Discussion about this post

User's avatar
zaporozhe's avatar

I suppose it's a measure of our present predicament that gold's role as a monetary metal was hotly debated during the first years of the Great Depression. From 1931 :

"The delegation has admitted the likelihood of a gold shortage and has proposed means of maintaining an adequate supply of credit expansion in the face of inadequate gold supplies."

https://chicagotribune.newspapers.com/article/chicago-tribune-the-problem-with-gold-as/122119688/

Economies grow. The transaction demand for money always increases. The supply of gold is fixed and inelastic. Debasement is inevitable.

Unless we're all up for deflation, which is worse.

Gold is a scorecard for how well we are allocating scarce resources to productive ends.

When we sent 600,000 soldiers to a land war in Asia and flew to the moon at the same time, gold noticed. When we swamped the nation in subsidies to weather a non-existent

plague while handing untold billions to chronically unproductive third worlders who are in the country illegally, gold noticed that, too.

But what gold is not is money, not in the practical sense that we need money.

Public policy should aim at ameliorating the inevitable. That is, if we accept that we are stuck with a fiat system that is inherently inflationary, then :

1) The Fed should abandon a dual mandate and target a 2% inflation rate only.

2) Recognizing that most of what governments do is inflationary and that persistent inflation isn't sourced anywhere else. The easiest to understand metric is a balanced budget, and it's with personal dismay that advocates of balanced budgets have vanished in the past 20 years.

I'm at a loss to guess how we get there from here. For example : the principle that governments should enforce the equality of outcomes is the midwife of more destructive spending than I care to imagine. What, two in five electors buy into that, probably more?

My inner pessimist concludes that a hard rain's gonna fall before people are disabused of that notion, and recalling Winston Churchill's quixotic return to the gold standard in 1925, I doubt the creation of a gold backed currency will be a ,erm, silver bullet that will finesse what's to come.

Mike's avatar

Pretty big assumption he’s making, and I know von Mises wrote it in 1953, but we have no proof Treasury has the 8000 tons we are told it has. Physically probably most of it is there, hopefully but I think Bessent whispered in Trump’s ear to drop the Ft Knox inspection because he knows that although there is gold there it has been re-hypothecated so many times it would crash the market trying to undo it.

27 more comments...

Ready for more?