Discussion about this post

User's avatar
NJ Transit Commuter's avatar

I am Gen X. Don’t make a habit of bashing Baby Boomers, but in this case it is warranted. You can see the trend in my family:

- Silent Generation grandparents: Bought decent suburban houses on one blue collar income

- Baby Boomer parents: Bought a huge McMansion mid-life on two decent incomes. 80% of the rooms are never used.

- Me: Bought a house smaller than my grandparents’ home (in a nicer suburb) on one income, white collar work.

- Kids (Gen Z): STEM degrees and will struggle to buy a house unless they get help from me and my parents.

When I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, farm land all around me was being turned into massive housing developments for Boomers to buy, property taxes were a fraction of what they are now and income tax policies were very house friendly (unlimited property tax and interest deduction.)

As soon as the Boomers got their McMansions, the drawbridge went up: strict zoning and permitting to stop new house construction, skyrocketing property taxes, caps on property tax deduction, etc.

Laramie's avatar

I agree with this guy that housing ideas like portable mortgages, 50-year mortgages, etc., are just gimmicks. But, he's a fool if he really believes this: "From a simple numerical perspective, the idea of growing one’s wealth through home price appreciation is absurd."

He may disagree with the gimmick of allowing a $500,000 step-up in basis with each sale, but that's what the tax code says. If you sell each time your home approaches $500,000 in appreciation (married exemption), you can ride home ownership up from a $500,000 starter house to one worth many millions, capital gains tax free. This, in my opinion, makes owning a home as one's primary residence the single best investment one can make. Treat the interest you pay on your mortgage as rent and the principal as simply paying yourself. There's no guarantee that the housing market will always rise or that anyone's individual property will appreciate, but that's the way the smart money bets.

His point about always needing another house of roughly the same value also doesn't hold water. Kids leave the nest and people downsize. Folks like me get the hell out of California and move to jurisdictions that cost a fraction of inflated West Coast realty (and with 0 state income tax). You just have to play the hand the government deals you.

24 more comments...

Ready for more?