12 Comments
User's avatar
Laramie's avatar

Thank you. I've been saying this for a year. I've been long STRC for months. Had I been smart, I would also have been short MSTR.

"If you own the common, it is becoming difficult to look at those transactions and conclude that your security sits anywhere near the top of Strategy’s list of priorities."

This is the issue that is most surprising to me. In Capital Markets 101, investors are supposed to learn that there is a capital stack: Bonds sit at the top, then preferred stock, then common stock. While Strategy has introduced many clever variants, the basic rules are still intact.

STRC was a great buy at $71.5. It is tied for the second senior-most claim on Strategy's assets. But, for that same reason, MSTR was a terrible play with BTC sitting between $55,000-$60,000 and Strategy's average BTC acquisition cost at $75,000.

Capital markets are efficient in the long term, but occasionally they can be very stupid in the short term.

Mark Heywood's avatar

you have been long STRC, I'm sorry.

PoW's avatar

Clarification - the converts sit first in the cap structure, STRF is second, and STRC is third. STRC unsecured, subordinated and perpetual preferred. While I agree with you about it being a great buy in the 70s this all works longer term if you have an underlying BTC thesis. It is not like a missed dividend on strc gives you a claim to the underlying BTC. I hold some common, STRF and STRC but just want to ensure investors realize you are ultimately underwriting BTC but just with different return and volatility expectation on each instrument.

Laramie's avatar

Good clarification, and you're right. STRF and the convertible notes are both ahead of STRC. They have about $8 billion in "liquidation value" between them, with about $50 billion of BTC owned by Strategy, and a few billion in cash at this point. I don't think there's any realistic liquidation scenario on the horizon. But, that cushion is why I think STRC was (and still is) much more valuable than the trough it traded down to.

PoW's avatar

Painful being a common shareholder recently but to be clear it 100% depends on your entry price and implied MNAV at time of purchase. If you look at slide 14 of the Q2 26 Earnings Pres can see a demonstrated history of growth in SATS per share year over year (56k/share in 2020 to 203k/share as of 7/26/26). If BTC is down 50% from ATH it makes complete sense that as an intelligently levered BTC play the common would be down by an amplified amount. Accordingly when the market turns bullish the stock would be expected to outperform BTC.

So to answer your question Quoth - investors that believe in the longer term BTC thesis being intact and have a desire to seek amplified returns (w accepted amplified volatility) should buy the stock at these levels. There may also be institutional holders that have a mandate to own common stocks and are not allowed to invest in commodities / digital assets that would like to express a view on BTC so logical for them to own it.

TLDR as in any asset the purchase price (implied multiple) matters and zooming in on a couple month trend of active capital management to craft a long term narrative is flawed IMO. In a bull run on BTC all the excess returns over and above their debt / pref obligations flow straight to the common shareholders (Amplification!). Not to mention as the collateral value and credit coverage ratios improve, the ability to issue more STRC and tighten the dividend will just add reflexivity to the common via increased SATS per share. Defense for bear markets and offence for Bull markets....

Mark Heywood's avatar

I was always daytrading MSTR on the short side, the minute STRC was concocted I knew the writing on the wall I said GTFO of the whole shitpile. What good is 10% when you base shares are down 15% or more. Bitcoin is a ponzi, pump and a fools errand to flush idiots. MSTR is the poster child of the giant turd circling the bowl.

Jeffrey Pleiman's avatar

Ah yes. Aged like a $2 bottle of wine

Bill's avatar

I owned all the prefs and mstr - sold all the preferreds at he the bottom (took my loss) except STRK and then used all the proceeds from the sells to buy more STRK in the 50’s - My thought was it was a like buying a long term call option that at the the time in june, was paying me 15-16% instead of losing time value every day. So far so good - still way down overall but maybe time heals all wounds…. Now - after some reflection and reading this- i regret not also selling mstr and stacking more STRK.

I try to stay positive…

A chart that says “go fuck yourself” (made me laugh) - has a twin brother that says “i got you” ?

Mark Heywood's avatar

stacking more stretch ??

bdhfdfhgf's avatar

QTR - I see you as a quality thinker and writer - and I'm happy with my subscription.

However, I believe you could have covered the (valid and on-point) observations made in this piece in dramatically fewer words.

Steve S's avatar

Spoken like a reader who prefers acronyms over words and dislikes vowels.