31 Comments
User's avatar
Marty Weil's avatar

I’m surprised there hasn’t been more widespread and vocal pushback against Mamdani’s Democratic Socialism agenda. This shift runs counter to the principles of our Constitutional Republic—the very system Franklin warned the Convention had given us only “if we can keep it.” Clearly, we have not.

Marty Weil's avatar

I’m referring to Ben Franklin. Ever heard of him? If you stuck around until the 8th grade, you would not publicly embarrass yourself.

craazyman's avatar

What about Franklin Roosevelt?

4 terms right?

well . . . everybody has an opinion in a democracy. LOL

Anti-Hip's avatar

I don't know of anything in the US Constitution that clearly prevents its, or its states', governments from implementing, in part or even wholly, any social ownership of the means of production. Could you tell me where it is indisputably stated (as opposed to being an interpretation of language)?

I am not a socialist. I do believe, however, in allowing the balancing of Rightist (freedom) and Leftist (equalizing) positions, ebbing and flowing over time, as has certainly happened historically in the US.

Marty Weil's avatar

Where does the Constitution ban socialism?

• In the Fifth Amendment protection of private property

• In the Tenth Amendment limitation of federal power

• In Article IV’s guarantee of a republican form of government

• In the philosophical foundations that assume private economic liberty as essential to political liberty

Social ownership of production isn’t merely unwise. It is structurally incompatible with the Constitution’s core purpose: preventing government from having that kind of power in the first place.

The question isn’t whether the Constitution mentions socialism by name.

It’s that every mechanism of the Constitution assumes private economic freedom as essential to political freedom.

Anti-Hip's avatar

Where does the Constitution ban socialism?

-- [My responses ...]

• In the Fifth Amendment protection of private property

-- Text: "No person shall be ... be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation."

-- (1) Passing any law that allows "deprivation" satisfies the requirement. e.g. We have the 16th amendment for income tax. (2) "Just compensation" can be interpreted in any number of ways, and has.

• In the Tenth Amendment limitation of federal power

-- Text: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

-- The federal government has the explicit power to "tax", among other things that may be interpreted as "socialist", and where it is not done at the federal level, an individual state can do so.

• In Article IV’s guarantee of a republican form of government

-- A "republican" form of government is simply a specific government implementation of a more general concept, "democracy" (the latter which applies to any type of polity, public or private, sovereign or not).

• In the philosophical foundations that assume private economic liberty as essential to political liberty

-- Unless there are Supreme Court interpretations (especially those based on founding father ideas) that concretely restrict or prevent (any or certain forms) socialism, then it appears it's still open to question.

You further say: "Social ownership of production isn’t merely unwise. It is structurally incompatible with the Constitution’s core purpose: preventing government from having that kind of power in the first place. / The question isn’t whether the Constitution mentions socialism by name. / It’s that every mechanism of the Constitution assumes private economic freedom as essential to political freedom."

-- I'm not arguing here about the merits of socialism -- I'm arguing whether it's *legal* in the U.S., and I'm confident it is, mainly because the Constitution is so minimalist. Lawyers here, please speak up...

Joe's avatar

The phrase "economically illiterate voters” jumped out. This is an apt description of, not just the voters of New York City, but a majority of the voters in the whole country. How else to explain the continuous election of politicians from both parties that have no problem adding to the national deficit every single year.

Bill Lacey's avatar

Mamdani's mistake is getting elected mayor. He would have been better off being a rabble-rouser, playing that into a TV gig. Or better yet, run for Congress, where you can have townhall meetings, speak in a variety of pandering accents, rile everyone up and then go back to Georgetown without having to deliver anything. That's a much easier and more lucrative grift than having to deliver the undeliverable to a mob with a short attention span and a proven propensity for violence.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

At the heart of it they all love the power over others. If you heard his "acceptance speech" you would have heard a vitriolic screed of revenge over the "rich" and "others."

Progressives are not altruistic or virtuous. They are people who desire the power to control everyone else's lives under the veil of virtue. Make a Progressive angry and the mask falls off to reveal the totalitarian underneath.

He's no different, and since he grew up in wealth, he'd rather have the power and the prestige.

He's not going to stop at just mayor, either...

craazyman's avatar

All fair points but what's the solution to the suffocating economic squeeze almost everybody below the "Schiff Gold crowd" experiences every day? Yeah, I know "Mises!". Yeah right.

That is not a serious argument. It's a utopian construct for which there is no evidence anywhere over 50,000 years of western civilization.

What's the solution?

We can throw digs and philosophical punches at Mamdani's rhetoric. But it wouldn't have worked if the status quo was working. It isn't working. Mamdani is a lot like Trump -- various strains of populism.

My (repetitive I know) guess is Mamdani makes common cause with some big money and they try some new things, maybe harkening back to the 1st progressive era 100+ years ago. Some of it may actually work! It won't be Marxism, or communism or an "ism" except the somewhat uniquely American "pragmatism". Will it work? well. Only time will tell. Probably some will and some won't. Just like any other politician.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

What are these "new things" that progressives tried 100 years ago that "might actually work?"

Every "progressive" idea I've ever seen involves stealing from me to pay for someone else's needs.

So what are the "new things?"

craazyman's avatar

LOL. well. It may not work for you but it might work for 100 other people. They call that representative democracy. They have elections and people vote for candidates. Social security, medicare, unemployment insurance, interstate highway system, public libraries, etc. They all came from legislation and public policy.

I mean, yeah, you can be against all those. That's your right. To be sure. But if you're outnumbered 100 to 1 (or 20 to 1), you have to suck it up.

What might work in New York? Well. Some variation on bringing better and more effective public services, some variation where Mamdani and Alex Soros get together with all the Wall STreet progressives and try to reinvent government. Maybe they'll actually come up with things that work?? Maybe.

Illinois Entrepreneur's avatar

"It may not work for you, but it might work for 100 other people."

Well, sure, if you loot a store it doesn't work for the owner, but it works for the looters!

I understand what you are saying about representative democracy. My point is not that I have a grievance with the winners making policy, but that they don't understand or study enough economic history to not repeat the same failed policies.

And, no, I'm not against societal infrastructure or amenity improvement. That benefits us all.

But there does not seem to be any "new" ideas. The ideas I've seen thus far are the same, recycled Progressive ones from...100 years ago, as you pointed out. It always seems that the only answer is to "tax the rich" and raise taxes on everyone. This is not a new idea, and it does not work.

craazyman's avatar

I agree it's going to be difficult. We'll see. Here's a personal experience that colors my thinking a bit: I was a New York investment industry professional in 08/09 and after. I witnessed first hand the Occupy Wall Street. I was a supporter -- due to the "sanctity of bonuses" and bailouts to the same actors whose failed risk managment brought on the crisis. Utterly appalling stuff. Some of the OWS organizers (at first, before the whole thing degenerated into hippy drug dens) were some of the most intelligent, articulate, thoughtful and civic minded people anyone could meet. They were some impressive human beings.

Of course, it all degenerated, as these collectivist enterprises tend to do (hippy summer of love into rancid authoritarian communes, etc.,) Still, I'll give them a chance in Mamdani's administration. I'll wait and see what they do, what they come up with. Will it be groundhog day all over again? Maybe. But sometimes good ideas emerge and sometimes they work. I think some of the New Deal programs and spirit actually did some good -- social security and unemployment insurance, early progressive era reforms of factory/child labor, etc. There are good things in there. Not everything.

There are some smart and thoughtful people who will be part of what Mamdani tries to do. Some probably from Wall STreet. I'll wait and see. Then evaluate, after a year or so.

Tankster's avatar

Uh, maybe 700 years of Western Civilization? Post Dark Ages

Anti-Hip's avatar

"Mamdani is a lot like Trump -- various strains of populism"

Exactly. He's a mirror image, just with a different flavor constituency, putting up a middle finger to the extensive failures of the establishment. But let's keep in mind that both he and Trump were highly curated to rise to the top. The voters didn't choose them, others did; that's how we can understand better where we are now going.

Bill Theobald's avatar

OK, so we all know Mandami is a one term mayor that, hopefully, will enlighten NYC residents of what doesn’t work (again). So in the next election the pendulum will swing in the other direction and end up somewhere, hopefully, in the middle. So I’m wondering what the next mayor candidates platform in NYC will be. Any intelligent thoughts here are appreciated.

Anti-Hip's avatar

"we all know Mandami is a one term mayor"

Afraid not. That approach was tried most recently with two-termer de Blasio. And then there is what happened with c.1970 two-term mayor Lindsay, along with the two decades following him. And don't even ask about the (majority) political views of the legislative City Council, which has responsibility for the budget.

Bill Theobald's avatar

Ok what are opinions of the city council.?

Anti-Hip's avatar

The majority of the council reflects the majority that voted Mamdani in. Here, have at it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Council

Bill Theobald's avatar

Seems NYC keeps slipping further into chaos. How is it that Wall Street let this get away from them.? Greed is definitely not good.

Steve Mudge's avatar

Who was the conservative commentator who said he was hoping Mamdani would win: It's a relatively contained experiment in (too much) Socialism that every few decades needs to happen to show that too much government overreach doesn't work so well. On the larger stage we have an executive branch trying to do the same in a different direction.

Don C.'s avatar

I said it - But I doubt you were referring to me!

Leskunque Lepew's avatar

Spot on.

The vast majority of his voters cant grasp the consequences of his promises.

John's avatar

Almost 50 years ago my professor had been in the grocery business before getting a PhD. Margins were slim and have risen slightly since due to higher margin items being added. Even if you take the high margin items into account and reduced prices I don't think that 3 dollars per hundred is going to make that much difference to the average American. Basic unprepared food is still very affordable!

Don C.'s avatar

Having left my wonderful midtown apartment some 18 years ago, I look forward to watching my former fair city crumble & burn from the safe confines of boring, suburban Connecticut.

Tankster's avatar

Contrast Peter Venkman at 1.25 of this clip: "No job is too big, no fee is too big." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n7JG4Lf7fgY&t=98s

Chris rooke's avatar

As an Englishman having lived in NY I always felt ‘knob’ a British phrase! Has it now moved to Philli?