14 Comments
User's avatar
Mrs Bucket's avatar

Great article, also some clues as to why the Democrats have so many Champagne Socialists, Limousine Liberals and Bollinger Bolsheviks. Isn't it amazing how they start out poor and whining 'it's not fair' but when in government end up rich, like Nancy Pelosi, Diane Weinstein, Kim Schrier etc. What is Obama worth? And Biden?

Don C.'s avatar

I have heard and used the term "Limousine liberals" but had NOT heard the other 2 and they are GOLD! Champagne Socialists and Bollinger Bolsheviks - f'ing perfect!

balazs's avatar

There is a thing about inequality. Everyone think its a bad thing. However, if you try to find a statistical definition for it and try to measure it, for instance by looking at differences between average and median income or wealth (Lyn Alden did a very nice analysis of this about 2 years ago), you will find that places like Switzerland or Monaco or Singapore are by far the most unequal places in the world.

However, they also happen to be the best places to live for humans on this planet. GINI coefficient, human development index, people's subjective happines, you name it, unequal countries are almost always in the lead.

The only outlier of this seems to be the US, which is unequal but is getting less and less a good place to live for its citizens. Well, the US however is also a global imperium on the decline, and side-effects of this, like Triffin's dilemma are probably the most reasonable causes for this paradox.

So why are we afraid of inequality? Inequality creates incentives and social mobility. In my home country, Hungary society was a lot more equal from 1948 to 1990 in the years of Soviet style socialism. The income difference in 1980 between the top and the bottom decile was 4x, in 2000, 10 years after the change it was 17x. Was Hungary a better place to live in 1980 than in 2000?

An unequal society is not a problem. A society without social mobility and inequality is a HUGE problem.

The Radical Individualist's avatar

I'm not an economist, but I can't help seeing that capitalism in the nineteenth century involved producing real goods and the transportation to move them. Today's capitalism largely involves financial instruments and computer software. Those robber barons are looking pretty good, right about now.

Dean Whiting's avatar

“”””Today, the financial elite manipulate the allocation mechanism itself, without producing real value, “””

It would seem that the Ukraine war provides an illustration of this… despite (or perhaps because of) lacking financial manipulation, Russia is able to rely on production of war fighting material vs the Wests financial sanctions and manipulations.

Brian Clavin's avatar

What an Interesting Perspective!!

Not sure if it is entirely true…

But it is a Tour de Force in analysing a thought to its logical conclusion/destination.

Nice Work!!

Gonzalo Avendano's avatar

Inequality is exaggerated and amplified with inflation, but inflation is not the cause itself. Inequality, is the consequence of the acting of unequal human beings in social life, achieving different results. Inequality is natural. Equality would be unnatural and imposible. Inflation accelerates the process, because it punish more the less able of the society. It is a tax on the poor.

craazyman's avatar

Not bad for a Mises Freak!

A lot of truth there & well said.

The anecdote about 8% inflation is misleading though. A rich person’s assets my inflate at 8% but the poor man’s wages won’t flatline at 0%. They’ll rise too. And a lot of wealthy people do get wiped out in hyper inflations. The relative winners/losers is more nuanced.

The notion of the perpetually self-regulating “market” — that would autonomously handle booms & busts if the govermint stayed out — is also a fiction. Markets reflect group psychology and no govermint is needed for booms & busts. Human psychology does it all. Inevitably, those without capital suffer from distorted economic boom structure when the bust hits — collapsed enterprises, job loss, etc. Social/political pressure demands the govermint step in or else people will be destitute. Sure, you can say “let them all die, it’s the market at work” but politicians, or even emperors, kings, dictators will be taken down by social convulsion.

You have to be realistic about “political economy”, the market is no god, even with a lower-case G. It’s not even a saint. It’s not a sinner either. It’s just you and me multiplied by a few million. It makes mistakes just like we do.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Well done, concise insights.

Rick's avatar

Case in point. One can buy a 90% silver 1964 Kennedy 1/2 dollar on line for $10, and a 90% silver quarter for $5. That represents a 95% reduction in the value of the current proletariat dollar since 1964.

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

The usual competent job by the Mises Institute.