So cars as a service is the eventual final end state. Once private equity gets involved this will be significantly more expensive than owning your own car.
Furthermore if our tech leaders get a critical mass of these things on the road look forward to legislation forcing the public to transition to this solution. For safety reasons of course.
So everyone will be able to send their autonomous robot to work in a self-driving car. Freeing up 100% of their time for doomscrolling and social media. What a future!
Put the cork back in the champagne, Professor. The golden age of techolibertarianism has a short life, if any. Part 2 is titled "The Inevitability of Government-Driven Cars on Rails Controlled by a Central Government-Run Facility". They justify their total control by citing some bugs, edge cases, safety (whatever that is; they'll find a few accidents and all media will cover it in Daily Mail style), fairness (whatever they define that to be), rationing (fuel, materials, bandwidth), keeping cars out of the hands of criminals, detransportationing those guilty of wrongspeak, keeping Sensitive Environmental Treasures off-limits to the masses, etc. And of course Revenue Enhancement, like the Turnpike, controlled-access and this time they do it without toll gantries. Kathy Hochul keeps her precious congestion pricing. And you commoners can't own cars: the government lets you rent one for each trip, like a city bike share operation. In short, it's just like the CSX trains through my town are controlled by an office a hundred miles away, possibly on virtual rails. The satellites will handle the details. The "self" in "self-driving" is just a linguistic artifact, it's not your self. Someone else decides Who goes Where and When in What. Cradle to grave to Next Exit 1 km. Safety and convenience, brought to you by Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg.
I've spent s lot of time on the road. I mean a lot....
Currently, distracted drivers are a huge problem...including law enforcement personnel. I see it everyday.
I thoroughly enjoy driving and would feel very uncomfortable having a processor chip controlling the vehicle. Processors can be hacked. If im driving, I know I cant be hacked.
That's your sentiment. For every one of you, there are 5 (or whatever) with the opposite sentiment. Every year, that number will grow from the younger generations. Eventually it will be normal.
The inevitability of "to go where?" Who can afford to travel let alone buy a car? Young kids are not driving. They don't have access to $500 cars they can work on themselves as I once did.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin.
Not sure even Ben could have imagined a time in America where Americans would willingly trade away freedom for a "solution" that has an almost certain ending in a dystopia where the wonderful "regulators" restrict mileage or allowable pickups based on your "social score" or demand the onboard surveillance audio / video be streamed to an "independent third party" to ensure "safety" of the riders. There is zero change of a good ending for this particular non-fiction formerly known as sci-fi. The real winners here: social media companies, companies who have developed the self-driving software / hardware, governments.
Just to put it into perspective: Where I live, roads are already 50% safer in terms of deaths-per-travelled-distance, 70% safer in terms of deaths-per-registered-car and 80% safer in terms of deaths-per-capita (only counting traffic accidents).
So while autonomous vehicles are incredibly impressive technology, the achievements aren't actually that impressive when compared internationally with countries that don't even allow autonomous vehicles testing yet (except some central town autonomous shuttle buses that go up to 10mph).
The safest choice here is to take a train ride on the excellent and very dense train network.
Even in the neighboring country where highways tend to have no speed limits, the deaths-per-travelled-distance are 40% lower than in the US.
The actual way to improve things for everyone is to design roads for the safety of everyone, including anyone that doesn't drive a car. The US was that way a hundred years ago, before towns and cities got paved over with multi-lane roads and car parks since the 1950s and suburbia was invented.
this is the kind of nonsense, reverse-engineered from an emotional conclusion comment i wouldn’t expect to see in thinking society.
‘we are falling behind the rest of the world’, aye? this is either a propaganda bot or an NPC ideologue. the rest of the world is pretty much a shit show of rebranded, failed governmental structures and we know how their story ends.
i’m not sure if it’s poor human sentence structure or sam alt-man’s confession that AI is an eons-old demonically-controlled civilization destroyer, but are you saying you were alive when the industrial revolution came around? i feel like we navigated that shit pretty well. remember that one time when we built a world-dominating empire in 250 years?
now granted, we’re actively fucking it up and allowing the borg the re-assimilate us, but we had a good run.
so, if your metric for us ‘getting it together’ is the TPP (tesla per person) ratio, or the acceptance of skynet’s ‘three-laws safe and effective’ immutable conveyance system… you should get in line for a reset to your liberty meter or head to germany.
freedom and incentivizing creativity solves literally everything over time - though on a long enough timeline, our survival rate drops to zero. accepting and welcoming obvious control structures is your blue pill. you like the taste of the steak, even tho you know it’s not real.
i think i’ll enjoy being the last guy clinging to his v8 and pew-pews, shaking my head as i shed a tear for the plebs who accepted their plebdom, jumped into their silver tube to get to the widget factory, then tacitly accepted their new pronouns “lemming / epsilon” as they launch off the tracks into a ball of fire.
inevitable? maybe. but the breadth, width and depth of controlled masses will never be the barometer by which most on this substack form their thoughts.
get long robots and gunpowder… just make sure you have a properly registered cbdc wallet to process your imperial credits so one can pay for the destruction of the other.
Perhaps it's better to state that other countries have used their monies to build infrastructure while we have spent $1T/year on military equipment. If you're paying attention, we got ripped off with garbage equipment that they are in the process of re-ordering. Eisenhower lied, right?
There's a lot to like about autonomous self-driving transportation, but there will be operational problems for sure. Consider areas with severe weather, especially wintertime, and where roads are clogged with traffic, abandoned cars, accidents, etc. How about the problems of a shared space for public vehicles - think public transportation today. Uck! The advance of technologies is a two-edged sword: in the aggregate there's improvement but the edge cases and misapplication can be difficult and have unintended consequences.
1.) It may be awhile, remember that Google Maps is still leading vehicles off cliffs.
2.) Besides as "Get Away" vehicles, they stink. Tell us that once the regulators get ahold of this that they won't have the vehicle driven directly to law enforcement headquarters once the crime is committed.
I would love to be able to relax and read instead of drive on the morning commute, especially in my former life in Southern California where mass transit options are limited and often awkward (I figured it would take 2 1/2 hours each way to work using Metrolink and bus transfers compared to the 30 minute trip by car). The transition to a majority AV world will probably be awkward but given enough users cars can interact, improving traffic, forming convoys, and even syncing those abilities with traffic signals to help with inter-city flows. That said, I've been an off-road explorer most my life, mostly in Baja, but now in New Mexico, and I don't think it would be half as fun if I wasn't doing the driving. But for the mundane aspects of driving I think AVs sound great.
Amazing how as a group, let's say we Americans for arguments sake, we fear and push back on innovation and progress. I'd say especially with our beloved cars. Where I live, in a close in Charlotte neighborhood, our streets are filled with SUVs of varying size and many large trucks like the F-150 type. And a small number of Teslas. There was no burning of Tesla dealerships when all that was happening. Most parking lots I enter are filled with these large trucks and cars.
Our government has officially declared us a non electric car country (despite the bright red Tesla that was given to our president). We are literally falling behind the rest of the world. And why? I look back at every point of innovation in my lifetime and see this theme going way back - the industrial revolution, electricity, the Model T the internet and many more. I hope we get it together soon.
Oil is not an infinite resource, may 50 years at current production, so electric is inevitable. Of course it will get much better, even the solid state batteries currently being worked on have longer ranges than gas and short charging times.
Forgive me, which country led the way in the Industrial Revolution, electricity, the Model T, the Internet, and "many more"? It's name escapes me right now. Iran? Nah, I'm sure they would have if they could have, but that doesn't sound right. France? Definitely not. China? Oops, wrong again. I think it's the same country that used to understand that personal liberty was paramount and that any so-called "innovation" and "progress" needed to be carefully examined against this fundamental right to ensure its compatibility. Insulting Americans who appreciate the freedom to choose their own risk tolerance, the freedom to choose their means of locomotion, or who are suspicious that EVs/AVs will eventually be used in nefarious ways by those in positions of power (because no innovation has EVER been used to restrict the liberties of the people) smacks of the elitist "I know what's best for you" tyrrany that we declared independence from nearly 250 years ago.
Self driving cars are a far bigger impact than this. The real solution is they will quadruple the traffic they put on current roads. Cars can be spaced inches apart on all sides. People will no longer be able to drive because we don’t have the reaction time to drive this closely. In the densest freeway traffic jam you have ever been in, less than 1/3 of the roadway is full and this allows them to fill up. With cars that close their form will change to optimize reduced wind resistance so fuel usage will drop. Criminals might use this to rob someone in the car in front or on their side. Freeways will not have a center median and traffic will have more lanes in the high traffic direction that changes all the time. No stop lights cars will just whizz through the intersection and the computers will interleave them. Pedestrians will just step off to cross and the traffic will just flow around them. Police cars and the elite will move through wide open lanes at tremendous speed, hackers will provide themselves driving advantages we cannot imagine. It will begin with “high speed lanes” for the self driving cars and congested lanes for old school drivers so people will rapidly adopt the newer cars at some inflection point. Manual driving will become illegal. Trucks will only travel at off peak hours. On long open stretches cars will gather together to reduce wind resistance. Let your imagination go on this and you can see big changes.
Lots of interesting conjectures for sure though "quadrupling" the amount of traffic doesn't sound right since even if someone owns several cars they can only drive one at a time. Maybe pockets of convoyed cars can back up manual car drivers since AVs would go the speed limit but this happens with human drivers all the time with a few slow drivers eventually causing traffic to back up. Good to think of the downsides though.
In Los Angeles the traffic getting to work is horrendous. Building more freeways and roads won’t fix a gradually worsening problem but quadrupling the traffic volume the current roads can carry would be a great solution. I’m sure in Manhattan or DC it is the same.
Yeah the 405 is so named because it takes 4 hours and five minutes to go anywhere😂 I can actually remember when there was a early morning and late afternoon commute traffic but the freeways were otherwise relatively open. I was occasionally still working in SoCal until three years ago so I'm painfully aware of the craziness.
So cars as a service is the eventual final end state. Once private equity gets involved this will be significantly more expensive than owning your own car.
Furthermore if our tech leaders get a critical mass of these things on the road look forward to legislation forcing the public to transition to this solution. For safety reasons of course.
Not to mention seamless restrictions from the government. Looks like no vacation this year, we’ve used all of our miles!
So everyone will be able to send their autonomous robot to work in a self-driving car. Freeing up 100% of their time for doomscrolling and social media. What a future!
Not a future. It's already happening.
Given the comments thus far, I would say your conclusion is correct: "The real barriers are regulation and public sentiment."
A solution looking for a problem.
Put the cork back in the champagne, Professor. The golden age of techolibertarianism has a short life, if any. Part 2 is titled "The Inevitability of Government-Driven Cars on Rails Controlled by a Central Government-Run Facility". They justify their total control by citing some bugs, edge cases, safety (whatever that is; they'll find a few accidents and all media will cover it in Daily Mail style), fairness (whatever they define that to be), rationing (fuel, materials, bandwidth), keeping cars out of the hands of criminals, detransportationing those guilty of wrongspeak, keeping Sensitive Environmental Treasures off-limits to the masses, etc. And of course Revenue Enhancement, like the Turnpike, controlled-access and this time they do it without toll gantries. Kathy Hochul keeps her precious congestion pricing. And you commoners can't own cars: the government lets you rent one for each trip, like a city bike share operation. In short, it's just like the CSX trains through my town are controlled by an office a hundred miles away, possibly on virtual rails. The satellites will handle the details. The "self" in "self-driving" is just a linguistic artifact, it's not your self. Someone else decides Who goes Where and When in What. Cradle to grave to Next Exit 1 km. Safety and convenience, brought to you by Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg.
I've spent s lot of time on the road. I mean a lot....
Currently, distracted drivers are a huge problem...including law enforcement personnel. I see it everyday.
I thoroughly enjoy driving and would feel very uncomfortable having a processor chip controlling the vehicle. Processors can be hacked. If im driving, I know I cant be hacked.
I miss COVID. The streets were empty.
You can't be hacked but you can be killed by a drunk or wrong way driver.
Or you can kill yourself by a momentary lapse of attention or a wide awake doze you don't even realize you are experiencing.
That's your sentiment. For every one of you, there are 5 (or whatever) with the opposite sentiment. Every year, that number will grow from the younger generations. Eventually it will be normal.
The inevitability of "to go where?" Who can afford to travel let alone buy a car? Young kids are not driving. They don't have access to $500 cars they can work on themselves as I once did.
"Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin.
Not sure even Ben could have imagined a time in America where Americans would willingly trade away freedom for a "solution" that has an almost certain ending in a dystopia where the wonderful "regulators" restrict mileage or allowable pickups based on your "social score" or demand the onboard surveillance audio / video be streamed to an "independent third party" to ensure "safety" of the riders. There is zero change of a good ending for this particular non-fiction formerly known as sci-fi. The real winners here: social media companies, companies who have developed the self-driving software / hardware, governments.
Agreed and a great quote from a Founding Father.
Just to put it into perspective: Where I live, roads are already 50% safer in terms of deaths-per-travelled-distance, 70% safer in terms of deaths-per-registered-car and 80% safer in terms of deaths-per-capita (only counting traffic accidents).
So while autonomous vehicles are incredibly impressive technology, the achievements aren't actually that impressive when compared internationally with countries that don't even allow autonomous vehicles testing yet (except some central town autonomous shuttle buses that go up to 10mph).
The safest choice here is to take a train ride on the excellent and very dense train network.
Even in the neighboring country where highways tend to have no speed limits, the deaths-per-travelled-distance are 40% lower than in the US.
The actual way to improve things for everyone is to design roads for the safety of everyone, including anyone that doesn't drive a car. The US was that way a hundred years ago, before towns and cities got paved over with multi-lane roads and car parks since the 1950s and suburbia was invented.
this is the kind of nonsense, reverse-engineered from an emotional conclusion comment i wouldn’t expect to see in thinking society.
‘we are falling behind the rest of the world’, aye? this is either a propaganda bot or an NPC ideologue. the rest of the world is pretty much a shit show of rebranded, failed governmental structures and we know how their story ends.
i’m not sure if it’s poor human sentence structure or sam alt-man’s confession that AI is an eons-old demonically-controlled civilization destroyer, but are you saying you were alive when the industrial revolution came around? i feel like we navigated that shit pretty well. remember that one time when we built a world-dominating empire in 250 years?
now granted, we’re actively fucking it up and allowing the borg the re-assimilate us, but we had a good run.
so, if your metric for us ‘getting it together’ is the TPP (tesla per person) ratio, or the acceptance of skynet’s ‘three-laws safe and effective’ immutable conveyance system… you should get in line for a reset to your liberty meter or head to germany.
freedom and incentivizing creativity solves literally everything over time - though on a long enough timeline, our survival rate drops to zero. accepting and welcoming obvious control structures is your blue pill. you like the taste of the steak, even tho you know it’s not real.
i think i’ll enjoy being the last guy clinging to his v8 and pew-pews, shaking my head as i shed a tear for the plebs who accepted their plebdom, jumped into their silver tube to get to the widget factory, then tacitly accepted their new pronouns “lemming / epsilon” as they launch off the tracks into a ball of fire.
inevitable? maybe. but the breadth, width and depth of controlled masses will never be the barometer by which most on this substack form their thoughts.
get long robots and gunpowder… just make sure you have a properly registered cbdc wallet to process your imperial credits so one can pay for the destruction of the other.
Perhaps it's better to state that other countries have used their monies to build infrastructure while we have spent $1T/year on military equipment. If you're paying attention, we got ripped off with garbage equipment that they are in the process of re-ordering. Eisenhower lied, right?
A self-driving oriented business, Waymo, says self-driving is better?
Who wudda thunk?
There's a lot to like about autonomous self-driving transportation, but there will be operational problems for sure. Consider areas with severe weather, especially wintertime, and where roads are clogged with traffic, abandoned cars, accidents, etc. How about the problems of a shared space for public vehicles - think public transportation today. Uck! The advance of technologies is a two-edged sword: in the aggregate there's improvement but the edge cases and misapplication can be difficult and have unintended consequences.
1.) It may be awhile, remember that Google Maps is still leading vehicles off cliffs.
2.) Besides as "Get Away" vehicles, they stink. Tell us that once the regulators get ahold of this that they won't have the vehicle driven directly to law enforcement headquarters once the crime is committed.
And yet just about everybody not a Boomer uses Google or another map app.
That's what motos will be for!
I would love to be able to relax and read instead of drive on the morning commute, especially in my former life in Southern California where mass transit options are limited and often awkward (I figured it would take 2 1/2 hours each way to work using Metrolink and bus transfers compared to the 30 minute trip by car). The transition to a majority AV world will probably be awkward but given enough users cars can interact, improving traffic, forming convoys, and even syncing those abilities with traffic signals to help with inter-city flows. That said, I've been an off-road explorer most my life, mostly in Baja, but now in New Mexico, and I don't think it would be half as fun if I wasn't doing the driving. But for the mundane aspects of driving I think AVs sound great.
In California, they've had green lanes for decades. That whole concept will be repurposed, at least initially, to accommodate self-driving vehicles.
Amazing how as a group, let's say we Americans for arguments sake, we fear and push back on innovation and progress. I'd say especially with our beloved cars. Where I live, in a close in Charlotte neighborhood, our streets are filled with SUVs of varying size and many large trucks like the F-150 type. And a small number of Teslas. There was no burning of Tesla dealerships when all that was happening. Most parking lots I enter are filled with these large trucks and cars.
Our government has officially declared us a non electric car country (despite the bright red Tesla that was given to our president). We are literally falling behind the rest of the world. And why? I look back at every point of innovation in my lifetime and see this theme going way back - the industrial revolution, electricity, the Model T the internet and many more. I hope we get it together soon.
Electric cars have been tried before, they just don't work.
Oil is not an infinite resource, may 50 years at current production, so electric is inevitable. Of course it will get much better, even the solid state batteries currently being worked on have longer ranges than gas and short charging times.
Forgive me, which country led the way in the Industrial Revolution, electricity, the Model T, the Internet, and "many more"? It's name escapes me right now. Iran? Nah, I'm sure they would have if they could have, but that doesn't sound right. France? Definitely not. China? Oops, wrong again. I think it's the same country that used to understand that personal liberty was paramount and that any so-called "innovation" and "progress" needed to be carefully examined against this fundamental right to ensure its compatibility. Insulting Americans who appreciate the freedom to choose their own risk tolerance, the freedom to choose their means of locomotion, or who are suspicious that EVs/AVs will eventually be used in nefarious ways by those in positions of power (because no innovation has EVER been used to restrict the liberties of the people) smacks of the elitist "I know what's best for you" tyrrany that we declared independence from nearly 250 years ago.
Self driving cars are a far bigger impact than this. The real solution is they will quadruple the traffic they put on current roads. Cars can be spaced inches apart on all sides. People will no longer be able to drive because we don’t have the reaction time to drive this closely. In the densest freeway traffic jam you have ever been in, less than 1/3 of the roadway is full and this allows them to fill up. With cars that close their form will change to optimize reduced wind resistance so fuel usage will drop. Criminals might use this to rob someone in the car in front or on their side. Freeways will not have a center median and traffic will have more lanes in the high traffic direction that changes all the time. No stop lights cars will just whizz through the intersection and the computers will interleave them. Pedestrians will just step off to cross and the traffic will just flow around them. Police cars and the elite will move through wide open lanes at tremendous speed, hackers will provide themselves driving advantages we cannot imagine. It will begin with “high speed lanes” for the self driving cars and congested lanes for old school drivers so people will rapidly adopt the newer cars at some inflection point. Manual driving will become illegal. Trucks will only travel at off peak hours. On long open stretches cars will gather together to reduce wind resistance. Let your imagination go on this and you can see big changes.
Lots of interesting conjectures for sure though "quadrupling" the amount of traffic doesn't sound right since even if someone owns several cars they can only drive one at a time. Maybe pockets of convoyed cars can back up manual car drivers since AVs would go the speed limit but this happens with human drivers all the time with a few slow drivers eventually causing traffic to back up. Good to think of the downsides though.
In Los Angeles the traffic getting to work is horrendous. Building more freeways and roads won’t fix a gradually worsening problem but quadrupling the traffic volume the current roads can carry would be a great solution. I’m sure in Manhattan or DC it is the same.
Yeah the 405 is so named because it takes 4 hours and five minutes to go anywhere😂 I can actually remember when there was a early morning and late afternoon commute traffic but the freeways were otherwise relatively open. I was occasionally still working in SoCal until three years ago so I'm painfully aware of the craziness.