Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Brown's avatar

I'm surprised at the negative reactions below. Shostak is thinking in fundamental principles. He is trying to keep it simple, but that is not the same as hokey. He takes for granted that his readers understand money is not wealth. In an advanced economy (based on a division of labor), there can be no production unless there is some spare real wealth ("pool of real savings") to sustain the creator while he builds new tools or takes on other new productive projects. This is why Krugman (and Keynes) are so wrong when they say you can "stimulate" new wealth by simply printing money and throwing it somewhere. Mostly, you will transfer wealth from one person to another, destroying some wealth in the process. I wonder if the detractors understand what Shostak is saying. You may be missing his critical points if you haven't read Mises.

Michael Herring's avatar

Krugman is essentially a political weathervane.

11 more comments...

Ready for more?