Existential crisis? Hardly. Loss of purchasing power crisis? Sure, but that's been going on forever, it's just that we're in one of the acceleration phases that happens every few decades. Nothing is ready to take place of USD as reserve fx nor even of USTs as primary collateral. Author needs to understand the criteria for a reserve fx and global liquidity vehicle like USTs. Are they highly flawed? Sure. Do we have any realistic replacement? Sorry.
Suggest author do a bit more homework on what makes for a working global reserve fx. Hint: start with how much liquidity financial and specifically short term credit markets need just to function. If they stop functioning the whole financial system crashes. Yeah. Get to it.
Here's a nice simple youtube that should help acquaint you with some of the issues involved in de-dollarizing.
The only people that "need" the dollar today are the ones trapped inside the dollar fish bowl called America.
The ability to trade and do commerce in one's own currency today is made easy by this thing we all have called a "computer."
What's amazing is that the dollar is still trusted as much as it is. It is the dollar money changers that undermine the trust in most of the currencies around the world. I wonder why they do that? Hmmmm?
The dollar mongers are trying to stay relative today by using the military to gather control of energy markets that the dollar has lost.
A currency is only as good as the energy it will buy....right down to the most basic energy of all called "food."
Currencies that can control purchases of energy are on equal footing. As the dollar loses the ability to dominate the energy markets, other currencies in the world will gain in importance and prominence by their ability to buy and sell energy.
The Eurodollar market of offshore dollar denominated liabilities is estimated at around $13 trillion, though believed to be shrinking. Those dollar borrowers outside America also need dollars to service their debts. I agree over time the role and importance of the dollar looks set to decline through a combination of mismanagement and the rising importance of other currencies, but that's a slow process. However, I don't think the "dollar money changers" need to do much to undermine trust in other fiat currencies, the issuers of those currencies do a good job of that all by themselves for one reason or another.
agreed, but still. the overly quoted Hemingway comes to mind: How did you go bankrupt? "Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly".
You've sketched the "gradually" de-dollarization.
I've got to believe with all the computer science/math/econ technocrat/STEM Geeks across what was formerly called "the Third World" and then "Emerging Markets" and now "BRICS" and maybe soon -- well . . .
I've gotta believe they can figure this out. And that they will. and as a postscript I still think gold will play a role. Maybe not! it's an intellectual fist fight, I suspect. since lots of these Geeks and technocrats are schooled in Western econ programs. I know "Yuk!", but it's true.
And now that the U.S. Navy is something you see in Hollywood movies, not so much in your sea lanes anymore. The arm twisting isn't what it used to be, Trump's bloviations aside.
When? Hard to say. But it could be gradually and then suddenly. We're in gradually right now.
It’s all moot since there is no gold owned by the U.S. Treasury. An audit would prove one way or another if the reported gold is there and a lack of an audit confirms there is none.
The problem of making USD fully redeemable in gold is that banking runs on fractional lending. It can of course run on fractional banking in gold just like it does run on fractional banking in fiat money. HOWEVER, it can't run on the same 10:1 ratio.
Simply because gold is not fiat, if you are short of gold, highly unlikely someone will lend it to you. Same for the banks. So the fractional lending for gold is more like 2.5 : 1 ratio. That would mean, you would need 4x more gold money to cover all and every transaction on credit. If the US GDP is around 30 Tera $ at today's prices, you'll probably need 12 Tera $ in Gold money to cover it... If all of that is just via 8kTons of Gold at the Fed, a kg of Gold would fetch approx 1.5 Mio $.
I believe that “traditionally” many analysts have based their comments around M2 percentages. I know that Luke Groman uses M2. Current values would indicate a “price” for 40% coverage in the mid $30Ks. Intuitively that feels about right to me. Silver I want to see at the “Constitutional” level of 15/1 (which is about the geological ratio as well). The more we research, the more brilliant and prescient those Founding Fathers appear.
Silver - there is just too many copper, Nickel and whatever mines around. All of them produce the silver dirt. Silver today is simply an expensive industrial metal, just like tungsten, molybden and whatever. Scandium is more expensive. But no-one would use Scandium as a value store, lol.
You can still visit Swedish museums to see the huge copper plates Swedes used as money in the 17th century. The point is simply that refining silver by a factor of 10x is fairly easy given sufficient price. So any silver supply deficit is short term if there is long-term commercial interest. It's not like that with gold.
Great silliness. My USD is fully redeemable in gold. I can buy gold with my dollars any time I want. How would having the government be the gold seller change anything, from having any private party be the gold seller?
Yes Matt, you can but an ounce of gold for 5,000 of your US dollars today. Next year, probably not unless you cough up 10,000 of them there dollars. Dollars are currency, not money, as by definition, money is a stable store of value, which disqualifies dollars.
I'll grant you your point to the extent that we're free to buy and sell (albeit at a tax "disadvantage" - goddamn politicos had to fuck us over if we were onto them) gold and silver (and other commodities) in the "market". If the Dems get back into power I fully expect to see efforts to limit that freedom (as well as most other ones) and to reconfiscate PMs.
I think I’ll buy some more gold and silver if doing so is a bet on politicians avoiding hard/honorable decisions. Seems like a no lose proposition.
Or you could divide our total debt ($37 trillion) by number of ounces and get $140,000 per ounce.
Existential crisis? Hardly. Loss of purchasing power crisis? Sure, but that's been going on forever, it's just that we're in one of the acceleration phases that happens every few decades. Nothing is ready to take place of USD as reserve fx nor even of USTs as primary collateral. Author needs to understand the criteria for a reserve fx and global liquidity vehicle like USTs. Are they highly flawed? Sure. Do we have any realistic replacement? Sorry.
Suggest author do a bit more homework on what makes for a working global reserve fx. Hint: start with how much liquidity financial and specifically short term credit markets need just to function. If they stop functioning the whole financial system crashes. Yeah. Get to it.
Here's a nice simple youtube that should help acquaint you with some of the issues involved in de-dollarizing.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K6WPurHcXY4
Why the World Can’t QUIT the USA (The Dollar Trap)
Btw, there are good reasons why governments dropped hard money like gold and silver. Also deals w/ liquidity needs of modern world.
Oh yes, and where do you propose cutting the budget without risking consequences worse than a depreciating USD?
The only people that "need" the dollar today are the ones trapped inside the dollar fish bowl called America.
The ability to trade and do commerce in one's own currency today is made easy by this thing we all have called a "computer."
What's amazing is that the dollar is still trusted as much as it is. It is the dollar money changers that undermine the trust in most of the currencies around the world. I wonder why they do that? Hmmmm?
The dollar mongers are trying to stay relative today by using the military to gather control of energy markets that the dollar has lost.
A currency is only as good as the energy it will buy....right down to the most basic energy of all called "food."
Currencies that can control purchases of energy are on equal footing. As the dollar loses the ability to dominate the energy markets, other currencies in the world will gain in importance and prominence by their ability to buy and sell energy.
The Eurodollar market of offshore dollar denominated liabilities is estimated at around $13 trillion, though believed to be shrinking. Those dollar borrowers outside America also need dollars to service their debts. I agree over time the role and importance of the dollar looks set to decline through a combination of mismanagement and the rising importance of other currencies, but that's a slow process. However, I don't think the "dollar money changers" need to do much to undermine trust in other fiat currencies, the issuers of those currencies do a good job of that all by themselves for one reason or another.
There is no way around a massive systemic problem.
There are not enough dollars in existence in the entire world to pay the debt AND interest. There just is not….and never will be.
It may be a slow process, but it has been picking up speed and is way faster and more advanced than it was a decade ago.
agreed, but still. the overly quoted Hemingway comes to mind: How did you go bankrupt? "Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly".
You've sketched the "gradually" de-dollarization.
I've got to believe with all the computer science/math/econ technocrat/STEM Geeks across what was formerly called "the Third World" and then "Emerging Markets" and now "BRICS" and maybe soon -- well . . .
I've gotta believe they can figure this out. And that they will. and as a postscript I still think gold will play a role. Maybe not! it's an intellectual fist fight, I suspect. since lots of these Geeks and technocrats are schooled in Western econ programs. I know "Yuk!", but it's true.
And now that the U.S. Navy is something you see in Hollywood movies, not so much in your sea lanes anymore. The arm twisting isn't what it used to be, Trump's bloviations aside.
When? Hard to say. But it could be gradually and then suddenly. We're in gradually right now.
It’s all moot since there is no gold owned by the U.S. Treasury. An audit would prove one way or another if the reported gold is there and a lack of an audit confirms there is none.
One way to test the market is for the government to issue gold bonds. That might be interesting.
The problem of making USD fully redeemable in gold is that banking runs on fractional lending. It can of course run on fractional banking in gold just like it does run on fractional banking in fiat money. HOWEVER, it can't run on the same 10:1 ratio.
Simply because gold is not fiat, if you are short of gold, highly unlikely someone will lend it to you. Same for the banks. So the fractional lending for gold is more like 2.5 : 1 ratio. That would mean, you would need 4x more gold money to cover all and every transaction on credit. If the US GDP is around 30 Tera $ at today's prices, you'll probably need 12 Tera $ in Gold money to cover it... If all of that is just via 8kTons of Gold at the Fed, a kg of Gold would fetch approx 1.5 Mio $.
I believe that “traditionally” many analysts have based their comments around M2 percentages. I know that Luke Groman uses M2. Current values would indicate a “price” for 40% coverage in the mid $30Ks. Intuitively that feels about right to me. Silver I want to see at the “Constitutional” level of 15/1 (which is about the geological ratio as well). The more we research, the more brilliant and prescient those Founding Fathers appear.
Silver - there is just too many copper, Nickel and whatever mines around. All of them produce the silver dirt. Silver today is simply an expensive industrial metal, just like tungsten, molybden and whatever. Scandium is more expensive. But no-one would use Scandium as a value store, lol.
You can keep believing that and I'll keep laughing all the way to the Bank. First started buying silver in the "oughts" and never looked back.
As the saying goes: You can lead a horse to water....
You can still visit Swedish museums to see the huge copper plates Swedes used as money in the 17th century. The point is simply that refining silver by a factor of 10x is fairly easy given sufficient price. So any silver supply deficit is short term if there is long-term commercial interest. It's not like that with gold.
I’m not concerned with any “term” less than 5 years.
The day after SHTF Day the Wasem General Store in Utah will be accepting gold, silver and barter in payment.
The cost of Empire.
Great silliness. My USD is fully redeemable in gold. I can buy gold with my dollars any time I want. How would having the government be the gold seller change anything, from having any private party be the gold seller?
Yes Matt, you can but an ounce of gold for 5,000 of your US dollars today. Next year, probably not unless you cough up 10,000 of them there dollars. Dollars are currency, not money, as by definition, money is a stable store of value, which disqualifies dollars.
And the $ “currency” is entirely Fiat Debt!
I'll grant you your point to the extent that we're free to buy and sell (albeit at a tax "disadvantage" - goddamn politicos had to fuck us over if we were onto them) gold and silver (and other commodities) in the "market". If the Dems get back into power I fully expect to see efforts to limit that freedom (as well as most other ones) and to reconfiscate PMs.
Hater’s gonna hate