I am Gen X. Don’t make a habit of bashing Baby Boomers, but in this case it is warranted. You can see the trend in my family:
- Silent Generation grandparents: Bought decent suburban houses on one blue collar income
- Baby Boomer parents: Bought a huge McMansion mid-life on two decent incomes. 80% of the rooms are never used.
- Me: Bought a house smaller than my grandparents’ home (in a nicer suburb) on one income, white collar work.
- Kids (Gen Z): STEM degrees and will struggle to buy a house unless they get help from me and my parents.
When I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, farm land all around me was being turned into massive housing developments for Boomers to buy, property taxes were a fraction of what they are now and income tax policies were very house friendly (unlimited property tax and interest deduction.)
As soon as the Boomers got their McMansions, the drawbridge went up: strict zoning and permitting to stop new house construction, skyrocketing property taxes, caps on property tax deduction, etc.
I agree with this guy that housing ideas like portable mortgages, 50-year mortgages, etc., are just gimmicks. But, he's a fool if he really believes this: "From a simple numerical perspective, the idea of growing one’s wealth through home price appreciation is absurd."
He may disagree with the gimmick of allowing a $500,000 step-up in basis with each sale, but that's what the tax code says. If you sell each time your home approaches $500,000 in appreciation (married exemption), you can ride home ownership up from a $500,000 starter house to one worth many millions, capital gains tax free. This, in my opinion, makes owning a home as one's primary residence the single best investment one can make. Treat the interest you pay on your mortgage as rent and the principal as simply paying yourself. There's no guarantee that the housing market will always rise or that anyone's individual property will appreciate, but that's the way the smart money bets.
His point about always needing another house of roughly the same value also doesn't hold water. Kids leave the nest and people downsize. Folks like me get the hell out of California and move to jurisdictions that cost a fraction of inflated West Coast realty (and with 0 state income tax). You just have to play the hand the government deals you.
Great piece. Homeownership used to be a good “investment” like Bitcoin is a good investment now … because you could borrow at tax-deductible interest rates and if you were early enough in the wave of household formations that were behind you you would enjoy a leveraged return on your equity.
Now interest is largely not tax deductible, prices are high, and the demographics are unfavorable. It is an expensive alternative to renting … not one without benefits, but don’t pretend it’s an investment.
From a Boomer with significant investments in non-income-producing residential real estate.
I fully expect to eventually sell my primary and secondary residence at a loss …
They had to inflate the price of your house to eliminate them saying they raised your taxes. I had some bimbo last town election tell me they hadn't raised taxes in over a decade while my property taxes have quintupled thanks to yearly re-assessments in the interim.
"Affordability" has become the media's, and now the political class's, new favorite term. It is subjective enough that it can be employed on both sides of disagreement without the need of any clear numbers to back up either side's policy. The ever increasing debasement of the dollar, through excessive money printing (largely brought about by excessive Federal debt, ushered upward by spineless, corrupt politicians) is the real culprit for the "feeling" and there is no amount window dressing policy proposals that will fix it.
The last administration (coupled with bad Fed policies) made a total mess of housing, and now this administration is expected to fix it. Trump should have said “We’ll do our best, but unwinding the mess of the Biden years is quite difficult” and left it at that.
I think you're forgetting the mess the last administration inherited from Trump 1.0. The worst of the policies, fiscal and monetary, began then (of course we could look back much farther, but this is the post-GFC moment where housing went stoopid). The Biden foolishness was an extension of that.
Trump would be best served by explaining the conundrum, and the limits of the federal government to help. It might not be a popular message, but at least it would be honest and informative for those who never really considered the economics of the problem.
This is a giant topic in and of itself. I'd like to see all the PPP "loans" made retroactively taxable at a very high rate. That would sure plump up the .gov coffers and narrow the deficit for a year.
Interesting piece. What is going on in the housing market is almost a mirror image of the inflation loop Americans are stuck in.
Too many times DC & Wall Street have colluded to soak the poor for the benefit of the rich and powerful.
Starting in the 90s Americans have absorbed the consequences of ignorant self-serving DC policies that Wall Street was very happy to "help" implement.
Free money post 9/11 + Mortgages for anybody in the 90s have created this BEAST. Post GFC the situation was never allowed to heal and losses to be realized by the responsible parties.
Blame Trump or Powell or both, but the facts are it's what they inherited.
Decades and decades of DC Regulatory fuck ups (remember the S&L crisis?) and Wall Street bribing their way out, at the middle classes expense is how we got here.
Its fun to bash Trump and his unorthodox admin. but they aren't the ones that built this quagmire.
This stopped me in my tracks - Trump: "...doesn’t want house prices to go down because home valuations are such a large part of the “net worth” of homeowners, especially those in “their later years.” Valuation. Not "Value". Kinda like paper silver.
Trump should be forced, Clockwork Orange style, to watch 72 hours of Milton Friedman and Thomas Sowell videos, with a smattering of Ayn Rand - because I'm that livid!
I have one little observation. We have to live someplace. If it comes down to paying rent or home ownership, there is a very strong case for home ownership. At possibly no additional cost over renting, a home owner can build equity at no net cost.
I, like many people, spent my earlier years rehabbing my residence. I spent my Saturdays adding perhaps a couple of hundred dollars to the value of my home, while others spent a hundred dollars playing golf. Not for everyone, but I'd rather work on the house than play golf.
None of this is meant to refute anything in the article, but home ownership is a unique form of investment. It can't easily be equated with the routine investing in various markets.
And that increased equity sits invisible on your bottom line, tax-free until you sell. With a little luck the tax assessor don't doesn't know how much more your house is worth.
Homeownership was never an investment! Exactly as stated - it's a "consumption good" (as in "goods and services"). The only financial benefit is that ones builds "forced equity" as one pays off a mortgage - but in order to access that equity you either have to sell, or borrow against it.
> All of the aforementioned bad ideas rest on a flawed assumption—that housing is a financial investment. It isn’t, and never was.
I don't entirely agree with this. Buying a house (for personal use) may not result in the ownership of a productive asset, but buying a house (whether via a mortgage or cash) is effectively locking in the price of your housing over the course of your stay. The return on the money you "invested" on your housing seems effectively offset by inflation, but your cost of housing over that time was roughly constant (not actually due to increasing property taxes).
Treating housing as a wealth building vehicle from that sense is a losing proposition. But if the cost of renting increases faster than the increase in property taxes owed (which based on market forces it should), you are freeing capital you would otherwise spend on housing for actual investment.
On the flip side, if house prices decline or fail to keep up with inflation, you are actually tying up capital that could otherwise be invested productively. My criticism of the way people treat home ownership as an investment vehicle has less to do with whether it should be considered a financial investment, and way more to do with the expectations and dimwitted evaluation of that investment. Most people do not consider home ownership a risky asset, because home prices "always goes up" in the long run, but they rarely compare that return to performance of other assets (especially the dollar) over the same time.
We have never viewed our homes as an investment. Rather we have used the equity on sales to purchase our next home instead of renting. Because of my job we had to move five times. Each time we applied the growing equity amount to our next purchase. We could have avoided the expenses of homeownership by renting, but we would never have accumulated the wealth we did from our homes. We started with a relatively small house in a marginal area of Atlanta in the ‘70s with a 12.5% mortgage and proceeded from there.
If the Feds would stop trying to manipulate the housing market to please one demographic over another, the market would take care of itself.
The problem is not that the dollar denominated price of a new home has risen by 400%, it is that the dollar has lost 90% of its value in the last 40 years. If personal income, AFTER TAXES, had risen by 900% to counteract the loss of value of the dollar, the average Joe would not have any problem whatsoever buying a new home.
The problem is, has been, and will continue to be, big government. Can you name a single politican, elected or running for election, who is promoting cutting the size of government by 25%? Proliferation of government spending has caused the problem. Proliferation of spending is what gets politicians elected. Sooooo, is not the REAL PROBLEM the people who elect these politicians?
There is one proposed program (not sure if it was enacted) to prohibit the purchase of single family homes by investment companies, to try to keep them from bidding up the prices and keep the market a "retail market."
What are your thoughts on that proposal and do you know if it was enacted?
I am Gen X. Don’t make a habit of bashing Baby Boomers, but in this case it is warranted. You can see the trend in my family:
- Silent Generation grandparents: Bought decent suburban houses on one blue collar income
- Baby Boomer parents: Bought a huge McMansion mid-life on two decent incomes. 80% of the rooms are never used.
- Me: Bought a house smaller than my grandparents’ home (in a nicer suburb) on one income, white collar work.
- Kids (Gen Z): STEM degrees and will struggle to buy a house unless they get help from me and my parents.
When I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, farm land all around me was being turned into massive housing developments for Boomers to buy, property taxes were a fraction of what they are now and income tax policies were very house friendly (unlimited property tax and interest deduction.)
As soon as the Boomers got their McMansions, the drawbridge went up: strict zoning and permitting to stop new house construction, skyrocketing property taxes, caps on property tax deduction, etc.
40 million illegal immigrants the past two decades have needed someplace to stay. The plantation masters have made a killing.
I agree with this guy that housing ideas like portable mortgages, 50-year mortgages, etc., are just gimmicks. But, he's a fool if he really believes this: "From a simple numerical perspective, the idea of growing one’s wealth through home price appreciation is absurd."
He may disagree with the gimmick of allowing a $500,000 step-up in basis with each sale, but that's what the tax code says. If you sell each time your home approaches $500,000 in appreciation (married exemption), you can ride home ownership up from a $500,000 starter house to one worth many millions, capital gains tax free. This, in my opinion, makes owning a home as one's primary residence the single best investment one can make. Treat the interest you pay on your mortgage as rent and the principal as simply paying yourself. There's no guarantee that the housing market will always rise or that anyone's individual property will appreciate, but that's the way the smart money bets.
His point about always needing another house of roughly the same value also doesn't hold water. Kids leave the nest and people downsize. Folks like me get the hell out of California and move to jurisdictions that cost a fraction of inflated West Coast realty (and with 0 state income tax). You just have to play the hand the government deals you.
Great piece. Homeownership used to be a good “investment” like Bitcoin is a good investment now … because you could borrow at tax-deductible interest rates and if you were early enough in the wave of household formations that were behind you you would enjoy a leveraged return on your equity.
Now interest is largely not tax deductible, prices are high, and the demographics are unfavorable. It is an expensive alternative to renting … not one without benefits, but don’t pretend it’s an investment.
From a Boomer with significant investments in non-income-producing residential real estate.
I fully expect to eventually sell my primary and secondary residence at a loss …
They had to inflate the price of your house to eliminate them saying they raised your taxes. I had some bimbo last town election tell me they hadn't raised taxes in over a decade while my property taxes have quintupled thanks to yearly re-assessments in the interim.
"Affordability" has become the media's, and now the political class's, new favorite term. It is subjective enough that it can be employed on both sides of disagreement without the need of any clear numbers to back up either side's policy. The ever increasing debasement of the dollar, through excessive money printing (largely brought about by excessive Federal debt, ushered upward by spineless, corrupt politicians) is the real culprit for the "feeling" and there is no amount window dressing policy proposals that will fix it.
The last administration (coupled with bad Fed policies) made a total mess of housing, and now this administration is expected to fix it. Trump should have said “We’ll do our best, but unwinding the mess of the Biden years is quite difficult” and left it at that.
Trump just wants to get past the Midterms without any financial crashes. He is kicking the can into 2027.
I’d be surprised if there’s no crash b4 mid-terms.
They all do that since its become such a huge mess.
Partisan politics supercede the common good for decades.
I think you're forgetting the mess the last administration inherited from Trump 1.0. The worst of the policies, fiscal and monetary, began then (of course we could look back much farther, but this is the post-GFC moment where housing went stoopid). The Biden foolishness was an extension of that.
Trump would be best served by explaining the conundrum, and the limits of the federal government to help. It might not be a popular message, but at least it would be honest and informative for those who never really considered the economics of the problem.
Political animals always feel the need to “do something “. I’m deeply saddened no one will be prosecuted for the Covid saga
This is a giant topic in and of itself. I'd like to see all the PPP "loans" made retroactively taxable at a very high rate. That would sure plump up the .gov coffers and narrow the deficit for a year.
Wait your turn, I’m still deeply saddened no one will be prosecuted for the GFC
Interesting piece. What is going on in the housing market is almost a mirror image of the inflation loop Americans are stuck in.
Too many times DC & Wall Street have colluded to soak the poor for the benefit of the rich and powerful.
Starting in the 90s Americans have absorbed the consequences of ignorant self-serving DC policies that Wall Street was very happy to "help" implement.
Free money post 9/11 + Mortgages for anybody in the 90s have created this BEAST. Post GFC the situation was never allowed to heal and losses to be realized by the responsible parties.
Blame Trump or Powell or both, but the facts are it's what they inherited.
Decades and decades of DC Regulatory fuck ups (remember the S&L crisis?) and Wall Street bribing their way out, at the middle classes expense is how we got here.
Its fun to bash Trump and his unorthodox admin. but they aren't the ones that built this quagmire.
Fanny and Freddie shouldn't still be there. In the 2008 collapse people talked of eliminating them. But, surprise,they're still there.
This stopped me in my tracks - Trump: "...doesn’t want house prices to go down because home valuations are such a large part of the “net worth” of homeowners, especially those in “their later years.” Valuation. Not "Value". Kinda like paper silver.
Trump should be forced, Clockwork Orange style, to watch 72 hours of Milton Friedman and Thomas Sowell videos, with a smattering of Ayn Rand - because I'm that livid!
I have one little observation. We have to live someplace. If it comes down to paying rent or home ownership, there is a very strong case for home ownership. At possibly no additional cost over renting, a home owner can build equity at no net cost.
I, like many people, spent my earlier years rehabbing my residence. I spent my Saturdays adding perhaps a couple of hundred dollars to the value of my home, while others spent a hundred dollars playing golf. Not for everyone, but I'd rather work on the house than play golf.
None of this is meant to refute anything in the article, but home ownership is a unique form of investment. It can't easily be equated with the routine investing in various markets.
Same here, I added around 40-50K in value to our last house--its paying yourself in the long run.
And that increased equity sits invisible on your bottom line, tax-free until you sell. With a little luck the tax assessor don't doesn't know how much more your house is worth.
Housing is an investment only if you are a landlord, or if you sell the house to move to a much cheaper area.
Trump just wants to get past the Midterms without house prices crashing. After that, he doesn't care.
Homeownership was never an investment! Exactly as stated - it's a "consumption good" (as in "goods and services"). The only financial benefit is that ones builds "forced equity" as one pays off a mortgage - but in order to access that equity you either have to sell, or borrow against it.
> All of the aforementioned bad ideas rest on a flawed assumption—that housing is a financial investment. It isn’t, and never was.
I don't entirely agree with this. Buying a house (for personal use) may not result in the ownership of a productive asset, but buying a house (whether via a mortgage or cash) is effectively locking in the price of your housing over the course of your stay. The return on the money you "invested" on your housing seems effectively offset by inflation, but your cost of housing over that time was roughly constant (not actually due to increasing property taxes).
Treating housing as a wealth building vehicle from that sense is a losing proposition. But if the cost of renting increases faster than the increase in property taxes owed (which based on market forces it should), you are freeing capital you would otherwise spend on housing for actual investment.
On the flip side, if house prices decline or fail to keep up with inflation, you are actually tying up capital that could otherwise be invested productively. My criticism of the way people treat home ownership as an investment vehicle has less to do with whether it should be considered a financial investment, and way more to do with the expectations and dimwitted evaluation of that investment. Most people do not consider home ownership a risky asset, because home prices "always goes up" in the long run, but they rarely compare that return to performance of other assets (especially the dollar) over the same time.
We have never viewed our homes as an investment. Rather we have used the equity on sales to purchase our next home instead of renting. Because of my job we had to move five times. Each time we applied the growing equity amount to our next purchase. We could have avoided the expenses of homeownership by renting, but we would never have accumulated the wealth we did from our homes. We started with a relatively small house in a marginal area of Atlanta in the ‘70s with a 12.5% mortgage and proceeded from there.
If the Feds would stop trying to manipulate the housing market to please one demographic over another, the market would take care of itself.
The problem is not that the dollar denominated price of a new home has risen by 400%, it is that the dollar has lost 90% of its value in the last 40 years. If personal income, AFTER TAXES, had risen by 900% to counteract the loss of value of the dollar, the average Joe would not have any problem whatsoever buying a new home.
The problem is, has been, and will continue to be, big government. Can you name a single politican, elected or running for election, who is promoting cutting the size of government by 25%? Proliferation of government spending has caused the problem. Proliferation of spending is what gets politicians elected. Sooooo, is not the REAL PROBLEM the people who elect these politicians?
All of this makes sense to me.
There is one proposed program (not sure if it was enacted) to prohibit the purchase of single family homes by investment companies, to try to keep them from bidding up the prices and keep the market a "retail market."
What are your thoughts on that proposal and do you know if it was enacted?