I suppose it's a measure of our present predicament that gold's role as a monetary metal was hotly debated during the first years of the Great Depression. From 1931 :
"The delegation has admitted the likelihood of a gold shortage and has proposed means of maintaining an adequate supply of credit expansion in the face of inadequate gold supplies."
Economies grow. The transaction demand for money always increases. The supply of gold is fixed and inelastic. Debasement is inevitable.
Unless we're all up for deflation, which is worse.
Gold is a scorecard for how well we are allocating scarce resources to productive ends.
When we sent 600,000 soldiers to a land war in Asia and flew to the moon at the same time, gold noticed. When we swamped the nation in subsidies to weather a non-existent
plague while handing untold billions to chronically unproductive third worlders who are in the country illegally, gold noticed that, too.
But what gold is not is money, not in the practical sense that we need money.
Public policy should aim at ameliorating the inevitable. That is, if we accept that we are stuck with a fiat system that is inherently inflationary, then :
1) The Fed should abandon a dual mandate and target a 2% inflation rate only.
2) Recognizing that most of what governments do is inflationary and that persistent inflation isn't sourced anywhere else. The easiest to understand metric is a balanced budget, and it's with personal dismay that advocates of balanced budgets have vanished in the past 20 years.
I'm at a loss to guess how we get there from here. For example : the principle that governments should enforce the equality of outcomes is the midwife of more destructive spending than I care to imagine. What, two in five electors buy into that, probably more?
My inner pessimist concludes that a hard rain's gonna fall before people are disabused of that notion, and recalling Winston Churchill's quixotic return to the gold standard in 1925, I doubt the creation of a gold backed currency will be a ,erm, silver bullet that will finesse what's to come.
Pretty big assumption he’s making, and I know von Mises wrote it in 1953, but we have no proof Treasury has the 8000 tons we are told it has. Physically probably most of it is there, hopefully but I think Bessent whispered in Trump’s ear to drop the Ft Knox inspection because he knows that although there is gold there it has been re-hypothecated so many times it would crash the market trying to undo it.
Another relevant note is that recently the LBMA has struggled to deliver gold on demand. They were allowed to operate on the fractional reserve model and have severely underestimated the amount of "paper" gold ( futures, options, ETFs, etc.) traded. I have no doubt that, even if the gold is in Fort Knox, the government, if forced to return to the gold standard, would probably use the same type of model. Much like the LBMA, the Federal government would never expect the possibility of an actual redemption run. Then, it's back to square one, FDR's Executive Order 6102.
Mike, you would never be happy with an inspection of the Fort Knox gold. You want all gold to be viewed and inspected personally by YOU. You and hundreds of thousands of gold buggers would want to physically saw each 100lb gold bar in half to inspect it personally.
All the President needs to do, is to announce that America is creating a new currency based on gold at $25,000.00 an ounce. He will attempt to please the gold-doubters by having cursory inspections on all US gold vaults. He will then announce that the US Government will purchase 75% of all Gold produced in America directly from mines/producers at the current price and add it to the treasury. This will effectively make the US Treasury a gold royalty company. Each dollar backed by gold will effectively be 1 dollar of US Treasury stock. Good as gold.
Now as for the $38 trillion of debt. Al Gore can be brought out of retirement and put all debt into a LOCK BOX. Arrange a payment plan to pay the 38 trillion dollars of debt in installments over 100 years
This is not any more outlandish than accruing 38 trillion dollars in debt in the first place.
Bankers are oily beings and I am sure they can fine-tune this idea that will make themselves wealthy to boot.
I don't think returning the Dollar to the gold standard is possible right now. But to move in that direction, the federal government should be required to spend no more than the revenue it takes in every year. Congress must pass legislation for a balanced budget to begin the process. The second issue is the continued existence of the Federal Reserve. The Fed's existing charter would make it useless if they are limited in the amount of Dollars they can create. But there is little hope that is going to happen unless a major, catastrophic event takes place in America.
I was going to rage against the machine but remembered Marcus Aurelius' note to himself "I am under no obligation to have an opinion on something I don't understand fully" or words to that effect. So while I continue to be horrified at what our species inflicts upon itself time and time again, at this moment I'm going to take the ladder instead of the snake, and go topside for a walk in whatever GOD (Great OutDoors) has prepared for me.
I like the Roman reference. Here is what the "gold standard" would be up against even today . . . eventually anyway:
Debasement of Roman Coinage
The debasement of Roman coinage was a systematic process that began in the mid-1st century AD, under the reign of Emperor Nero. The silver content of the denarius was gradually reduced, from approximately 95% silver at the beginning of the first century AD to around 70% by the mid-2nd century AD. This process accelerated during the Third Century Crisis, leading to a denarius that contained only about 0.02% silver by the end of the 3rd century AD. The debasement was not only a financial decision but also a tool of deceit, as the coins were silvered to give them the appearance of high-quality silver, masking their diminished value. The debasement had profound implications for society and the economy, leading to rampant inflation, destabilized trade, and diminished credibility in the Roman currency.
Why do gold bugs and Mises Freaks always make this claim?
"The purchasing power of the US dollar has been debased by over 99 percent since the foundation of the Federal Reserve. (An ounce of gold cost $20.67 in 1913. "
That's nonsense. "debasement" in that sense is just adding zeros to all prices. You could divide all prices by "some number" and re-base them back using arithmetic. It's like saying temperatures have risen if they're measured in Farenheit but everything is cool in Celsisus -- so we don't need air conditioning, all we need if we're too hot is a Celsius standard.
I mean really. Oy Vey, it's an apocalypse of reasoning. We need an analytical gold standard for monetary philosophy bloviations.
The political pressure would eventually become too hard to manage, just like in the William Jennings Bryan speech in 1896. A gold standard would restrain the kind of spending we all complain about -- I agree. And the Roman example isn't 100% instructive because you can't debase paper or digital currency the way you could coins. But the issue isn't -- at least in my view based on history -- the restraining structure whether a gold standard or an "independent Fed" (even though it really isn't). In an elected representative democracy/republic it seems to me "the people" will always find a way to express an inflationist urge -- since it does spur credit and lending.
it seems to me this is the inherent tension in any ownership based society -- whether ancient Rome or us today -- there is always a division of wealth, always wealth inequality, always a tension between the sense of equality as citizens vs. inequality in the wealth sphere, always a political pressure by the have-not (who do have political voice in various politicians -- the "populists" across time and place). The people always will find away to "debase" no matter the system. Or they revolt. And sometimes the debase AND revolt.
The gold standard may be a better bulwark than now, I don't disagree, but it is by definition a political creation. As a form of politics it's subject to the rule of politics not the rules of economics. Politics >> Economics.
There have been periods of stability on the gold standard, to be sure. But they were politically different. Much more rigid class systems (like England) which hasn't had a revolution since 1680s.
It's not so simple in my view anyway, to surgically separate restraint mechanisms from the political/social culture they arose from.
Mises and the Germans were always different. And it carried all the way to how the Bundesbank operated. The Weimar was always an object lesson. yes it abanoned the gold standard in WW1. Yes, and look what happened. It's an argument for the gold standard but it's also an argument for the impossibility of maintaining a gold standard in the face of politics.
A return to the gold standard remains the clear way to stop the Federal government's continual habit of excessive funding. "Those boys north of Richmond" would not wield the power to surreptitiously steal value away from American citizens through their ever increasing love of printing "dollars", backed only by, "faith in the system". Therefore, I won't hold my breath waiting for it to happen, after all, politicians think they know how to spend your value better than you could ever understand.
I see a possible mitigating factor in all this mess: The US gov't spends some time acquiring every gold mine all over the world, every gold processing plant, then builds the largest inventory possible. THEN, drops the dime on the dollar. Only such outright totalitarian methods would reduce the effect.
China is doing that right now. They just purchased Allied Gold in Canada. America has so much gold in the ground that we can do that in our country alone.
Thought experiment: If we adopt Mises' strategy and peg the dollar to gold with no wartime exceptions, would that not limit our ability to defend ourselves against a powerful adversary, and would it not be an invitation for an adversary to take advantage of that Achilles' heel?
A perfectly valid point. The timing is the issue. I’m not sure that the US can do that while the rest of the world and especially China can continue to print. I’m not prepared to go beyond that until ALL of the ramifications are illuminated and understood.
I suppose it's a measure of our present predicament that gold's role as a monetary metal was hotly debated during the first years of the Great Depression. From 1931 :
"The delegation has admitted the likelihood of a gold shortage and has proposed means of maintaining an adequate supply of credit expansion in the face of inadequate gold supplies."
https://chicagotribune.newspapers.com/article/chicago-tribune-the-problem-with-gold-as/122119688/
Economies grow. The transaction demand for money always increases. The supply of gold is fixed and inelastic. Debasement is inevitable.
Unless we're all up for deflation, which is worse.
Gold is a scorecard for how well we are allocating scarce resources to productive ends.
When we sent 600,000 soldiers to a land war in Asia and flew to the moon at the same time, gold noticed. When we swamped the nation in subsidies to weather a non-existent
plague while handing untold billions to chronically unproductive third worlders who are in the country illegally, gold noticed that, too.
But what gold is not is money, not in the practical sense that we need money.
Public policy should aim at ameliorating the inevitable. That is, if we accept that we are stuck with a fiat system that is inherently inflationary, then :
1) The Fed should abandon a dual mandate and target a 2% inflation rate only.
2) Recognizing that most of what governments do is inflationary and that persistent inflation isn't sourced anywhere else. The easiest to understand metric is a balanced budget, and it's with personal dismay that advocates of balanced budgets have vanished in the past 20 years.
I'm at a loss to guess how we get there from here. For example : the principle that governments should enforce the equality of outcomes is the midwife of more destructive spending than I care to imagine. What, two in five electors buy into that, probably more?
My inner pessimist concludes that a hard rain's gonna fall before people are disabused of that notion, and recalling Winston Churchill's quixotic return to the gold standard in 1925, I doubt the creation of a gold backed currency will be a ,erm, silver bullet that will finesse what's to come.
Pretty big assumption he’s making, and I know von Mises wrote it in 1953, but we have no proof Treasury has the 8000 tons we are told it has. Physically probably most of it is there, hopefully but I think Bessent whispered in Trump’s ear to drop the Ft Knox inspection because he knows that although there is gold there it has been re-hypothecated so many times it would crash the market trying to undo it.
Another relevant note is that recently the LBMA has struggled to deliver gold on demand. They were allowed to operate on the fractional reserve model and have severely underestimated the amount of "paper" gold ( futures, options, ETFs, etc.) traded. I have no doubt that, even if the gold is in Fort Knox, the government, if forced to return to the gold standard, would probably use the same type of model. Much like the LBMA, the Federal government would never expect the possibility of an actual redemption run. Then, it's back to square one, FDR's Executive Order 6102.
Mike, you would never be happy with an inspection of the Fort Knox gold. You want all gold to be viewed and inspected personally by YOU. You and hundreds of thousands of gold buggers would want to physically saw each 100lb gold bar in half to inspect it personally.
All the President needs to do, is to announce that America is creating a new currency based on gold at $25,000.00 an ounce. He will attempt to please the gold-doubters by having cursory inspections on all US gold vaults. He will then announce that the US Government will purchase 75% of all Gold produced in America directly from mines/producers at the current price and add it to the treasury. This will effectively make the US Treasury a gold royalty company. Each dollar backed by gold will effectively be 1 dollar of US Treasury stock. Good as gold.
Now as for the $38 trillion of debt. Al Gore can be brought out of retirement and put all debt into a LOCK BOX. Arrange a payment plan to pay the 38 trillion dollars of debt in installments over 100 years
This is not any more outlandish than accruing 38 trillion dollars in debt in the first place.
Bankers are oily beings and I am sure they can fine-tune this idea that will make themselves wealthy to boot.
yup!
The problem is our government is too fucking stupid to realize there is a problem.
There might be a handful members of congress that actually get it, have the majority (both sides) are corrupt OR retarded.
The fraudulent democrats are out of control.
I don't think returning the Dollar to the gold standard is possible right now. But to move in that direction, the federal government should be required to spend no more than the revenue it takes in every year. Congress must pass legislation for a balanced budget to begin the process. The second issue is the continued existence of the Federal Reserve. The Fed's existing charter would make it useless if they are limited in the amount of Dollars they can create. But there is little hope that is going to happen unless a major, catastrophic event takes place in America.
That ship has sailed.
You’d have to go to LITERAL war with those in control of the current financial system.
uuuuh, yep!
I was going to rage against the machine but remembered Marcus Aurelius' note to himself "I am under no obligation to have an opinion on something I don't understand fully" or words to that effect. So while I continue to be horrified at what our species inflicts upon itself time and time again, at this moment I'm going to take the ladder instead of the snake, and go topside for a walk in whatever GOD (Great OutDoors) has prepared for me.
I like the Roman reference. Here is what the "gold standard" would be up against even today . . . eventually anyway:
Debasement of Roman Coinage
The debasement of Roman coinage was a systematic process that began in the mid-1st century AD, under the reign of Emperor Nero. The silver content of the denarius was gradually reduced, from approximately 95% silver at the beginning of the first century AD to around 70% by the mid-2nd century AD. This process accelerated during the Third Century Crisis, leading to a denarius that contained only about 0.02% silver by the end of the 3rd century AD. The debasement was not only a financial decision but also a tool of deceit, as the coins were silvered to give them the appearance of high-quality silver, masking their diminished value. The debasement had profound implications for society and the economy, leading to rampant inflation, destabilized trade, and diminished credibility in the Roman currency.
https://www.unrv.com/economy/currency-debasement.php
Are we chatting offline? Just checking. Thanks
Why do gold bugs and Mises Freaks always make this claim?
"The purchasing power of the US dollar has been debased by over 99 percent since the foundation of the Federal Reserve. (An ounce of gold cost $20.67 in 1913. "
That's nonsense. "debasement" in that sense is just adding zeros to all prices. You could divide all prices by "some number" and re-base them back using arithmetic. It's like saying temperatures have risen if they're measured in Farenheit but everything is cool in Celsisus -- so we don't need air conditioning, all we need if we're too hot is a Celsius standard.
I mean really. Oy Vey, it's an apocalypse of reasoning. We need an analytical gold standard for monetary philosophy bloviations.
Give us an example. Thanks
The political pressure would eventually become too hard to manage, just like in the William Jennings Bryan speech in 1896. A gold standard would restrain the kind of spending we all complain about -- I agree. And the Roman example isn't 100% instructive because you can't debase paper or digital currency the way you could coins. But the issue isn't -- at least in my view based on history -- the restraining structure whether a gold standard or an "independent Fed" (even though it really isn't). In an elected representative democracy/republic it seems to me "the people" will always find a way to express an inflationist urge -- since it does spur credit and lending.
it seems to me this is the inherent tension in any ownership based society -- whether ancient Rome or us today -- there is always a division of wealth, always wealth inequality, always a tension between the sense of equality as citizens vs. inequality in the wealth sphere, always a political pressure by the have-not (who do have political voice in various politicians -- the "populists" across time and place). The people always will find away to "debase" no matter the system. Or they revolt. And sometimes the debase AND revolt.
The gold standard may be a better bulwark than now, I don't disagree, but it is by definition a political creation. As a form of politics it's subject to the rule of politics not the rules of economics. Politics >> Economics.
There have been periods of stability on the gold standard, to be sure. But they were politically different. Much more rigid class systems (like England) which hasn't had a revolution since 1680s.
It's not so simple in my view anyway, to surgically separate restraint mechanisms from the political/social culture they arose from.
Mises and the Germans were always different. And it carried all the way to how the Bundesbank operated. The Weimar was always an object lesson. yes it abanoned the gold standard in WW1. Yes, and look what happened. It's an argument for the gold standard but it's also an argument for the impossibility of maintaining a gold standard in the face of politics.
Money is complicated. :-)
Thank you.
Not going to happen. THEY don’t want stability. It’ll have to be forced by catastrophic happenings. I put myself on a silver standard
EXACTLY!
A return to the gold standard remains the clear way to stop the Federal government's continual habit of excessive funding. "Those boys north of Richmond" would not wield the power to surreptitiously steal value away from American citizens through their ever increasing love of printing "dollars", backed only by, "faith in the system". Therefore, I won't hold my breath waiting for it to happen, after all, politicians think they know how to spend your value better than you could ever understand.
I see a possible mitigating factor in all this mess: The US gov't spends some time acquiring every gold mine all over the world, every gold processing plant, then builds the largest inventory possible. THEN, drops the dime on the dollar. Only such outright totalitarian methods would reduce the effect.
OR, do I misunderstand entirely?
China is doing that right now. They just purchased Allied Gold in Canada. America has so much gold in the ground that we can do that in our country alone.
So, maybe this idea has legs?!
I think someone with a lot of dollar reserves is currently establishing a market price for gold.
Thought experiment: If we adopt Mises' strategy and peg the dollar to gold with no wartime exceptions, would that not limit our ability to defend ourselves against a powerful adversary, and would it not be an invitation for an adversary to take advantage of that Achilles' heel?
You forget rules do not apply to government and bankers, they make change rules at will.
A perfectly valid point. The timing is the issue. I’m not sure that the US can do that while the rest of the world and especially China can continue to print. I’m not prepared to go beyond that until ALL of the ramifications are illuminated and understood.