By Artis Shepherd, Mises Institute
It seems the housing market is destined to be the target of yet another administration’s clumsy tinkering. In another quiet-part-out-loud incident at the White House recently, the president was asked whether he would declare a national emergency in order to act on housing affordability. Trump responded that he doesn’t want house prices to go down because home valuations are such a large part of the “net worth” of homeowners, especially those in “their later years.”
The exchange is worth watching. Note the collectivist premises underlying both the reporter’s question and the president’s answer. Note also the content of that answer, which admits to a public policy of higher housing prices for existing homeowners despite the contradictory wish of affordability for everyone else. Trump followed several days later with more economic nonsense:
[I want to] protect the people that, for the first time in their lives, feel good about themselves. They feel like, you know, that they’re wealthy people.
Existing housing, people that own their homes, we’re going to keep them wealthy. We’re going to keep those prices up. We’re not going to destroy the value of their homes so that somebody who didn’t work very hard can buy a home.
These observations comport with many of the ideas being offered recently by the current administration to supposedly address housing affordability. But what precisely are these ideas addressing? The answer is that they are simply a continuation of the socialist schemes trotted out by prior administrations, none of which are remotely about returning housing to a free-market context and, by extension, none of which have a hope in hell of alleviating the affordability issue.
$200 Billion MBS Purchases and Other Dumb Ideas
The latest housing market caper—no doubt whispered into Donald’s ear by the intellectually bereft Bill Pulte—is to have Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac buy $200 billion worth of mortgage-backed securities (“MBS”), thus injecting liquidity into the mortgage market and driving rates down. It’s hard to imagine this proposal coming from anyone with a working understanding of capital markets.
For starters, Fannie and Freddie don’t have $200 billion in cash. The liquidity needed to purchase the MBS would have to come from further money printing and/or increased indebtedness on the part of the federal government and its agencies. These are inflationary measures.
Also, buying MBS is a technical process the logistics of which the current administration apparently fails to grasp. To wit, Fannie and Freddie are required to hedge any MBS purchases retained on their balance sheet. Thus, buying MBS is likely to be hedged by shorting treasuries. While this doesn’t mean the intended effect on mortgage rates disappears, it does mean that the impact of the corresponding hedge is displaced into other parts of the financial system.
In this particular case, MBS and mortgage spreads would decrease while treasury yields increase. The country would accelerate its debt service death spiral in order to decrease mortgage rates by—maybe—a couple dozen basis points and drive up home prices even further than today’s already pathological valuations.
Another stroke of policy brilliance is to allow the release of 401k balances without penalty to make down payments on homes. While people’s money should be their own and the premise of a penalty for using your money as you see fit is absurd, this specific targeting of home purchases will have the effect of depleting the meager savings of the young working class while pushing them towards housing that is too expensive.
Mortgage portability is another idea recently coughed up by the aforementioned Bill Pulte. Imposed by the federal government in lieu of a direct lender-borrower agreement, it would allow existing mortgages to be transferred to new home purchases. In the lending community, this is pure nonsense. The concept of changing the nature of a loan’s security on a whim would never fly, and this is precisely why asset-backed loan portability is largely non-existent in capital markets today.
A few weeks ago, the 50-year mortgage idea was trotted out by the aging president and Pulte. Alongside the announcement, the following image was posted:
Intended as a favorable comparison, Trump misses the gist entirely. Few presidents have done greater or more lasting harm to the American people than Franklin Roosevelt, and fewer still have done so with such naked moral corruption. Only Woodrow Wilson, Lyndon Johnson, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, and possibly Trump himself rival FDR in the destructive effects of their legacies.
The 50-year mortgage has now been withdrawn, after being roundly ridiculed as the unserious gimmick that it is.
The Fallacy
All of the aforementioned bad ideas rest on a flawed assumption—that housing is a financial investment. It isn’t, and never was. Housing is an asset that is essentially a consumption good. It is consumed each day by living in the house and all that entails. The community within which the home exists—and close relationships have been formed—can’t lightly be swapped out for another.
Further, significant expense is incurred in maintenance, property taxes, insurance, and capital expenditures that forestall physical depreciation.
From a simple numerical perspective, the idea of growing one’s wealth through home price appreciation is absurd. To access such increases, one must sell the home and simultaneously buy another. But, all else equal, the price of the home being acquired has also gone up to the same degree, so there is no net benefit. There is in fact a net negative in the form of transaction costs—commissions, moving, and other related expenses.
Taking home equity loans is even worse. Accessing liquidity from home equity in this manner does absolutely nothing to increase homeownership wealth. Once the home equity facility is drawn, the owner becomes a borrower. Any cash he has borrowed is offset by the corresponding loan liability. That loan immediately begins accruing interest—usually at a high rate—further undercutting any supposed financial benefit.
There is one notable instance where home equity can be used to achieve financial ends deemed desirable by the owner. That is a downsizing of the variety undertaken by seniors, often shortly after their children have grown up and moved out. And therein lies the rub. When housing is viewed as an investment by a cohort of politically-vociferous Americans, a policy of monetary debasement and asset inflation by the administration will follow in order to appease that cohort. The president admitted as much in the White House.
Who pays the price? Everyone else.

QTR’s Disclaimer: Please read my full legal disclaimer on my About page here. This post represents my opinions only. In addition, please understand I am an idiot and often get things wrong and lose money. I may own or transact in any names mentioned in this piece at any time without warning. Contributor posts and aggregated posts have been hand selected by me, have not been fact checked and are the opinions of their authors. They are either submitted to QTR by their author, reprinted under a Creative Commons license with my best effort to uphold what the license asks, or with the permission of the author.
This is not a recommendation to buy or sell any stocks or securities, just my opinions. I often lose money on positions I trade/invest in. I may add any name mentioned in this article and sell any name mentioned in this piece at any time, without further warning. None of this is a solicitation to buy or sell securities. I may or may not own names I write about and are watching. Sometimes I’m bullish without owning things, sometimes I’m bearish and do own things. Just assume my positions could be exactly the opposite of what you think they are just in case. If I’m long I could quickly be short and vice versa. I won’t update my positions. All positions can change immediately as soon as I publish this, with or without notice and at any point I can be long, short or neutral on any position. You are on your own. Do not make decisions based on my blog. I exist on the fringe. If you see numbers and calculations of any sort, assume they are wrong and double check them. I failed Algebra in 8th grade and topped off my high school math accolades by getting a D- in remedial Calculus my senior year, before becoming an English major in college so I could bullshit my way through things easier. I am an investor in Mark’s fund.
The publisher does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information provided in this page. These are not the opinions of any of my employers, partners, or associates. I did my best to be honest about my disclosures but can’t guarantee I am right; I write these posts after a couple beers sometimes. I edit after my posts are published because I’m impatient and lazy, so if you see a typo, check back in a half hour. Also, I just straight up get shit wrong a lot. I mention it twice because it’s that important.



I am Gen X. Don’t make a habit of bashing Baby Boomers, but in this case it is warranted. You can see the trend in my family:
- Silent Generation grandparents: Bought decent suburban houses on one blue collar income
- Baby Boomer parents: Bought a huge McMansion mid-life on two decent incomes. 80% of the rooms are never used.
- Me: Bought a house smaller than my grandparents’ home (in a nicer suburb) on one income, white collar work.
- Kids (Gen Z): STEM degrees and will struggle to buy a house unless they get help from me and my parents.
When I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, farm land all around me was being turned into massive housing developments for Boomers to buy, property taxes were a fraction of what they are now and income tax policies were very house friendly (unlimited property tax and interest deduction.)
As soon as the Boomers got their McMansions, the drawbridge went up: strict zoning and permitting to stop new house construction, skyrocketing property taxes, caps on property tax deduction, etc.
I agree with this guy that housing ideas like portable mortgages, 50-year mortgages, etc., are just gimmicks. But, he's a fool if he really believes this: "From a simple numerical perspective, the idea of growing one’s wealth through home price appreciation is absurd."
He may disagree with the gimmick of allowing a $500,000 step-up in basis with each sale, but that's what the tax code says. If you sell each time your home approaches $500,000 in appreciation (married exemption), you can ride home ownership up from a $500,000 starter house to one worth many millions, capital gains tax free. This, in my opinion, makes owning a home as one's primary residence the single best investment one can make. Treat the interest you pay on your mortgage as rent and the principal as simply paying yourself. There's no guarantee that the housing market will always rise or that anyone's individual property will appreciate, but that's the way the smart money bets.
His point about always needing another house of roughly the same value also doesn't hold water. Kids leave the nest and people downsize. Folks like me get the hell out of California and move to jurisdictions that cost a fraction of inflated West Coast realty (and with 0 state income tax). You just have to play the hand the government deals you.