14 Comments
User's avatar
TimCNY's avatar

I entered the nuclear power industry in 1980 after graduating with a BS in mechanical engineering. My first job was as a startup and commissioning engineer and received my first license in 1982. I've been anticipating the "nuclear renaissance" ever since. In my opinion, given the mix of energy sources, nuclear power is the best use for baseload power generation. Next best would be coal and hydroelectric. Notice all are burdened by difficult (and I think unreasonable) environmental regulations and impossible risk assessments.

If medicine, chemicals and pharmaceuticals were subject to the same scrutiny, most drugs and chemicals would be banned, and as would many medical procedures because the risks, while low for most would result in poor outcomes for some. In the nuclear energy business, that is a huge hurdle. Component upgrades and controls system improvements may take years to recieve approvals, making them costly and risky from a business perspective, therefore logical beneficial improvements aren't even attempted. Regulatory capture isn't a problem; regulatory antagonism is.

Ken Kunda's avatar

The Nuclear Regulatory Agency changed from an agency to promote and regulate nuclear power safely to an agency dedicated to limiting any nuclear power through over regulation.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Is thorium the way to go, much safer and less HazMat ?

TimCNY's avatar

I was an operator and in construction. Not involved in reactor design.

Mark Heywood's avatar

Great article, thanks for sharing. I think we all share Robert's opinion.

DLB's avatar

I am not aware of the write offs and incentives for nuclear energy in America, but it's interesting to note what does exist for the oil and gas industry. 100% first-year write-off of their investment against active income is what they have enjoyed for decades. As an investor, this is a very valuable investment to have. If your direct oil and gas investment equals your annual income, you can write it all off against your income and owe 0 taxes while retaining ownership in the oil or gas well. I'm not advocating those incentives be removed as they help keep the prices down that all of us pay for their end products. But it is necessary to understand that almost all sources of energy in America have some sort of incentive given to them by the IRS via congress.

TimCNY's avatar

I'm not sure what you mean by "100% write off". Purchasing new reserves are not treated as current expenses. They are subject to depletion allowances. Capital equipment purchases are subject to the same depreciation rules as any other business. So I'm not sure what you are saying is accurate under current tax rules.

DLB's avatar

As it was explained to me in a presentation from a private oil and gas drilling company in America. I would be able to write off 100% of my investment in the oil and gas company as part owner, against any other income i have from other sources for that year. I checked with my tax accountant who had not done this before, but did reply back to me that after researching the tax code, what I was told was allowed at the time, which was in 2011. I did a quick check with the Google AI assistant today, and in summary it said that the same rules apply today. It's been 15 years since and I have not invested again, but it did work in 2011. I would like to make clear, I do not take chances with the IRS, I depend on professional tax advice.

george's avatar

They want you to forget Tesla's experiments on wireless energy. We're supposed to be flying in anti-gravity cars powered by free electricity by now. JP Morgan said no.

Watchingtheweasels's avatar

Although I am inclined to support deregulation as a matter of economic philosophy, I look at the airline industry a half century after deregulation (same day service, sometimes!) and commercial banking after the repeal of Glass-Stegall and think “deregulate the nuclear industry? No freakin way.”

Mrs Bucket's avatar

First, Soviet Russia and then Communist China do NOT want the west or the USA to have cheap, reliable, clean nuclear power, so they work though their many channels to subvert the obvious solution to clean energy.

Paul C's avatar

Looks like steamed water I think they’re all fos there’s no nuclear

Allan Richard Wasem's avatar

The amount of energy inputs equals the amount of "civilization" in any society. In order first for there to be energy outputs there must be an ROI for the energy producer. Said ROI must be reasonably competitive with alternative ROIs available for the investment capital necessary to create the energy outputs. The strangulation of nuclear power generation by government regulation has created a situation which there is effectively NO net ROI available for future producers of nuclear power. Until that situation changes there will be no substantial (re)development of the nuclear power industry domestically.