certainly enormous truth in this post. But I question even the basic premise of "scientific authority" in many health policy areas. The quantitative methods used to establish "Truth" originated with modeling physical systems in conditions of motion within gravitational fields (and gambling chances in games, LOL). In effect, deterministic systems with limited and obvious causal factors.
These were adopted -- along with the entire toolbox of statistical analyses, need for adequate data sets, confidence intervals and influencing factors that were believed to cause results but were themselves hypotheses. And it was used to measure Truth across human behavior.
The math is cogent for sure. But the application to wildly unstable social systems where data can be challenging, people have free will, there are potentially hundreds of seen and unmeasured causal factors and you have fairly pervasive non-determinism.
In short, you have a potential shit-show of superficial erudition with enough math to intimidate almost anybody, all papering over a messy swamp of reality.
If you're the bureaucrat you waive the paper in people's faces. Case closed and money flows.
The truthiness of all this isn't -- it seems to me -- close to what's represented. To be fair, there may be areas in healthcare-adjacent research chemistry, biology, epidemiology where these methods are better applied. And the folks applying them certainly understand the limitations.
But then the bureacracy and careerism kick in -- as this post remarks -- and the truthiness that may be tentative at best fades even farther from cogent grasp.
You're in the EXTRAORDINARY POPULAR DELUSIONS AND THE MADNESS OF CROWDS corner of human psychology. That's when things get weird, and that's where all this stuff lands.
This article hits the nail on the head. Around 20 years ago, after I had gotten my graduate degree in Complex Systems with honors, I was searching for a Doctoral program so that I could go on to do something of consequence in my career.
It led me to major NYC university and its MPH program launch. The college professors who were ordained to launch the program could not stop fawning over their royal guests from the WHO and the US alphabet agencies. The other students, mostly undergrads, were like rock fans. I found the whole bureaucrat hero worship culture disturbing.
I asked only one question: If I finished my MPH degree with Research (into epidemiology) as my specialization in top if my then current MS in Systems, could I publish my research? The answer was of course, after the WHO and/or the CDC reviewed it, redacted it, and chose to clear it for publication. The reasoning was that since I would need to intern with one of those agencies, which would be a supreme honor, I would sign long term nondisclosure agreements before I walked in their doors.
I saw this censorship, especially by the WHO, which wasn't even US agency, to be a way to control and distort public health narratives. So I politely declined and moved on to something else.
I believe he exposed something darker. We were armed with everything we need to know about viruses in High School, in both Biology and History. The Spanish Flu remains the deadliest pandemic in history. A World War was fought during it and we learned everything about viruses (as well as sunlight being the best disinfectant). How is it possible this was allowed to happen if everyone was taught and tested on this subject?
I disagree 100%. The Spanish Flu killed young men. COVID attacked the aged & infirm. The lessons were completely different. And sunlight kills viruses? C’mon dude. You’re one step away from injecting clorox and eating ivermectin. The real and only issue is understanding what “gain of function” experiments were being conducted and who paid for them in Wuhan? The Chinese know for certain. And they ain’t talking. Fauci probably knows. And congress bullied him into not talking. So we’ve learned exactly bugger-all nothing. Except that sunlight, clorox and ivermectin don’t cure a goddamn thing.
Really...is that your argument? I've never ingested sodium cyanide to see if it kills me, but years of use as a poison has absolutely convinced me not to. As an obvious track record, much like ivermectin, doesn't convince you, feel free to to put some of your skin in the game to change my perception.
We are told that Fauci's diaries reveal a man preoccupied with his image, reputation, celebrity, relationships, and place in history. Fine. Those are legitimate things to examine. But if concern with one's public image is evidence of moral or professional corruption, how exactly does Trump escape the same scrutiny?
Trump's obsession with how he is perceived is not some minor footnote to his presidency. His public image, personal loyalty, television coverage, praise, ratings, crowd size, and historical reputation have been central to his political identity for decades. Yet the essay devotes enormous attention to Fauci's vanity while barely applying the same lens to the person who occupied the Oval Office and had vastly greater power to shape public behavior and declare the lock-downs.
That's what makes the argument feel less like an impartial examination of institutional failure and more like a prosecution of a predetermined villain.
There are plenty of legitimate questions to ask about Fauci: whether he communicated uncertainty honestly, whether institutional incentives distorted decision-making, whether dissent was treated fairly, and whether his enormous influence was appropriate. Those questions deserve serious scrutiny.
But criticism becomes less persuasive when every unfavorable characteristic in Fauci is treated as evidence of systemic corruption while comparable—or arguably far more conspicuous—behavior in Trump is simply left outside the frame.
The pandemic was not a morality play with one narcissist on one side and dispassionate truth-seekers on the other. It was a messy collision of politicians, bureaucracies, scientists, institutions, media, and personalities—all operating under extraordinary uncertainty.
If the author's larger argument is that scientific institutions should be held accountable, I'm with him. But accountability loses credibility when the standard isn't applied consistently.
And ultimately, Fauci was an unelected public-health official. Trump was the president of the United States, the Commander In Chief. If we're going to talk about the consequences of leadership, influence, ego, and image-making, we shouldn't pretend one of those men was operating in a vacuum. Trump had to personally give us rambling daily updates because he was "smarter" than anyone in his administration.
What is the connection of NIH under his watch with Big Pharma, Transnational gangsters ( Bill Gates et-al) and profiteering? After all, Dr Tony's name is on the Moederna patent. Nice royalty check. How many perished for his payday?
The medical industry, and that's what it is from family practice, to academia, to pharmaceuticals to political lobbies, is just one big circle jerk. They are ticks and parasites feeding off of each other while draining the host that is us.
During covid I was in my physicians office and told to wear a mask. I had been "friends" with the physician for over a decade. When in the exam room where I could be without mask I asked him, "Doc, you know these things are just fabric and viruses pass through them as if they aren't even there. Why are they being required?". His answer? "They don't protect anyone from a virus, but they make people feel safer." What? I have not seen the man since. I later found out that physicians offices were paid to require masking. One big circle jerk.
What is up with this fixation on Fauci. At best, it’s concern for scientific integrity, but if that’s the case, you’re completely missing the point. The risk is further reducing the credibility of institutions and making it easier to dismiss all science by saying nothing can be trusted. The criticism you’re directing has nothing to do with science itself. In every organization, individuals with questionable morals, political skill, and superficial charm tend to rise to the top. Expecting scientific institutions to be filled with people with saintly qualities is just foolish. Science, unlike organized religion, Wall Street, and politics, is the only thing with built-in self-correction. The harm science can cause when it goes wrong is marginal compared to Wall Street and political parties. There are better targets for your criticism than Anthony Fauci.
Until the scientific method reasserts itself America will be in stasis intellectually. Sad to say our competitors may be less constrained. This is creeping into all of our businesses and institutions at the same time our education system is failing to educate. Give it time and the net effect is a reduction in strength of our nation until the current status quo can no longer sustain itself and then change will come. Maybe they will try to forestall this with AI but don’t count on it. It is likely to be more of the same on steroids. If you can see all of this it is a tremendous advantage and opportunity.
Fauci was caught in a dilemma of his own making. His fame and credibility required that COVID remain a dire threat while there was always the possibility that his culpability in its creation might be revealed, taking him from hero to villain and possibly prison inmate. So the stakes were high.
When masks and vaccination became badges for obedience, representing concern for others (and avoidance of either meant you were a heartless bastard) he jumped on that bandwagon because it helped cement his role as hero. Obedience to authority folded easily into Democrat philosophy. Self-determination and independence of thought belongs naturally in the province of empathy-free Republicans. Again, Fauci took the path of least resistance since his press coverage was delivered by a mostly Democrat-aligned journalistic community. And they didn't want to be proved wrong later either so that cement hardened early.
A conspiracy of genuinely bad reporting on COVID, now acknowledged, put one more nail into the coffin of mainstream journalism. A few reporters kept their jobs for a few more months parroting the pronouncements of Tony Fauci. "Believe the science" is now a punch line. So is "believe the New York Times."
I have a rant. I think "trust the science" or "believe the science" are the most idiotic statements ever made. It is putting two ideas together that are mutually exclusive.
The science? you prove the science to me! You show me the data! You show me the test results! You show me the analysis! You show me that alternative explanations for the data are invalid!
Trust? Belief? That is incompatible with true, provable science.
I am an engineer by trade. We build products for a purpose. I don't tell our customers "trust me, I'm the professional, it will work for you" Nope. We demonstrate the product to our customers - proving that it works.
I can continue down this path and write a whole article or a book. As some other have indicated, this is all related to the "Truth".
There are things that are "true" regardless of what you believe.
There are people in this world that will argue that sentence with you. Well, they have belief. God help them.
I think the story that is unfolding today about Anthony Fauce is a clue as to how our government really operates. It's not for the good of the public who vote these people into office, but more so for the benefit of many who occupy office. The "Deep State" runs America, not those who are elected, but those who have the money and the power to direct what policies the government approves. This has never been more evident than what Anthony Fauci did over the course of his career. Which was not to make things better for those of us living in America, but to make himself wealthier, and become the center of attention. Ego, or Pride, is one of the deadly sins, and Anthony Fauci was consumed by it.
certainly enormous truth in this post. But I question even the basic premise of "scientific authority" in many health policy areas. The quantitative methods used to establish "Truth" originated with modeling physical systems in conditions of motion within gravitational fields (and gambling chances in games, LOL). In effect, deterministic systems with limited and obvious causal factors.
These were adopted -- along with the entire toolbox of statistical analyses, need for adequate data sets, confidence intervals and influencing factors that were believed to cause results but were themselves hypotheses. And it was used to measure Truth across human behavior.
The math is cogent for sure. But the application to wildly unstable social systems where data can be challenging, people have free will, there are potentially hundreds of seen and unmeasured causal factors and you have fairly pervasive non-determinism.
In short, you have a potential shit-show of superficial erudition with enough math to intimidate almost anybody, all papering over a messy swamp of reality.
If you're the bureaucrat you waive the paper in people's faces. Case closed and money flows.
The truthiness of all this isn't -- it seems to me -- close to what's represented. To be fair, there may be areas in healthcare-adjacent research chemistry, biology, epidemiology where these methods are better applied. And the folks applying them certainly understand the limitations.
But then the bureacracy and careerism kick in -- as this post remarks -- and the truthiness that may be tentative at best fades even farther from cogent grasp.
You're in the EXTRAORDINARY POPULAR DELUSIONS AND THE MADNESS OF CROWDS corner of human psychology. That's when things get weird, and that's where all this stuff lands.
This article hits the nail on the head. Around 20 years ago, after I had gotten my graduate degree in Complex Systems with honors, I was searching for a Doctoral program so that I could go on to do something of consequence in my career.
It led me to major NYC university and its MPH program launch. The college professors who were ordained to launch the program could not stop fawning over their royal guests from the WHO and the US alphabet agencies. The other students, mostly undergrads, were like rock fans. I found the whole bureaucrat hero worship culture disturbing.
I asked only one question: If I finished my MPH degree with Research (into epidemiology) as my specialization in top if my then current MS in Systems, could I publish my research? The answer was of course, after the WHO and/or the CDC reviewed it, redacted it, and chose to clear it for publication. The reasoning was that since I would need to intern with one of those agencies, which would be a supreme honor, I would sign long term nondisclosure agreements before I walked in their doors.
I saw this censorship, especially by the WHO, which wasn't even US agency, to be a way to control and distort public health narratives. So I politely declined and moved on to something else.
My suspicions proved well founded. It's a racket.
wow. reminds me of a quip I heard attributed to short seller David Einhorn about fukked up companies: "No matter how bad you think it is, it's worse."
I believe he exposed something darker. We were armed with everything we need to know about viruses in High School, in both Biology and History. The Spanish Flu remains the deadliest pandemic in history. A World War was fought during it and we learned everything about viruses (as well as sunlight being the best disinfectant). How is it possible this was allowed to happen if everyone was taught and tested on this subject?
The pcr test was never intended as a diagnostic tool per the inventor.
I disagree 100%. The Spanish Flu killed young men. COVID attacked the aged & infirm. The lessons were completely different. And sunlight kills viruses? C’mon dude. You’re one step away from injecting clorox and eating ivermectin. The real and only issue is understanding what “gain of function” experiments were being conducted and who paid for them in Wuhan? The Chinese know for certain. And they ain’t talking. Fauci probably knows. And congress bullied him into not talking. So we’ve learned exactly bugger-all nothing. Except that sunlight, clorox and ivermectin don’t cure a goddamn thing.
Ivermectin is an FDA approved prescription medication. It was proven to be effective with COVID.
Have you actually taken ivermectin? Skin in the game is more convincing than an opinion.
Really...is that your argument? I've never ingested sodium cyanide to see if it kills me, but years of use as a poison has absolutely convinced me not to. As an obvious track record, much like ivermectin, doesn't convince you, feel free to to put some of your skin in the game to change my perception.
There is good evidence that the treatment killed more people than the Spanish Flu.
This also happened right after a war where there was a high level of chemical weapons used.
We are told that Fauci's diaries reveal a man preoccupied with his image, reputation, celebrity, relationships, and place in history. Fine. Those are legitimate things to examine. But if concern with one's public image is evidence of moral or professional corruption, how exactly does Trump escape the same scrutiny?
Trump's obsession with how he is perceived is not some minor footnote to his presidency. His public image, personal loyalty, television coverage, praise, ratings, crowd size, and historical reputation have been central to his political identity for decades. Yet the essay devotes enormous attention to Fauci's vanity while barely applying the same lens to the person who occupied the Oval Office and had vastly greater power to shape public behavior and declare the lock-downs.
That's what makes the argument feel less like an impartial examination of institutional failure and more like a prosecution of a predetermined villain.
There are plenty of legitimate questions to ask about Fauci: whether he communicated uncertainty honestly, whether institutional incentives distorted decision-making, whether dissent was treated fairly, and whether his enormous influence was appropriate. Those questions deserve serious scrutiny.
But criticism becomes less persuasive when every unfavorable characteristic in Fauci is treated as evidence of systemic corruption while comparable—or arguably far more conspicuous—behavior in Trump is simply left outside the frame.
The pandemic was not a morality play with one narcissist on one side and dispassionate truth-seekers on the other. It was a messy collision of politicians, bureaucracies, scientists, institutions, media, and personalities—all operating under extraordinary uncertainty.
If the author's larger argument is that scientific institutions should be held accountable, I'm with him. But accountability loses credibility when the standard isn't applied consistently.
And ultimately, Fauci was an unelected public-health official. Trump was the president of the United States, the Commander In Chief. If we're going to talk about the consequences of leadership, influence, ego, and image-making, we shouldn't pretend one of those men was operating in a vacuum. Trump had to personally give us rambling daily updates because he was "smarter" than anyone in his administration.
Thanks for your post that gives a healthy perspective.
America became sicker under Dr Tony's watch.
What is the connection of NIH under his watch with Big Pharma, Transnational gangsters ( Bill Gates et-al) and profiteering? After all, Dr Tony's name is on the Moederna patent. Nice royalty check. How many perished for his payday?
I'd like to see those dots connected.
The medical industry, and that's what it is from family practice, to academia, to pharmaceuticals to political lobbies, is just one big circle jerk. They are ticks and parasites feeding off of each other while draining the host that is us.
During covid I was in my physicians office and told to wear a mask. I had been "friends" with the physician for over a decade. When in the exam room where I could be without mask I asked him, "Doc, you know these things are just fabric and viruses pass through them as if they aren't even there. Why are they being required?". His answer? "They don't protect anyone from a virus, but they make people feel safer." What? I have not seen the man since. I later found out that physicians offices were paid to require masking. One big circle jerk.
What is up with this fixation on Fauci. At best, it’s concern for scientific integrity, but if that’s the case, you’re completely missing the point. The risk is further reducing the credibility of institutions and making it easier to dismiss all science by saying nothing can be trusted. The criticism you’re directing has nothing to do with science itself. In every organization, individuals with questionable morals, political skill, and superficial charm tend to rise to the top. Expecting scientific institutions to be filled with people with saintly qualities is just foolish. Science, unlike organized religion, Wall Street, and politics, is the only thing with built-in self-correction. The harm science can cause when it goes wrong is marginal compared to Wall Street and political parties. There are better targets for your criticism than Anthony Fauci.
Until the scientific method reasserts itself America will be in stasis intellectually. Sad to say our competitors may be less constrained. This is creeping into all of our businesses and institutions at the same time our education system is failing to educate. Give it time and the net effect is a reduction in strength of our nation until the current status quo can no longer sustain itself and then change will come. Maybe they will try to forestall this with AI but don’t count on it. It is likely to be more of the same on steroids. If you can see all of this it is a tremendous advantage and opportunity.
Fauci was caught in a dilemma of his own making. His fame and credibility required that COVID remain a dire threat while there was always the possibility that his culpability in its creation might be revealed, taking him from hero to villain and possibly prison inmate. So the stakes were high.
When masks and vaccination became badges for obedience, representing concern for others (and avoidance of either meant you were a heartless bastard) he jumped on that bandwagon because it helped cement his role as hero. Obedience to authority folded easily into Democrat philosophy. Self-determination and independence of thought belongs naturally in the province of empathy-free Republicans. Again, Fauci took the path of least resistance since his press coverage was delivered by a mostly Democrat-aligned journalistic community. And they didn't want to be proved wrong later either so that cement hardened early.
A conspiracy of genuinely bad reporting on COVID, now acknowledged, put one more nail into the coffin of mainstream journalism. A few reporters kept their jobs for a few more months parroting the pronouncements of Tony Fauci. "Believe the science" is now a punch line. So is "believe the New York Times."
I have a rant. I think "trust the science" or "believe the science" are the most idiotic statements ever made. It is putting two ideas together that are mutually exclusive.
The science? you prove the science to me! You show me the data! You show me the test results! You show me the analysis! You show me that alternative explanations for the data are invalid!
Trust? Belief? That is incompatible with true, provable science.
I am an engineer by trade. We build products for a purpose. I don't tell our customers "trust me, I'm the professional, it will work for you" Nope. We demonstrate the product to our customers - proving that it works.
I can continue down this path and write a whole article or a book. As some other have indicated, this is all related to the "Truth".
There are things that are "true" regardless of what you believe.
There are people in this world that will argue that sentence with you. Well, they have belief. God help them.
I think the story that is unfolding today about Anthony Fauce is a clue as to how our government really operates. It's not for the good of the public who vote these people into office, but more so for the benefit of many who occupy office. The "Deep State" runs America, not those who are elected, but those who have the money and the power to direct what policies the government approves. This has never been more evident than what Anthony Fauci did over the course of his career. Which was not to make things better for those of us living in America, but to make himself wealthier, and become the center of attention. Ego, or Pride, is one of the deadly sins, and Anthony Fauci was consumed by it.
It's not only the "biomedical establishment". It's every scientific "establishment" connected to the fedgov by the great money spigot!
Screw the silly science and the sillier authority.