"The suggestion by some that there is a need to impose price controls on some essential consumer goods overlooks how such policies stifle the production process and lead to shortages..."
These analyses never take seriously the failure to enforce anti monopoly law or the degree to which the ownership of classes of so many goods is so concentrated- like processed food and medical care and telecom and utilities and network effects in tech. We’re at the point, right, that 50% of consumer spending is spent by the top 10% -or is it more than that? This Mises analysis focuses too much on consumer “power” and not enough on how much most can be squeezed as quality of life deteriorates.
You make a mistake if you think that monopolies can set any price they want. They can manipulate prices only to some extent.
The fact is, any supplier in any market can set any price they want. But fi they want to SELL anything, they need to price at a level where customers will buy. That holds true for monopolies.
I didn't say all this in defense of monopolies. I am a 100% free marked capitalist. But no economy, when regulated by people who don't understand basic economics, can succeed.
Exactly! Increased profits should not be seen as a reflection of inflation but of market collusion. People are great at seeing the problem but general terrible at determining the correct cause. Engineering has a formalized process to find the root cause of a problem and still gets it wrong. Instead of explaining over and over again that corporate greed isn't inflation, explain how monopolistic practices is what causes the higher prices and profits relative to their income.
Greed works against collusion. The seller who offers the product just a little cheaper sells out first. There's always some seller who isn't part of the collusion or who cheats it.
Greed can also work with collusion. Blindly saying capitalism fixes it because in an ideal world the lower price or higher quality guy will sell more sounds exactly the same to me as the "real communism has never been tried" people. It doesn't matter how good the "plan" is, it matters how it actually works in real life. In real life anyone making lots of money will use all kinds of monopolistic strategies to keep making lots of money. Have a plan to prevent this and fix it when it does happen or resign yourself to eventual communism.
Inflation, properly understood, is the main cause of the recent surge in profits and profit margins. These are not "obscene" profits. As new money floods into the economy, prices of both consumer goods (sales) and capital goods (costs) go up. However, the costs that are matched against sales are historical and are therefore recorded at a lower level than their current replacement cost. I suspect much of today's so-called "obscene profit" is due to this inherent problem of price increases over time and the accounting convention of matching historical costs with present-day sales. When prices fall, the opposite problem occurs: reported profits are compressed.
Failure to understand this dynamic will cause many investors to project current high profit margins into the future. The fact is, current high profit margins are sustainable only under a policy of accelerating inflation.
When price signals are eventually eliminated and allocation of goods and services is by right, there won't be anywhere near enough of anything to go around. At that point gated communities will sport armed guards since those wealthy living withing will have all they need or want but will have to keep the hungry rabble at bay. This is how all these socialist, collectivist schemes end.
As far as it goes, that is regarding consumer goods and services, the “Classical”/Austrian analysis of prices is absolutely correct, as long as government action does not deform the market. We currently have a “market’ that is so deformed by governments ((both federal and State) that it is a wonder that it still functions at all.
The entire price is subject to inflation. The investors who get return from profit expect to keep up with inflation too. It’s not like the profit’s value is not subject to inflation.
The discipline is that if I as a seller decide to shave profit by a penny, reducing my offering price accordingly,, I'll sell most or all of my goods before others with higher prices. Money now is more valuable than money later. These concepts are within the comprehensibility of anyone with above a room temperature IQ.
Increased money supply is driving corporate profits higher.
And tons of corporation have jumped on the band wagon and raised prices just because they have the cover of "inflation" on which to blame it.
It's all about higher prices on less service or a lower number of units.......to cut back on energy usage......but still be able to make the debt payments.
Yes, we know that in the long-term the Fed’s actions just amount to wealth redistribution. This makes the point that even in the short term it really just amounts to redistribution and little else. I think of your recent article about the Fed getting such a rat deal on the MBS it is holding. Well, someone got to upgrade those MBS for a lower risk asset returning a higher yield, and have the difference picked up by the taxpayer. It’s good to be a member bank of the Fed when the redistribution starts.
These analyses never take seriously the failure to enforce anti monopoly law or the degree to which the ownership of classes of so many goods is so concentrated- like processed food and medical care and telecom and utilities and network effects in tech. We’re at the point, right, that 50% of consumer spending is spent by the top 10% -or is it more than that? This Mises analysis focuses too much on consumer “power” and not enough on how much most can be squeezed as quality of life deteriorates.
You make a mistake if you think that monopolies can set any price they want. They can manipulate prices only to some extent.
The fact is, any supplier in any market can set any price they want. But fi they want to SELL anything, they need to price at a level where customers will buy. That holds true for monopolies.
I didn't say all this in defense of monopolies. I am a 100% free marked capitalist. But no economy, when regulated by people who don't understand basic economics, can succeed.
Gotta have that latest IPhone model.
Exactly! Increased profits should not be seen as a reflection of inflation but of market collusion. People are great at seeing the problem but general terrible at determining the correct cause. Engineering has a formalized process to find the root cause of a problem and still gets it wrong. Instead of explaining over and over again that corporate greed isn't inflation, explain how monopolistic practices is what causes the higher prices and profits relative to their income.
Greed works against collusion. The seller who offers the product just a little cheaper sells out first. There's always some seller who isn't part of the collusion or who cheats it.
Greed can also work with collusion. Blindly saying capitalism fixes it because in an ideal world the lower price or higher quality guy will sell more sounds exactly the same to me as the "real communism has never been tried" people. It doesn't matter how good the "plan" is, it matters how it actually works in real life. In real life anyone making lots of money will use all kinds of monopolistic strategies to keep making lots of money. Have a plan to prevent this and fix it when it does happen or resign yourself to eventual communism.
None of us here need this explained, surely this is more for children and Mamdani voters?
I figured with Mamdani's win yesterday, can't be too careful.
Inflation, properly understood, is the main cause of the recent surge in profits and profit margins. These are not "obscene" profits. As new money floods into the economy, prices of both consumer goods (sales) and capital goods (costs) go up. However, the costs that are matched against sales are historical and are therefore recorded at a lower level than their current replacement cost. I suspect much of today's so-called "obscene profit" is due to this inherent problem of price increases over time and the accounting convention of matching historical costs with present-day sales. When prices fall, the opposite problem occurs: reported profits are compressed.
Failure to understand this dynamic will cause many investors to project current high profit margins into the future. The fact is, current high profit margins are sustainable only under a policy of accelerating inflation.
When price signals are eventually eliminated and allocation of goods and services is by right, there won't be anywhere near enough of anything to go around. At that point gated communities will sport armed guards since those wealthy living withing will have all they need or want but will have to keep the hungry rabble at bay. This is how all these socialist, collectivist schemes end.
These days,if it's an ill-conceived idea, it's sure to be put in place.
High prices are the best cure for high prices.
As far as it goes, that is regarding consumer goods and services, the “Classical”/Austrian analysis of prices is absolutely correct, as long as government action does not deform the market. We currently have a “market’ that is so deformed by governments ((both federal and State) that it is a wonder that it still functions at all.
The entire price is subject to inflation. The investors who get return from profit expect to keep up with inflation too. It’s not like the profit’s value is not subject to inflation.
The discipline is that if I as a seller decide to shave profit by a penny, reducing my offering price accordingly,, I'll sell most or all of my goods before others with higher prices. Money now is more valuable than money later. These concepts are within the comprehensibility of anyone with above a room temperature IQ.
We’re about to see this play out in real time in NYC it seems.
Increased money supply is driving corporate profits higher.
And tons of corporation have jumped on the band wagon and raised prices just because they have the cover of "inflation" on which to blame it.
It's all about higher prices on less service or a lower number of units.......to cut back on energy usage......but still be able to make the debt payments.
Yes, we know that in the long-term the Fed’s actions just amount to wealth redistribution. This makes the point that even in the short term it really just amounts to redistribution and little else. I think of your recent article about the Fed getting such a rat deal on the MBS it is holding. Well, someone got to upgrade those MBS for a lower risk asset returning a higher yield, and have the difference picked up by the taxpayer. It’s good to be a member bank of the Fed when the redistribution starts.