness that may be tentative at best fades even farther from cogent grasp.

You're in the EXTRAORDINARY POPULAR DELUSIONS AND THE MADNESS OF CROWDS corner of human psychology. That's when things get weird, and that's where all this stuff lands.

curious_scientist's avatar

This article hits the nail on the head. Around 20 years ago, after I had gotten my graduate degree in Complex Systems with honors, I was searching for a Doctoral program so that I could go on to do something of consequence in my career.

It led me to major NYC university and its MPH program launch. The college professors who were ordained to launch the program could not stop fawning over their royal guests from the WHO and the US alphabet agencies. The other students, mostly undergrads, were like rock fans. I found the whole bureaucrat hero worship culture disturbing.

I asked only one question: If I finished my MPH degree with Research (into epidemiology) as my specialization in top if my then current MS in Systems, could I publish my research? The answer was of course, after the WHO and/or the CDC reviewed it, redacted it, and chose to clear it for publication. The reasoning was that since I would need to intern with one of those agencies, which would be a supreme honor, I would sign long term nondisclosure agreements before I walked in their doors.

I saw this censorship, especially by the WHO, which wasn't even US agency, to be a way to control and distort public health narratives. So I politely declined and moved on to something else.

My suspicions proved well founded. It's a racket.

21 more comments...

Ready for more?