13 Comments
User's avatar
Jim Brown's avatar

I'm surprised at the negative reactions below. Shostak is thinking in fundamental principles. He is trying to keep it simple, but that is not the same as hokey. He takes for granted that his readers understand money is not wealth. In an advanced economy (based on a division of labor), there can be no production unless there is some spare real wealth ("pool of real savings") to sustain the creator while he builds new tools or takes on other new productive projects. This is why Krugman (and Keynes) are so wrong when they say you can "stimulate" new wealth by simply printing money and throwing it somewhere. Mostly, you will transfer wealth from one person to another, destroying some wealth in the process. I wonder if the detractors understand what Shostak is saying. You may be missing his critical points if you haven't read Mises.

craazyman's avatar

Money is just a symbol and it isn’t wealth, to be sure. No disagreement.

But “savings” are simply forms of money, therefore it is also a symbol which is just a composite of money symbols.

It’s all symbols — money and savings are two forms of the same symbol. But symbol of what? Well, at the most abstract level it’s symbols of claims to participate in social cooperational structures, the broad cultural capital that supports life needs through all the things we call an economy. If the private sector fails, as it has throughout history, the public sector steps in. Of course, it also fails. And so the private sector bails it out., They both fail, often in a pendulum-type cycle where each is a reaction against the failure of the other.

The government, if and when it spends, is not restricted by “savings” since it controls creation of money. One symbol doesn’t restrict the other. If government spends well and wisely, it can create cultural capital where none existed and support the cultural capital that we’d call wealth. If poorly, to be sure it can destroy cultural capital and wealth.

The abstractions that money represents aren’t simple, in my view. They are very complex cultural forces that go well beyond “savings”. Cultural capital and wealth at the macro aggregate level are very high-dimensional ideas and money as a store of value, medium of exchange, unit of account and container of savings is only one dimension.

It’s the reductive Manichean dichotomy between useless Government and the amazing genius of private free enterprise that rankles some of us, in my view.

Michael Herring's avatar

Krugman is essentially a political weathervane.

Mark S Griffith's avatar

For Lefty economists like Krugman, their economic policies are driven not by the observation of human behavior or evidence or facts but instead by ideology. For the Lefty, centralize power in the hands of a few elites is their ultimate dream. So, this is why they espouse such idiotic nonsense that flies in the face of reality. They form their economic theories to fit their political dreams or ideology.

For free market economists, liberty, both economic and political, is the ultimate goal. Therefore, they observe human behavior when folks are left alone to act in a market, and form their theories (and laws, like the law of scarcity and others like it) based on those observations.

And since Leftism is really Communism, and therefore a religious devotion more than a political ideology, their "faith" in Communism drives all their thinking, if you can call what they do, "thinking". Because at its core, Leftism/Communism is simply a constant battle with God's design or His order, which is another way of saying, the Left is constantly in battle with REALITY!!! And THAT my friends, is why all Leftists are dour, unhappy folks with no sense of humor. They are constantly running into the brick wall that is reality.

Tankster's avatar

How quaint. What’s the deficit? Trillions? That is a lot of tomatoes, potatoes, and baguettes.

svboy's avatar

"Money per se is therefore unproductive; it is dead stock and produces nothing.” dont tell that to the top 1% who hold 30% of the countries wealth AND the top 10% who hold 66% of the countries wealth leaving the bottom 90% with less than 35% of the wealth most of which is "live" stock that is very "productive".

He is also misrepresenting Keynes/krugman with the example of ditches and equally negative theories/examples can be made about the extreme wealth accumulation, which the start of the article talks about.

The question I have and which was not answered here is : "Government schemes that are aimed at artificially boosting employment", what exactly is this? I have not seen it in the US. Is he talking about the Armed Forces? .... The problem is that the government schemes are to a) give tax breaks to the people with the most money so they can "invest" it, b) build a huge defense force so we can support our allies and weaken our adversaries and c) support the weak, old so that they dont suffer...

Dan Star's avatar

Well government funneling money to unemployed does result in some increase in demand. However, this is borrowed wealth that is never repaid. So yes net loss.

Daniel Jones's avatar

Egyptians built pyramids. Europeans built cathedrals. The object is to keep people occupied, and therefore controlled by the Avaricious Class.

RU's avatar

These economics articles are so poorly written and stylistically outdated and hokey - trading bread for potatoes...really? - they are never helpful to anyone and end up hurting the author's cause. Normal people start reading, get to the hokey parts, and think "this guy is an idiot." That pushes them to the other side every time. The delivery is more important than the content when it comes to persuading people.

Laramie's avatar

I tend to agree, these are poorly written. Example: "Since government does not produce real wealth, it cannot save and therefore cannot fund wealth-creating activity."

Really? What if the government crafted regulations that resulted in a deep and liquid bond market, both efficient and the envy of the world in terms of liquidity? I'm not saying the private market plays no role in this, but certainly government regulation also could be said to play a role.

Then, what if the currency issued by that government became ultra-desirable -- not just to citizens but to non-citizens alike -- such that non-citizens tended to price their business transactions in the currency of this foreign government? The increase in demand (from external sources) for the government's currency consequently rises. As a consequence, the citizens of this nation can now buy more (foreign) goods and services with their currency units than they might otherwise have been able to buy had the currency itself not been so attractive.

Has the government played no role in wealth-creating activity? If one admits that well-crafted regulations might make a currency more attractive -- thus increasing the wealth of those who hold its currency -- then must one not admit that government "can[] fund wealth-creating activity."

It's a simple argument. I make no claim that our regulations are well-crafted, that government is good at anything, that government is necessary, or that the private sector can't always do better.

I simply assert that many of the arguments in this type of article appear wrong on their face.

craazyman's avatar

This post is complete nonsense.

The govermint like the private sector can do some things well and some things badly.

Well: NASA, interstate highways, many police forces, libraries, some schools, some state universities, etc.

Badly: bailouts of rich bankers, Pork barrel projects, MIC

Private enterprise also does things well and badly.

Govermint spending is 36% of GDP, according to wikipedia/BEA. That gets spent on private sector businesses. Some are probably good, some not.

A thoughtful person focuses on the good and the bad, not the "govermint" or "Private sector." Where are these divisions? They are no so clear with money flowing all around like whirlpools.

Private enterprise failures are legion. That's why mankind created govermint in the first place.

Steve S's avatar

Seldom do I agree with Paul Krugman, but need to take exception to the notion that the government lowering unemployment by employing ditch diggers somehow is a negative vis a vis cost to society. I see it as a benefit, not only to the unemployed who now will have earned funds with which to purchase goods and services, but to society in other remote ways. The writer mentions "unneeded" ditches, which I take is the writer's notion that if the ditches were needed then a private entity would pay for it. This is naive. Sometimes a ditch is needed but there is little to no profit in a private company paying for it. As for employing the unemployed, several benefits to society is engaging the unemployed in non criminal endeavors. Prolonged unemployed leads to those folk possibly engaging in criminal conduct, alcoholism, domestic violence, and other activities detrimental and a cost to society.

Marco's avatar

Sure they are.. And more and more. Sometimes I wish to find a way to understand which part of the God gdp is real and which fantasy.. I bet on 35 % and no more..